Shrek Forever After opens with a contract nobody asked for. Rumpelstiltskin, an imp with a grudge, once tried to trade King Harold and Queen Lillian a magic deal for the Kingdom of Far Far Away. The deal collapsed the moment a messenger announced that Shrek had rescued Fiona from the Dragon’s Keep. Rumpel has been waiting for payback ever since.
Trailer, via Universal Kids.
A Birthday Party Ends in a Rage
The fourth film in the Shrek franchise, released by Paramount Pictures in the United States on May 21, 2010, follows a domesticated Shrek. He is a husband, a father, and a local celebrity in Far Far Away. He is also miserable. The tagline promises that “It ain’t ogre… til it’s ogre,” and the story takes that threat literally.
At his children’s first birthday party, a run of mishaps pushes Shrek into a rage. He storms out and lashes out at Fiona. Rumpel, who saw the outburst, follows him into the forest and stages a scene of distress so Shrek will stop and help. Inside Rumpel’s carriage, Shrek says he is no longer a “real ogre.”
That line is the engine of the whole movie. Rumpel offers him one day as a “real ogre” in exchange for one day from his childhood being erased. Shrek signs. He is whisked into an alternate reality where he is feared by villagers again, and where nothing else is right.
Rumpelstiltskin Takes the Throne
The twist is blunt. Rumpel erased the day Shrek was born. Shrek never existed in this timeline, so Harold and Lillian signed the contract, disappeared, and Rumpel took the throne. Far Far Away is now a dystopian kingdom where ogres are enslaved and Fiona is a fugitive. Shrek’s swamp sits deserted and desolate.
Worse, the clock is running. When the day ends, Shrek ceases to exist. He has to restore his world and reclaim Fiona, whom he has never met in this version of events.
Mike Myers, Eddie Murphy, Cameron Diaz, Antonio Banderas, Julie Andrews, and John Cleese all return to their voice roles. Walt Dohrn joins the cast as Rumpelstiltskin, and also voices the Priest and Krekraw Ogre. Jon Hamm voices Brogan. Jane Lynch voices Gretched. Craig Robinson voices Cookie. Lake Bell and Kathy Griffin voice the patrol and wagon witches.
The Alternate Far Far Away Works Best
The best idea in Shrek Forever After is the one it cannot stop explaining. A Shrek who was never born is a clean premise: it strips the hero of his family, his fame, and his own history in a single stroke. Rumpel as a petty, contract-obsessed king is a sharper villain than the franchise had managed in years, and Dohrn’s performance gives the imp a wheedling menace that fits the material.
The film also knows what it is doing with Fiona. Making her a fugitive who has never met Shrek resets the love story without pretending the first three movies did not happen. When Shrek sets out to reclaim her, the movie is working with real stakes rather than another rescue mission.
But the execution sags. The alternate Far Far Away is drawn in broad strokes: witches, cages, a hunted underclass. The film keeps telling us the world is a nightmare without letting the nightmare breathe. The middle stretch runs on chases and captures, and the emotional beats arrive on schedule rather than with force.
A Fourth Film Meant to Be the Last
Shrek Forever After was intended to be the final film in the series. It premiered at the Tribeca Film Festival on April 21, 2010, and ran 93 minutes. It grossed $756 million and finished as the fifth-highest-grossing film of 2010. It also drew mixed reviews.
Those numbers tell a story the movie itself does not. A $756 million gross for a fourth installment is a machine still running at full speed, but the mixed reception is the sound of a formula hitting its limit. The premise of Shrek Forever After is a midlife crisis, and the film never quite decides whether it wants to satirize that or resolve it. The result sits between the two.
It did not stay final. Shrek 5 was announced in 2024 and is slated for release on June 30, 2027. Two spin-offs, Puss in Boots in 2011 and Puss in Boots: The Last Wish in 2022, have already been released, and a Donkey spin-off is in development. The franchise outlived its own ending.
The Contract and the Clock
The film’s central mechanic is a contract, and contracts are only as good as their terms. Shrek trades a day he never thinks about for a day he cannot get back. That is a clean, cruel bargain, and the movie gets real mileage out of it before the chase scenes take over.
What holds Shrek Forever After back is not ambition. It is follow-through. The film has a strong villain, a strong reset, and a strong clock, then spends its second half on captures and escapes that do not add to any of them. Rumpel’s kingdom should feel like a nightmare version of everything Shrek built. It mostly feels like a set.
The voice cast remains the franchise’s most reliable asset. Murphy’s Donkey and Banderas’s Puss in Boots are underused here, but they land when they appear. Andrews and Cleese give the vanished king and queen a weight the script does not always earn. Dohrn is the standout, and the film knows it.
Numbers Behind Shrek Forever After
- Release: May 21, 2010, in the United States, by Paramount Pictures
- Premiere: Tribeca Film Festival, April 21, 2010
- Runtime: 93 minutes
- Gross: $756 million, fifth-highest-grossing film of 2010
- Directed by: Mike Mitchell
- Written by: Josh Klausner, Darren Lemke
- Score: 5.8/10
What the Fourth Shrek Leaves Behind
Shrek Forever After is a farewell that does not want to leave. It gives its hero a genuine crisis, a genuine bargain, and a genuine cost, then blunts all three with a third act that prefers motion to consequence. The alternate Far Far Away is the most interesting place the franchise ever built, and the film barely lives in it.
Still, the premise earns its keep. A Shrek who never existed, a Fiona who never met him, and an imp who finally got his contract signed: that is a better final chapter than Shrek the Third suggested the series could produce. It is just not the one the film fully delivers.
The score is 5.8 of 10.
Get the Notebook.
The day's best stories and every fresh verdict, in plain English, in your inbox by seven. One email a day, no more.
