“New Girl” ran for seven seasons on Fox, from September 20, 2011, to May 15, 2018. It was created by Elizabeth Meriwether, produced by 20th Century Fox Television, and built around Zooey Deschanel as Jessica Day, a teacher who moves into a Los Angeles loft with three men after a bad breakup. The pilot drew 10.28 million U.S. viewers and a 4.8 rating in the adults 18–49 demo — the highest-rated fall debut for a Fox scripted show since 2001.
Trailer, via TV Promos.
Jess Day and the Craigslist Loft
The setup is a sitcom engine that works. Jess comes home from vacation, finds her boyfriend Spencer with another woman, and answers a roommate ad on Craigslist. She lands with Nick Miller, Schmidt, and Coach. Coach leaves after the pilot, replaced by Winston Bishop, Nick’s childhood friend, back from the Latvian Basketball League.
Meriwether wanted a lead who would be the side character on any other show. That is the show’s real bet, and it pays off more often than not. Jess is not written as the wife character who gets ignored while the men run the room.
Deschanel became a producer and helped build Jess, specifically asking to keep her out of that trap. Meriwether said the character started as a version of herself and later became a hybrid of the two of them and the writers.
Nick Miller, Schmidt, Winston Bishop
The ensemble is the reason to stay. Jake Johnson’s Nick tends bar and starts the series stuck on a breakup with Caroline. Max Greenfield’s Schmidt is a marketing associate in a female-dominated office, a ladies’ man in his own head. Lamorne Morris plays Winston as a former basketball player who becomes a cop, close to his cat Furguson.
Hannah Simone’s Cece is a fashion model and Jess’s best friend since childhood, skeptical of the roommates before she becomes tangled up with them.
The show pairs comedy with drama, and the characters in their late twenties and early thirties mostly circle relationship problems and career choices. That is the whole machine. It is a single-camera ensemble comedy aimed at a general audience, and it knows it.
Cece and Schmidt, Nick and Jess
The romantic plotting is where “New Girl” gets its longest mileage and its worst habits. Schmidt and Cece start a mostly sexual relationship midway through season 1, break up at the end of it, and later reconcile, marry, and have a child named Ruth. Cece nearly goes through with an arranged marriage to Shivrang in the season 2 finale before calling it off because she loves Schmidt.
Nick and Jess start dating at that same wedding, stay together through most of season 3, then split when they decide they want different things. They end up together and engaged in the final season.
The show combines comedy and drama elements as the characters, who are in their late 20s and early 30s, mostly revolve around relationship issues and career choices.
The Netflix Effect
“New Girl” was named one of the best new comedies of the 2011 fall season, and it drew particular praise for Deschanel, Johnson, Greenfield, Morris, and Simone. Then it found a second life on Netflix, becoming one of the most popular shows on the platform and pulling in mainstream viewers years after it started.
That second life matters more than the premiere numbers. A broadcast sitcom that gets rediscovered on streaming is a different kind of success than one that peaks in week one.
What the Premiere Numbers Prove
The 10.28 million viewers and the 4.8 demo rating are real, and so is the distinction of the highest-rated fall debut for a Fox scripted show since 2001. They are also the least interesting thing about the show’s run. A big premiere measures the marketing, not the writing. What kept “New Girl” alive for 146 episodes was the room, not the launch.
Where the Show Slips
The on-and-off structure wears thin. Nick and Jess date, break up, and circle back. Schmidt and Cece do the same, with a cheating plot wedged in. Coach returns in season 3, has a short fling with Cece, and stays through season 4. These are the moves of a show protecting a status quo it does not want to lose.
The cast keeps it watchable. Greenfield gets the biggest swings and Morris gets the strangest ones. Johnson plays a mess without asking for sympathy.
The Verdict on New Girl
“New Girl” is a good sitcom with a great central performance and a bad habit of stalling its own romances. Seven seasons and 146 episodes is a long run for a show that spent so much of it resetting the same two couples. The first three seasons are the argument for it. The later ones are the argument for ending earlier.
The streaming revival is the part worth noting. A show that critics liked in 2011 became a show that a much larger audience found years later, and that is a stranger and more durable legacy than the pilot rating ever suggested.
Get the Notebook.
The day's best stories and every fresh verdict, in plain English, in your inbox by seven. One email a day, no more.