Hulu’s eight-part adaptation of Stephen King’s 11/22/63 begins with a door. Jake Epping, an English teacher from Lisbon, Maine, walks through it and into 1960, sent by his friend Al Templeton to stop the assassination of John F. Kennedy on November 22, 1963. The series ran from February 15 to April 4, 2016, and it carries a 6.9/10 critical score. That number is fair. The show’s problem is not its premise but its split attention.
Trailer, via Hulu.
The Diner and the Door
The mechanic is clean. Al presents Jake with a chance to travel back to 1960. Jake goes. The mission is Kennedy. The complication is Sadie Dunhill. James Franco plays Jake, Sarah Gadon plays Sadie, and Chris Cooper plays Al. The show’s best idea arrives early: Jake becomes attached to the life he builds in the past, and that attachment could undo the whole thing. That is a real engine. A man sent to fix history, undone by the fact that he likes living in it.
Franco Cast Because He Asked
The casting story is worth telling because it explains the performance. Franco read King’s novel, contacted King about the film rights, and learned J. J. Abrams already had them. Franco wrote an essay about the book for Vice. Abrams saw it. Franco tweeted his disappointment at losing the rights, and Bridget Carpenter saw that. They offered him the lead. He took it on the condition that he could direct part of the series. Carpenter developed the show and executive produced with Abrams, King, and Bryan Burk.
So Franco is not a hired face. He is a fan who pushed his way in, and that shows in the performance — for better and worse. He is loose and game and never boring. He is also frequently too light for a story about a man watching a president’s murder approach. The show needs dread and Franco supplies charm, and the mismatch never resolves.
Oswald, Marina, and the Cost of Watching
Daniel Webber plays Lee Harvey Oswald, Lucy Fry plays Marina Oswald, and George MacKay plays Bill Turcotte. The Oswald material is the show’s strongest thread because it is the most concrete. Jake has to gather information about the people and events leading up to the assassination while maintaining a new life and avoiding suspicion. That double duty is where the series earns its eight episodes. The plot does not need a villain. It needs a man trying to be ordinary in a decade that is about to become a headline.
The show’s genre tags — Drama, Sci-Fi & Fantasy — undersell what it is actually doing. This is a thriller built on a moral trap. Every day Jake spends in 1960 is a day he is not stopping anything. Every person he loves is a person he will have to leave, or a person who will keep him from leaving. The show understands this. It just does not always trust it, and it reaches for incident when it should sit still.
What the Eight Episodes Get Right
The premise is the reason to watch. A time traveler who becomes attached to the life he makes in the past is a better story than a time traveler who simply fails or succeeds. The series was received positively by critics, and the 6.9/10 reflects a show that is good without being essential.
Where 11/22/63 falls short is in the middle. Eight episodes is the right length for this material, and the show still pads. The Oswald scenes hold. The Sadie scenes hold. The connective tissue between them sags, and the show’s tone wobbles between period romance and political thriller without committing to either.
The Kennedy assassination is the most overworked event in American fiction, and 11/22/63 does not add a new theory. It adds a new cost. The question is not whether Jake can stop it. The question is what stopping it would cost him, and whether a man is allowed to want a life that history has already spent. That is the part worth watching. The rest is a well-made vehicle for a question the show only half answers.
Key facts
– Score: 6.9/10 (Metacritic 69/100)
– Network: Hulu
– Episodes: 8, one season
– First aired: February 15, 2016
– Last aired: April 4, 2016
– Based on: 11/22/63 by Stephen King (2011)
– Developed by: Bridget Carpenter
– Starring: James Franco, Sarah Gadon, Chris Cooper, Daniel Webber, Lucy Fry, George MacKay
Get the Notebook.
The day's best stories and every fresh verdict, in plain English, in your inbox by seven. One email a day, no more.