Phil Connors is a Pittsburgh weatherman who hates Punxsutawney, hates the groundhog, and hates the people he calls hicks. Then a blizzard he swore would miss Western Pennsylvania strands him there. He wakes up the next morning to “I Got You Babe” on the clock radio at the Cherry Street Inn. He wakes up to it again the morning after that. And again.
Groundhog Day is Harold Ramis’s 1993 fantasy romantic comedy, written by Ramis and Danny Rubin, and it turns that one joke into 101 minutes of the strangest mainstream comedy of its decade. Bill Murray plays Phil. Andie MacDowell plays Rita Hanson, his producer. Chris Elliott plays Larry, his cameraman. The premise is a time loop, and the film never explains it, which is the right call.
Trailer, via Sony Pics at Home Canada.
A weatherman stuck on February 2
Phil travels to Punxsutawney for his annual coverage of the Groundhog Day festivities. He gives a half-hearted report on Punxsutawney Phil. The blizzard hits anyway. He tries to leave, fails, and spends the night. Every following morning resets him to February 2, and nobody else notices.
He tells Rita. She sends him to a neurologist, who sends him to a psychologist. Neither can explain anything. He gets drunk with locals Gus and Ralph, leads police on a high-speed car chase, and lands in jail. The next morning he is back at the Cherry Street Inn.
Once Phil works out that nothing he does carries a consequence, the film shifts. He binge eats. He sleeps with women he barely knows. He robs. He uses what he has learned about the day to get away with all of it.
Murray wanted philosophy, Ramis wanted jokes
The making of Groundhog Day was not smooth, and the friction is worth naming because it shaped the finished film. Murray and Ramis had worked together since 1974, across five films, including Meatballs, Caddyshack and Ghostbusters. On this one they clashed over the script. Murray wanted the philosophical elements. Ramis pushed the comedy.
Rubin had written it as a spec script in the early 1990s to get meetings for other work. His version was darker. Ramis worked with him to soften the tone and make it palatable to a general audience.
The casting history is its own comedy:
- Tom Hanks was Ramis’s first choice for Phil, and turned it down, reasoning that he was typecast as nice people and audiences would expect his inevitable redemption.
- Michael Keaton passed because he did not understand the film, and later said he regretted it.
- Chevy Chase was also considered.
- Rubin wanted Kevin Kline, believing Murray lacked the acting ability for the part.
Ramis overruled him. “Don’t worry. This is what Bill Murray can do. He can be that nasty and still make you like him,” Ramis told Rubin. MacDowell agreed: “He’s a jerk but he makes you laugh.”
That is the whole engine. Phil is cynical, sarcastic and detached, and the film keeps him just short of malicious so you stay with him. Rubin had not written Phil as especially nasty — he wanted a normal person in an extranormal situation. Murray made him worse, and better.
Woodstock, Illinois, and a cold shoot
Principal photography ran from March to June 1992, almost entirely in Woodstock, Illinois. Filming was difficult. The weather was bitterly cold. The Ramis-Murray conflict continued through it.
The supporting cast does real work in small rooms. Stephen Tobolowsky is Ned Ryerson, the insurance man Phil cannot escape. Brian Doyle-Murray is Buster Green. Marita Geraghty is Nancy Taylor. Angela Paton is Mrs. Lancaster. Rick Ducommun and Rick Overton are Gus and Ralph. Robin Duke is Doris the waitress. Ramis himself cameos as the neurologist. Punxsutawney Phil is played by a groundhog named Scooter.
The film premiered at the Fox Village Theatre on February 4, 1993, and Columbia Pictures released it on February 12. It earned over $105 million and became one of the year’s highest-grossing films.
What actually holds up
The loop is a gimmick, and gimmicks date. What does not date is the structure underneath it. Phil’s arc is not about escaping February 2. It is about the fact that he only becomes worth watching once he stops treating the day as a thing to survive and starts treating it as a thing to fill. The film never says this out loud. It does not need to.
The weaknesses are real. Rita is underwritten. She exists to offer human warmth and intelligence, and MacDowell delivers both, but the script gives her little to do besides be the reason Phil improves. The third act leans on montage where the first two acts lean on Murray’s face. And the comedy and the philosophy never fully merge — you can feel the two men pulling in different directions in the edit.
But the pull is productive. A version of Groundhog Day that was only philosophy would be a thesis. A version that was only comedy would be a sketch stretched past its limit. What shipped is neither, and the tension is why people still argue about it three decades on.
Murray is the reason it works. He plays Phil as a man who is genuinely unpleasant and genuinely funny, and he never asks you to forgive him early. When the change comes, it comes from behavior, not from a speech. That is a harder trick than it looks, and Ramis was right that Murray could do it.
Groundhog Day is not a perfect film. It is a very good one with a great premise, a great lead performance, and a supporting cast that knows exactly how much space to take. It earns its reputation.
Get the Notebook.
The day's best stories and every fresh verdict, in plain English, in your inbox by seven. One email a day, no more.
