Nightdive Studios’ CEO Stephen Kick has raised hopes for an Eternal Darkness remaster, calling the GameCube horror classic “one of my all-time favorites” and pointing fans toward the studio’s “Deep Dives” videos. The company, now owned by Atari, has spent years bringing classic games back to life, from System Shock, Quake, Doom and Turok to Heretic + Hexen and Thief: The Dark Project.
Kick’s Comment
Kick responded to a fan request via social media on the 25th anniversary of the GameCube. He wrote: “Eternal Darkness is one of my all-time favorites and it deserves the treatment I know Nightdive Studios is capable of,” Kick wrote. “Keep your eye on our Deep Dives…”
That last line refers to the studio’s lengthy YouTube videos tracking its current projects. Fans have read it as a sign the remaster is coming next.
The Track Record With Nintendo
Nightdive has tried to work with Nintendo before. In 2022, Kick said the company “always get[s] gun shy working with third-party developers.” He noted that talks on an array of Nintendo games never came to anything, including a remaster of the N64 classic Goldeneye 007. Nintendo ultimately rejected that project, then dropped the original on Nintendo Switch Online instead.
Despite that history, Kick has long maintained that Eternal Darkness is his favorite Nintendo game he’d like Nightdive to work on.
What Eternal Darkness Actually Is
Developed by Silicon Knights, the game launched for the GameCube in 2002. Players control an array of historical characters, each of which can descend into madness if you’re not careful. The psychological effects hit the player directly, from skewed camera angles to bleeding walls and moving statues. At its most extreme, the game breaks the fourth wall, appearing to reset progress or mute players’ TVs.
Nintendo itself locked down the sanity mechanics with a patent.
The Sequel That Never Happened
The game earned strong reviews but sold relatively poorly. Plans for a sequel were discussed for years, but issues within Silicon Knights hampered progress. A later push for a spiritual successor via a crowdfunding campaign also fell by the wayside. Silicon Knights shut down in 2014, and Nintendo’s patent for the sanity system is now believed to have lapsed.
The Case For a Remaster
Nightdive’s work fits the pattern. The studio takes classic games and gives them a lick of visual paint while staying true to their original forms, often in collaboration with the original development studio. Its enhanced ports have found an audience.
The question is whether Nintendo will let it happen this time.
What Happens Next
There is no official announcement yet. Kick’s comment was encouraging, but his past experience with Nintendo suggests caution. The studio has pointed fans toward its Deep Dives, and the GameCube anniversary gave him the opening to speak.
For now, fans wait.
Key Facts Box
- Eternal Darkness launched for GameCube in 2002
- Developed by Silicon Knights
- Nintendo patented the sanity mechanics
- Silicon Knights shut down in 2014
- Nintendo’s patent is believed to have lapsed
- Nightdive is now owned by Atari
Order of Events
- Nightdive’s CEO Stephen Kick responds to a fan request on the 25th anniversary of the GameCube.
- Kick calls Eternal Darkness “one of my all-time favorites.”
- Kick points fans toward the studio’s Deep Dives videos.
- The GameCube anniversary gives Kick the opening to speak.
- Nintendo’s history with third-party developers remains a hurdle.
The remaster would bring a cult classic back to modern screens. The sanity mechanics were locked down with a patent, and the patent is now believed to have lapsed. The other barrier is Nintendo itself, and Kick’s past comments suggest the path is not smooth.
Still, Kick has made his position clear. Eternal Darkness is his favorite Nintendo game he wants Nightdive to work on. The Deep Dives hint at what’s coming next.
Get the Notebook.
The day's best stories and every fresh verdict, in plain English, in your inbox by seven. One email a day, no more.