WRITTEN IN PLAIN AMERICAN ENGLISH.
About
CLAY TRIBUNE.
ShopCartAccount
Advertisement

Top Gun Review: Planes, Romance, and No Depth

A review of Top Gun, a shallow, entertaining film trading depth for style, with a hollow romance and a spectacle of aerial combat.

By mitch·3 min read
A fighter jet flies perilously close to the sun amid a fiery orange sky.

Top Gun is a movie about young pilots who fly fast planes and look cool doing it. That is the whole idea. There is no plot beyond that. Two young men compete to be the best pilot in the air force, fall for the same woman, and win a contest at the end. The film spends most of its runtime showing planes flying through the sky, with little concern for why anyone cares.

Trailer, via Paramount Movies.

Icarus Syndrome

The film borrows heavily from the Greek myth of Icarus, a boy who flies too close to the sun and falls to his death. In Top Gun, the pilots fly dangerously close to the sun, and the film celebrates that danger instead of warning against it.

Advertisement

The Romance

The love story between the two leads is thin. They fight over a woman, she chooses one of them, and the other moves on. None of it feels earned. The film expects the audience to care because the actors are handsome, not because the relationship has any substance.

The Music

The soundtrack features Kenny Loggins singing “Danger Zone” and Berlin performing “Take My Breath Away.” These songs became hits on their own, far outshining the film itself. The music is better than the story it accompanies.

The Action

The dogfight scenes are technically impressive. Planes move fast, turn sharply, and explode with satisfying effect. But the action serves the spectacle, not the characters. We watch planes crash because the film wants us to see planes crash, not because we care about the pilots inside them.

The Message

Top Gun is a celebration of American masculinity and military power. It treats war as a game, fought by young men who are rewarded for being brave and attractive. There is no moral weight to any of it.

The Reception

Critics have long noted that Top Gun is a shallow, entertaining film that trades depth for style. The movie knows exactly what it is and does not pretend otherwise. That honesty is part of its appeal.

The Legacy

The film launched a franchise, a sequel, and a reboot. Its influence on popular culture is undeniable. But none of that changes what is on screen.

Scene Length
Opening credits 5 minutes
Dogfight montage 10 minutes
Romance scenes 15 minutes
Closing credits 3 minutes
  • The lead actor delivers a performance that critics have described as wooden
  • The film’s dialogue is often spoken at a high volume, as if shouting were a substitute for wit
  • The final scene, where the winner is announced, feels rushed and anticlimactic after everything that came before it

Top Gun is a fun movie to watch once. It is not a film that rewards repeat viewing. It is a product of its era, made to sell tickets and posters, not to tell a story with lasting meaning.

The Notebook

Get the Notebook.

The day's best stories and every fresh verdict, in plain English, in your inbox by seven. One email a day, no more.

We send one note to confirm. Every issue has a one-click way out.

Film reviews
Advertisement

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

As an Amazon Associate, Clay Tribune earns from qualifying purchases.