Dexter Morgan is alive, sober, and selling camping gear in upstate New York. That is the hook Showtime built Dexter: New Blood on, and for a while it works.
The 10-episode miniseries, developed by Clyde Phillips, ran from November 7, 2021, to January 9, 2022. It picks up a decade after the original Dexter finale, “Remember the Monsters?”, which aired in 2013. Michael C. Hall returns as Dexter, now calling himself Jim Lindsay and working as a clerk at a wilderness sporting goods store in the fictional town of Iron Lake.
Trailer, via Paramount Plus Nordic.
Jim Lindsay and the Life He Built
Dexter faked his death in a hurricane and started over. He has a girlfriend, Angela Bishop, who happens to be the town’s chief of police. He has suppressed the urge to kill. He talks to his dead sister, Debra, who appears as an imaginary presence — Jennifer Carpenter reprising the role she played across the original series’ eight seasons.
That arrangement is the show’s best idea. A man with a body count living quietly among people who trust him is a premise that writes itself, and New Blood knows it. The early episodes trade on the gap between Jim Lindsay’s mild manners and what the audience knows he is.
Then Harrison shows up.
Harrison Morgan Arrives Unannounced
Jack Alcott plays Harrison Morgan, Dexter’s estranged son, who appears in the first episode with motives the show keeps deliberately unclear. A string of incidents around Iron Lake follows, and Dexter starts to fear that his “Dark Passenger” — and possibly his son’s — will surface.
The casting around Hall is solid. Julia Jones plays Angela Bishop, Johnny Sequoyah plays her daughter Audrey, Alano Miller plays Logan, and Clancy Brown plays Kurt Caldwell. John Lithgow returns in a cameo as Arthur Mitchell, the Trinity Killer, a nod to the original series’ most memorable villain.
- Michael C. Hall as Dexter Morgan
- Jack Alcott as Harrison Morgan
- Julia Jones as Angela Bishop
- Johnny Sequoyah as Audrey Bishop
- Alano Miller as Logan
- Clancy Brown as Kurt Caldwell
- Jennifer Carpenter as Debra Morgan
A Prequel, a Sequel, and What Came After
Showtime did not treat this as a one-off. Dexter: Original Sin followed in 2024, a prequel series with a frame story that picks up from New Blood‘s final scene. A sequel series, Dexter: Resurrection, is also in the works.
That is a lot of franchise machinery built on a miniseries that never quite earns its own ending. The show spends its middle stretch on Iron Lake’s small-town secrets, and the mystery plotting is competent without being distinctive. Clancy Brown is a reliable heavy, but Kurt Caldwell never becomes the kind of antagonist Lithgow’s Trinity Killer was. The season’s tension comes almost entirely from Hall, who plays restraint better than most actors play rage.
Where the Revival Lands
The revival’s real subject is whether a man can choose to stop being what he is. New Blood asks that question directly, through Harrison, and then answers it in a way that will divide the people who stuck with Dexter Morgan through eight seasons and a widely disliked finale.
The show’s problem is that it wants credit for a clean break while keeping every option open. It brings back Debra as a conscience, brings back the Trinity Killer as a ghost from the past, and sets up two more series. A story about a man finally facing consequences keeps hedging on whether he should face any.
That hedging is why the score lands where it does. Hall is the reason to watch. The premise is the reason to start. The ending is the reason a lot of viewers will argue about it for years, which is not the same thing as the reason it works.
Metacritic put Dexter: New Blood at 61 out of 100, a 6.1/10. That feels right. It is a better revival than the original finale deserved, and a less complete one than the character deserved. Hall’s return is worth the ticket. The rest is a setup for something the show never commits to being.
Get the Notebook.
The day's best stories and every fresh verdict, in plain English, in your inbox by seven. One email a day, no more.