A train full of children, a conductor who denies Santa’s very existence, and a small boy who loses his faith in Santa Claus — that’s the whole engine of The Polar Express, and it runs on pure sentiment rather than plot. Robert Zemeckis directs from Chris Van Allsburg’s picture book, and the result is a movie about believing, even when belief feels absurd.
Trailer, via Warner Bros. Rewind.
The Train
The setup is simple. A boy named Harry boards a train bound for the North Pole on Christmas Eve, after he loses his faith in Santa Claus. He meets other children, a conductor, and a strange man who claims to be the real Santa. The journey is meant to restore Harry’s belief, but the film spends more time on the train’s motion than on why the boy ever doubted in the first place.
The Motion Capture
Zemeckis uses motion capture animation, a technique that turns live actors into digital characters. The performance capture is technically impressive, but the faces often look stiff, and the eyes lack life. The train itself is the star — a vast, gleaming locomotive that carries the story forward, even when the dialogue stalls behind it.
The Soundtrack
The score, composed by Alan Silvestri, carries the film’s emotional weight. It swells during key moments, underscoring the boy’s growing sense of wonder and loss. The music is the best reason to watch.
The Message
The Polar Express is a story about faith, wrapped in a train ride. It tells Harry that believing is enough, even if the evidence isn’t. That’s a fine message, but the film doesn’t quite earn it through character development. Harry is a passive observer of his own transformation, and the film rarely lets him speak his doubts out loud.
Final Word
The Polar Express is a well-made, sincere attempt to capture the magic of childhood, but it leans too hard on spectacle over substance. The train is beautiful, the score is stirring, but the boy’s arc feels thin next to the grandeur around him.
Key Facts
– Title: The Polar Express
– Year: 2004
– Director: Robert Zemeckis
– Format: Motion capture animation
– Score: 6.7/10
Get the Notebook.
The day's best stories and every fresh verdict, in plain English, in your inbox by seven. One email a day, no more.
