“A Discovery of Witches” is a fantasy drama that tries to do something ambitious: adapt Deborah Harkness’s bestselling novel into a serialized TV show. It mostly succeeds, but the show’s strengths are also its weaknesses. The series, created for the Sundance Channel, stars Teresa Palmer as Diana Bishop, a historian who discovers she is a witch and finds herself caught between a centuries-old vampire named Matthew Clairmont and a coven of magical beings who want her dead. The result is a slow-burn romance wrapped in a cloak-and-dagger plot, with enough historical detail to satisfy fans of period drama and enough supernatural intrigue to keep fantasy audiences engaged.
Trailer, via Sky TV.
Diana Bishop’s Scholarly World
Teresa Palmer plays Diana Bishop, a history professor at Yale who specializes in alchemy. She is a brilliant academic, but she has spent years hiding her magical abilities from the world. When she accidentally opens a manuscript in the Bodleian Library in Oxford, she unleashes a chain of events that forces her to confront her heritage. The show spends considerable time establishing Diana’s scholarly rigor, showing her poring over ancient texts and debating theories with colleagues. This attention to detail pays off, grounding the fantastical elements in a relatable world of research and intellectual curiosity.
Palmer brings a quiet intensity to the role. She is not a flashy actress, but she carries the weight of Diana’s internal conflict well. Her performance anchors the series, making Diana’s reluctant journey into her witchcraft feel earned rather than forced.
Matthew Clairmont’s Vampire Romance
Matthew Clairmont is played by Mathew Lewis, best known for his role as Neville Longbottom in the Harry Potter films. He brings a brooding intensity to the character, a centuries-old vampire who falls in love with Diana despite the rules of his kind. Their romance is the emotional core of the show, and the actors sell it with genuine chemistry. The tension between their desire and the danger surrounding them keeps the audience invested.
The relationship is complicated by the fact that vampires are forbidden to form lasting bonds with humans. Matthew’s decision to break that rule sets the plot in motion, and the show explores the consequences of his actions across multiple episodes. The pacing is deliberate, which frustrates some viewers but rewards those willing to sit through the slow build.
The Coven and the Magicians
The villains of the first season are the coven led by Marcus de Clermont, Matthew’s uncle. They believe Diana is a danger to their kind and will stop at nothing to eliminate her. This faction adds a layer of moral ambiguity to the story, since their motivations are understandable even as their methods are cruel. The show also introduces a group of witches known as the Magicians, who operate outside the established hierarchy and provide a counterpoint to the traditional magical community.
These characters add depth to the world beyond the central romance. The show’s ensemble cast includes excellent performances from the supporting actors, though the pacing of their storylines can sometimes feel rushed compared to the main plot.
Historical Detail and World-Building
One of the strongest aspects of “A Discovery of Witches” is its commitment to historical accuracy. The show is set in the present day, but it frequently dips into flashbacks that explore key moments in the past. These scenes are rich with period detail, from the architecture of medieval Oxford to the politics of 16th-century France. The production design is meticulous, and the attention to costuming and set decoration is evident throughout.
The show also delves into the history of magic itself, showing how witchcraft evolved over centuries and how different cultures treated practitioners. This educational approach is a welcome change from many fantasy shows, which gloss over the origins of their worlds. The show’s willingness to explain its mythology is a strength, though some viewers may find the exposition heavy-handed at times.
The Slow Burn and Its Cost
The show’s biggest weakness is its pacing. The first season is 10 episodes long, and the plot takes its time getting to the big reveal. Some viewers will find the early episodes tedious, with extended sequences of dialogue and character development that feel like filler. The slow burn is intentional, but it means the payoff arrives later than it might in a more tightly constructed narrative.
The show also struggles with balancing its romantic and action-driven elements. There are several action sequences, but they are often brief and poorly choreographed. The show is clearly more interested in the emotional stakes than in spectacle, which is a valid choice, but it leaves some viewers wanting more kinetic energy.
Critical Reception
Critics have been divided on “A Discovery of Witches.” Some praised its attention to historical detail and its willingness to take risks with its source material, while others found the pacing frustrating and the action lacking. The show has a Metacritic score of 6.7 out of 10, which reflects the mixed response from critics.
“A Discovery of Witches” is a confident adaptation that respects its source material while finding its own identity.
The show’s blend of romance, historical drama, and fantasy appeals to a specific audience, but it may not win over casual viewers looking for fast-paced entertainment. The show’s success depends on viewers being patient enough to invest in its world and its characters.
Final Verdict
“A Discovery of Witches” is a thoughtful, well-made fantasy drama that deserves credit for its ambition. It takes its time telling a story, and that patience is rewarded in the final episodes. The performances are strong, the world-building is detailed, and the central romance is genuinely moving. However, the slow pacing and occasional uneven action sequences hold it back from greatness.
The show is at its best when it balances its historical and supernatural elements, creating a world that feels both grounded and magical. It is a show that rewards attention and patience, even if it asks for both in large quantities.
Get the Notebook.
The day's best stories and every fresh verdict, in plain English, in your inbox by seven. One email a day, no more.
