ROBLOX. VIDEO GAMES. MOVIES. ORIGINAL ANIMATIONS.
CLAY TRIBUNE.
Advertisement

Z Nation: One Great Idea, No Discipline — A 4.8/10 Retrospective

Z Nation ran five seasons on Syfy as a cheap, funny, uneven zombie road trip. Murphy was a great idea. Black Summer did it better. 4.8/10.

By mitch·7 min read
A weary band of survivors trudges along a desolate highway toward a ruined city.

Z Nation ran for five seasons and 68 episodes on Syfy, from September 12, 2014 to December 28, 2018. It was created by Karl Schaefer and Craig Engler and produced by The Asylum, the company behind the low-budget mockbuster trade. That pedigree tells you most of what you need to know going in, and most of what went wrong.

The premise is a road trip. Three years after a virus has gutted the country, a small group of survivors must move one man from New York to California, where the last known working viral lab waits for his blood. That man is Alvin Bernard Murphy, played by Keith Allan. He is the only known survivor of a zombie bite who did not turn. His blood carries the antibodies that might make a vaccine.

Trailer, via SYFY.

Advertisement

Murphy Is the Whole Engine

The show’s best idea is Murphy himself. Before society fell, he was one of three inmates at Portsmouth Naval Prison in Kittery, Maine, in a government-approved experiment. Each man got a different test vaccine. Murphy was the only one who lived. When the prison fell, the head of the experiment and her staff evacuated and left him behind. He was bitten multiple times. He did not turn.

Then the show adds a twist that keeps the engine running. Murphy is not stable. His skin sheds. His body turns blue. He can control and even mesmerize certain zombies he meets. He has not become a full zombie and he still controls himself, but he is mutating into something between the two. And he keeps a dark secret about his condition that threatens the whole group.

That is a real hook, and Keith Allan plays it with a smirk that makes Murphy tolerable and unnerving at once. The problem is the show around him.

The Group, and Who Leads It

Kellita Smith plays Lieutenant Roberta Warren, an ex-National Guard member activated out of Missouri. She loses nearly everyone and everything that mattered to her, and she takes over the group after Garnett dies. She is the show’s spine, and Smith gives it more weight than the scripts usually earn.

The rest of the traveling party:

  • Nat Zang as 10K, the young sniper
  • Russell Hodgkinson as Doc, the older survivor
  • Anastasia Baranova as Addy Carver
  • DJ Qualls as Citizen Z
  • Katy O’Brian as Georgia “George” St. Clair
  • Gracie Gillam as Sgt. Lilley
  • Ramona Young as Kaya
  • Tara Holt as Lucy Murphy

Citizen Z is the show’s second-best device. Simon “Citizen Z” Cruller is a former hacker stranded at the NSA’s Northern Light listening post in the Arctic Circle. After a rescue flight goes wrong, he is the facility’s only surviving employee. He uses the equipment to guide the group west and runs a radio broadcast warning survivors about disaster-level weather and zombie hordes. He goes slowly insane from loneliness until he rescues a sled dog named Pup.

Qualls is funny and the isolation material is genuinely strange. It is also completely disconnected from the road trip for long stretches, which is the structural problem in miniature: Z Nation has two shows inside it and never decides which one it is.

The Spokane Backlot

Z Nation was filmed in the Spokane, Washington area, and it looks it. The Asylum’s budget shows in every crowd scene, every gutted building, every zombie makeup job that stops at the neck. That is not automatically fatal. A zombie show can survive cheap if it is smart or funny or mean enough.

Z Nation tries to be all three at once. It is billed as horror comedy-drama, and the comedy is the part that works most often. The show is at its best when it stops pretending to be prestige television and commits to being a B-movie with a body count. When it reaches for sincere emotion, the seams show.

Five Seasons, One Cancellation

Syfy announced on June 16, 2016 that the third season would be preceded by a TV movie set before the climax of season 2, introducing central characters for season 3. That movie never arrived as a movie. It was instead presented as the first two episodes of the third season, the two-part “No Mercy.” A small thing, but telling: the show kept promising a bigger version of itself and delivering the regular version.

Syfy renewed Z Nation for a fifth season on December 15, 2017. The fifth season premiered on October 5, 2018. On December 22, 2018, Syfy cancelled the series after five seasons. The 68th and final episode aired on December 28, 2018, closing it out.

What Warren Becomes

The later seasons get strange in ways that are worth naming. In season 4, Warren wakes up in Zona after being treated for a ricocheting bullet that passed through Murphy. A vaccine made from Murphy’s blood fails among the Zona citizens, chaos follows, and she and Murphy escape and reunite with the group.

In the season 4 finale, the drone she is trapped in crash-lands. In season 5, she becomes a talker after dying from blood loss. Unlike other talkers, she does not crave brains, presumably because Murphy’s blood is in her system.

That is a bold swing. It is also the kind of swing a show makes when it has run out of road and needs a new shape. Z Nation never had a plan sturdy enough to survive its own improvisations, and by season 5 the improvisations are the whole show.

Black Summer Did It Better

The most useful comparison is the one the franchise made for itself. Black Summer is a prequel series with an entirely new cast, darker in tone and less comedic, showing the start of the apocalypse referenced in Z Nation. It ran for two seasons on Netflix between 2019 and 2021.

Black Summer is the version of this material that works. It strips out the jokes, the radio booth, the chosen-one mythology and the road-trip structure, and keeps only the panic. Z Nation had the better premise and the worse execution, and the spinoff proves the premise was never the problem.

The Sixth Season That Wasn’t

In March 2024, The Asylum posted on X, formerly Twitter, in a way fans read as a hint that a sixth season might be coming. It may have been a reference to the series returning to multiple streaming platforms instead. In August 2025, there was another social media post, though the record here is thin.

Fans keep looking for a revival because Z Nation left a door open and never walked through it. That is not the same as the show deserving one. Five seasons and 68 episodes is a full run for a series this uneven, and the finale closed the story it set out to tell.

Our Verdict

Z Nation is a show with one great idea, one great performance, and no discipline. Murphy is a genuine invention — a protagonist who is also the threat, a vaccine that might be worse than the disease, a man whose blood is hope and whose body is horror. Keith Allan and Kellita Smith carry more than the writing gives them. Citizen Z is a good gimmick in a show that cannot integrate its good gimmicks.

Everything else is The Asylum doing what The Asylum does. The Spokane locations are flat. The action is cheap. The tonal shifts are whiplash, and the later seasons pile on twists — Zona, the talkers, Warren’s death and return — because the show never trusted its own core. A road trip from New York to California with the fate of humanity in the back seat is enough. Z Nation kept adding and kept subtracting from the same total.

The published critical score of 4.8 out of 10 is fair, and it is fair for a specific reason: the show is never boring, which counts for something, and it is never good, which counts for more. Black Summer showed what this universe could be when someone decided to take it seriously. Z Nation is the rough draft that made that possible, and a rough draft is what it plays like.

The Notebook

Get the Notebook.

The day's best stories and every fresh verdict, in plain English, in your inbox by seven. One email a day, no more.

We send one note to confirm. Every issue has a one-click way out.

Advertisement

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

As an Amazon Associate, Clay Tribune earns from qualifying purchases.