Easy A arrived in 2010 with a premise that should not have worked: a high schooler lies about losing her virginity, and the lie swallows her whole. Will Gluck directed it. Bert V. Royal wrote it. Emma Stone plays Olive Penderghast, and the film runs 93 minutes. It grossed $75 million worldwide against an $8 million budget. It is a comedy that pays for its jokes with a real cost.
Trailer, via Sony Pictures Entertainment.
Olive Penderghast and the Rumor Mill
Olive is 17, living in Ojai, California, and narrating her own story into a webcam. She dodges a camping trip with her best friend Rhiannon Abernathy by claiming a date with a college boy. She spends the weekend at home with a musical greeting card. Pressed on Monday, she lies about what happened. Marianne Bryant, a devout Christian student, overhears it, and the story is out of her hands.
Royal’s screenplay pulls from Nathaniel Hawthorne’s 1850 novel The Scarlet Letter. Olive reads it in English class. She stitches a red “A” onto her clothes and wears her new reputation like armor. The film knows exactly what it is doing with that image.
“Let’s not and say we did.”
That tagline is the whole engine. Olive never has sex with anyone she claims. She takes gift cards from boys who want the credit. She plays beard for Brandon, a gay classmate who gets bullied, so a party crowd will believe he is straight.
A Cast That Refuses to Wobble
Stone carries this. The film’s reputation rests on her, and she is the reason the lie never turns into a lecture. Stanley Tucci and Patricia Clarkson play her parents, Dill and Rosemary, and they are the movie’s secret weapon. Thomas Haden Church is Mr. Griffith, her favorite teacher. Lisa Kudrow is Mrs. Griffith, the guidance counselor. Malcolm McDowell is Principal Gibbons. Amanda Bynes is Marianne, and this is her final performance to date.
The plot turns ugly in the right way. Micah, Marianne’s ex, contracts chlamydia from sleeping with Mrs. Griffith. He blames Olive. Because Mr. Griffith is the teacher she respects, Olive accepts the blame. That is the moment the film stops being a lark about gossip and becomes something sharper.
What the Film Gets Right
The school board gets concerned. The church group tries to “save” Olive. Her classmates turn on her. The film stacks these pressures without letting any one of them become the whole point.
The screenplay is smart about the mechanics of a rumor. It shows the trade: attention for gift cards, a fake reputation for real popularity. Then it shows the bill.
The weakness is the ending. Easy A wants Olive to crush the rumor mill once and for all, and the film reaches for a clean resolution the first two acts did not earn. A story this tangled in other people’s judgments does not untangle in one gesture.
The Verdict on Easy A
Easy A won the Critics’ Choice Award for Best Comedy. Stone got a Golden Globe nomination for Best Actress in a Comedy or Musical. Entertainment Weekly ranked it number 14 on its 2021 list of the Best High School Movies. The praise is deserved, and the box office proves audiences agreed.
What matters here is Stone. She makes Olive funny without making her cruel, and vulnerable without making her a victim. The Scarlet Letter hook could have been a gimmick. Instead it gives the film a spine.
The film is not perfect. The third act is too tidy, and the resolution arrives faster than the setup deserves. But Easy A understands something most teen comedies miss: a reputation is a thing other people build, and taking it back is harder than earning it.
Get the Notebook.
The day's best stories and every fresh verdict, in plain English, in your inbox by seven. One email a day, no more.
