Netflix’s Cursed premiered on July 17, 2020, with a pedigree that promised more than it delivered. Frank Miller and Tom Wheeler built the show from their 2019 graphic novel of the same name, a re-imagining of the Arthurian legend told through the eyes of Nimue, a young heroine with a mysterious gift who is destined to become the powerful and tragic Lady of the Lake. Katherine Langford plays her. The season runs 10 episodes. It never got a second.
The premise is sturdy. After her mother’s death, Nimue joins forces with a young mercenary named Arthur, played by Devon Terrell, on a quest to find Merlin and deliver an ancient sword to him. Along the way she becomes a symbol of courage and rebellion against the Red Paladins and their complicit King Uther. The show’s own description calls it a coming-of-age story about the obliteration of the natural world, religious terror, senseless war, and finding the courage to lead in the face of the impossible.
That is a lot of weight for one season to carry. Cursed carries some of it.
Trailer, via Netflix.
Nimue, Arthur, and the Sword
The casting is the show’s clearest asset. Langford gives Nimue a watchful stillness that fits a character whose gift is mysterious rather than showy. Terrell’s Arthur is warmer and less mythic than the legend usually allows, which is the point of telling this story through Nimue’s eyes. Gustaf Skarsgård plays Merlin, Peter Mullan plays Father Carden, and Daniel Sharman plays the Weeping Monk. Sebastian Armesto is King Uther Pendragon. Lily Newmark is Pym, Matt Stokoe is Gawain, Billy Jenkins is Squirrel. Creator Frank Miller appears in a cameo.
The supporting cast list is long, and that is part of the problem. Cursed spreads its episodes across a large field of characters, and not all of them earn the time. Father Carden and the Weeping Monk give the season its most effective menace, a religious terror that feels concrete rather than abstract. The Red Paladins work as villains because the show keeps them simple: they burn, they hunt, they believe.
Where the season thins out is in the middle. The quest structure should tighten as Nimue and Arthur move toward Merlin, but the show keeps stopping to introduce factions and side characters. A coming-of-age arc needs forward motion, and Cursed too often trades momentum for world-building.
What the First Season Gets Right
The themes the show names for itself are the ones it handles best. The destruction of the natural world and the fear of religious violence are not decoration here. They give the Red Paladins a reason to exist beyond generic evil, and they give Nimue a cause beyond her own survival. When the series lets her become a symbol, it works.
The action and fantasy elements are serviceable. The sword matters, the magic stays vague in a way that suits a mystery, and the medieval Great Britain setting is rendered as a fantasy version rather than a history lesson. That freedom helps. It also means the show has no obligation to the actual legend, which frees it to make Nimue the center rather than a prize.
The problem is that the season ends without resolving enough. One season and a cancellation in July 2021 means Cursed stops mid-arc. Viewers who invest in Nimue’s journey get a beginning and a middle and no ending.
The Case Against a Second Season
Netflix canceled Cursed after one season. The published critical score sits at 5.9 out of 10, with a Metacritic score of 59 out of 100. That number is fair. It captures a show that is better than its worst instincts and worse than its best ones.
Here is what the season offers, in plain terms:
- Katherine Langford as Nimue, the Lady of the Lake
- Devon Terrell as Arthur, a young mercenary
- Gustaf Skarsgård as Merlin
- Daniel Sharman as the Weeping Monk
- Peter Mullan as Father Carden
- Sebastian Armesto as King Uther Pendragon
- Lily Newmark as Pym, Matt Stokoe as Gawain, Billy Jenkins as Squirrel
That is a strong ensemble. The failure is not in the casting. It is in the shape of the season. Cursed wants to be an epic and a coming-of-age story at once, and it does not have the room to be both. The Red Paladins give it a spine. The quest gives it a direction. What it lacks is the discipline to cut characters and scenes that do not serve Nimue.
The cancellation is not a tragedy, but it leaves the story unfinished. The themes were right, the lead was right, the villain was right. The execution was uneven.
Cursed is worth watching for Langford and for the Red Paladins. It is not worth mourning. The show had a clear idea of what it wanted to say about the obliteration of the natural world, religious terror, senseless war, and finding the courage to lead in the face of the impossible. It just could not say it fast enough.
Get the Notebook.
The day's best stories and every fresh verdict, in plain English, in your inbox by seven. One email a day, no more.