Paradise Killer asks you to solve a mass murder on an island that was always going to be destroyed anyway. The Syndicate Council is dead, the sacrifice that would have moved Paradise Island 24 on to its 25th iteration is on hold, and the only detective available has spent more than 3,000,000 days in exile. Her name is Lady Love Dies. She is very good at this.
Kaizen Game Works built Paradise Killer as an open world detective story, published by Fellow Traveller. It came out September 4, 2020 on Nintendo Switch and Windows, then reached PlayStation 4, PlayStation 5, Xbox One and Xbox Series X/S on March 16, 2022. It scores 7.9 out of 10.
Trailer, via PC Gamer.
Lady Love Dies and the Island That Fails
The premise is the best thing in the game, and it is worth stating plainly. The Syndicate is a group of immortal humans trying to build a “perfect society” so they can reawaken their ancient gods. The method is monstrous. They kidnap people from Earth, let them live as Citizens on an island, and when the experiment fails, they ritually slaughter everyone and use the souls to build the next one.
Paradise Island 24 is the 24th attempt. On the night of the regular sacrifice, the entire Council is found murdered inside chambers only Council members can open. That is the locked-room problem at the center of Paradise Killer, and it is a good one.
Initial evidence points at Henry Division, an imprisoned Citizen possessed by a demon. He should not have been physically capable of being there. The Syndicate Judge thinks there is more to it and sends for Love Dies, giving her authority over the case and authorization to execute anyone proven guilty in court.
An Open World Where Everyone Is Hiding Something
Love Dies roams a 3D island in first person, gathering evidence and questioning residents. The design is nonlinear. You can bring the case to trial whenever you want, though the game is clear that more evidence makes a conviction more likely. Nearly everyone on the island has something to hide, and the game does not push you toward one answer.
The structure is the argument. Paradise Killer hands you a cast of secretive immortals, a pile of clues, and no referee. You decide who is guilty. You can accuse anyone. You will have to prove it in trial to convict.
That freedom is real, and it is also the source of the game’s biggest problem.
What the Trial Actually Demands
A detective game lives or dies on whether the accusation feels earned. Paradise Killer gives you the tools to earn it, but the tools are uneven. Evidence collection is mostly walking, looking and talking. Interrogation is mostly reading. The island is drenched in vaporwave color and cosmic dread, and the art direction carries more tension than the moment-to-moment play does.
There is no combat. There is no timer forcing your hand. What there is, instead, is a long stretch of exploration where the mystery has to hold your attention on its own. For a while it does. The setting is strange enough to keep you moving, and the Citizens are strange enough to keep you asking.
Then the middle of the game arrives, and the pace sags.
The Case Against Paradise Killer
Here is the honest criticism. Paradise Killer is more interesting to think about than it is to play for long stretches. The open world is large and the movement through it is not especially satisfying. The clues are scattered across the island in a way that respects your intelligence but also respects your patience, and patience runs out.
The trial system is the payoff, and it works. You present your case, you name your culprit, and the game holds you to it. That is a real design achievement, and few detective games commit to it this hard.
But the road to the trial is longer than the trial deserves. The game’s best ideas — the doomed island, the ritual sacrifice, the immortal bureaucracy that treats human lives as fuel — are delivered through text and atmosphere rather than through play. You are told the Syndicate is monstrous. You are not often made to feel it.
What Paradise Killer Gets Right
The things it gets right are not small. The premise is one of the strangest in recent adventure games, and it commits fully. The cast is memorable. Lady Love Dies is a genuine character, not a player avatar with a badge. The locked-room murder is set up with care, and the demon-possessed prisoner is a strong first suspect because the game knows you will notice how convenient he is.
- Open world exploration with no forced order
- First-person investigation across a 3D island
- Interrogation of a full cast of secretive residents
- A trial system where you can accuse anyone but must prove it
- A single-player structure with no combat and no timer
That list is the whole game. There is no filler mode, no side content bolted on to pad the runtime. What you see is what Kaizen Game Works built, and the focus is admirable.
The Verdict on Paradise Island 24
Paradise Killer is a game about a society that keeps failing and keeps trying again, and its own design reflects that stubbornness. It refuses to hold your hand. It refuses to tell you who did it. It trusts you to build a case and live with the result.
That trust is the reason to play it. It is also the reason some players will bounce off. The game asks for a kind of attention that modern adventure games rarely demand, and it does not always reward that attention with momentum. The island is beautiful and empty in equal measure. The mystery is compelling and the pacing is not.
A 7.9 out of 10 is the right score. Paradise Killer is not a flawless detective game. It is a bold one, with a premise strong enough to carry it past its slow stretches and a trial system that delivers when it finally arrives. If you want a game that respects your ability to reason, this is it. If you want a game that keeps moving, you will feel the drag.
The part worth watching is what Kaizen Game Works does next. The studio built a world where guilt is a choice the player makes and then has to defend. That is a hard thing to get right once. It is harder to get right twice. Paradise Killer earns its score on the strength of that idea and the nerve to follow it through, even when the island gets quiet.
Get the Notebook.
The day's best stories and every fresh verdict, in plain English, in your inbox by seven. One email a day, no more.
