Neil Gaiman’s The Sandman has been a sacred text for fantasy readers since its debut in 1989. The TV adaptation, streaming on Netflix, takes on the sprawling mythology of Dream, the Endless, and the stories that ripple through their dominion. The result is a mixed bag of ambition and uneven execution, one that captures the spirit of the comics but struggles to hold together across its ten episodes.
Trailer, via DC.
Dream’s Captivity
The show opens with Dream being captured and imprisoned for decades, a plot point borrowed directly from the comics. That arc works best. The performances are strong, and the visual style leans into the surrealism that made the comics iconic. But the pacing suffers once Dream escapes and the series tries to juggle multiple timelines and narratives at once.
A Cast Too Large
The problem is scope. The Sandman runs ten episodes, and it wants to cover everything from Dream’s imprisonment to the rise of a new Dream, while also weaving in stories about Desire, Death, and the other Endless. That’s a lot to fit in. The result is a show that feels fragmented, with character arcs that don’t quite resolve and subplots that trail off.
“The Sandman” is ambitious and occasionally brilliant, but it’s a show that can’t decide what it wants to be.
The cast is large, and some characters feel like they’re there to fill space rather than drive the story forward. The show’s attempt to balance personal drama with cosmic stakes is a tall order across ten episodes.
The Strengths
When it commits, The Sandman shines. The scenes involving Dream’s realm of the Dreaming are visually stunning, and the performances by Kirby Howell-Baptiste as Desire and Gwendoline Christie as Death carry the emotional weight of the story. The episode centered on Dream’s imprisonment is the strongest in the series, a tight, character-driven narrative that doesn’t need to explain the whole universe.
The show also handles the darker material well, including moments of violence and death that could have felt gratuitous. It trusts the audience to sit with the discomfort, which is a mark of confidence.
The Weaknesses
The weaknesses are structural. The show’s middle stretch drags, with episodes that feel like filler rather than story. Some characters are introduced and then dropped without resolution, leaving the overall narrative feeling incomplete. The pacing is inconsistent, with some episodes moving at a crawl while others rush through significant plot points.
The adaptation also takes liberties with the source material that some fans will find jarring. The show covers many threads across ten episodes, which means it can’t spend equal time with every character or storyline.
Where It Lands
The Sandman is a worthy entry point for newcomers to the mythos, and a faithful adaptation in spirit. But it’s a flawed one. The show is ambitious, and it occasionally delivers moments of genuine brilliance. It’s a show that captures the magic of Gaiman’s creation while struggling to contain it within a single season.
The final score is 6.6 out of 10.
Get the Notebook.
The day's best stories and every fresh verdict, in plain English, in your inbox by seven. One email a day, no more.
