Netflix’s gamble was simple: take four separate Marvel shows, put their leads in one room, and hope the sum beat the parts. Marvel’s The Defenders ran that experiment for eight episodes, all released on August 18, 2017.
Trailer, via Netflix Malaysia.
Four Heroes, One Conspiracy in New York City
The premise is laid out in the synopsis: Daredevil, Jessica Jones, Luke Cage and Iron Fist join forces to take on common enemies as a sinister conspiracy threatens New York City. That is the whole architecture. Four street-level heroes, each with a solo series behind them, pulled into a single threat.
Douglas Petrie and Marco Ramirez created the series for Netflix. One season, eight episodes, first and last aired the same day.
The cast is the draw, and it is a real one. Charlie Cox returns as Matt Murdock / Daredevil. Krysten Ritter returns as Jessica Jones. Mike Colter returns as Luke Cage. Finn Jones returns as Danny Rand / Iron Fist. Élodie Yung returns as Elektra Natchios.
- Title: Marvel’s The Defenders
- Created by: Douglas Petrie, Marco Ramirez
- Network: Netflix
- Season: 1, eight episodes
- First and last aired: 2017-08-18
- Genres: Sci-Fi & Fantasy, Action & Adventure, Crime
- TMDB audience score: 7.0/10 (1,721 votes)
| Episode | Air date | Release |
|---|---|---|
| Season 1, Episodes 1–8 | 2017-08-18 | All episodes released at once |
A Cast Built From Four Shows
That list is the argument for the series existing. Four leads who each carried their own show, plus Yung’s Elektra, is a lot of screen presence in one frame. The genres tell you what to expect: Sci-Fi & Fantasy, Action & Adventure, Crime. The show sits in all three lanes at once.
The problem is structural, and it is not the actors’ fault. Eight episodes is not much time to give four leads a shared story and keep each of them in character. Matt Murdock’s guilt, Jessica Jones’s refusal of heroism, Luke Cage’s neighborhood politics, Danny Rand’s mysticism — these are different registers. The Defenders has to flatten them into one.
The Team-Up Tax
Flattening is exactly what happens. The show’s best idea is the collision itself, and its worst habit is treating that collision as enough. When the four are in a room together, the friction is the entertainment. When the plot takes over, the friction goes away and the thing turns generic.
The conspiracy is the engine. The source describes it as sinister, and that is all it says. It gives the heroes a common enemy. It does not give them much to disagree about once they do.
Yung’s Elektra is the piece that cuts against the grain. The source gives her a name and nothing else. The show does not always use what she brings.
What the Score Says
The published audience score sits at 7.0/10 from 1,721 votes on TMDB. That is a fair read on what this is: competent, watchable, and short of what four shows’ worth of setup promised. It is not a disaster and it is not a triumph. It is a competent crossover that clears its own bar.
The 7.0 lands where it should. Fans of any one of the four leads get a version of that lead. Fans of all four get a team that never quite becomes more than the sum of its parts.
The eight-episode order is the constraint that explains most of it.
The Verdict on Marvel’s The Defenders
Here is what matters. Marvel’s The Defenders is a crossover that delivers the meeting and undersells the aftermath. The four leads are the reason to watch. What the show never solves is the question of why these four, specifically, need each other.
The answer the show offers is the conspiracy. That is not an answer. It is a premise.
The score of 7.0/10 is the right one. It credits the cast, the scale, and the fact that eight episodes of four heroes sharing a screen is not nothing. It also docks the show for a story that treats the team-up as the destination rather than the beginning. The Defenders is worth the eight episodes. It is not worth expecting more than that.
Get the Notebook.
The day's best stories and every fresh verdict, in plain English, in your inbox by seven. One email a day, no more.