“Oz” arrived on HBO in July 1997 with a simple, brutal premise: put men from every faction of the prison system in one controlled wing and watch what the control costs. Tom Fontana created the show, co-executive produced it and wrote most of it. It ran six seasons and 56 episodes, ending in February 2003.
It was the first one-hour dramatic series HBO produced. That fact matters less than what Fontana did with the freedom the network gave him. “Oz” is a prison drama that refuses the redemptive arc. Men enter Emerald City, and most of them leave in a body bag, a cage or a coffin of their own making.
Trailer, via HBO.
Emerald City and Tim McManus
The setting is the Oswald State Correctional Facility, a fictional level 4 maximum-security state prison. The show never names its state, though references across the series point to New York. “Oz” is the nickname for the prison, and it also nods to L. Frank Baum’s Land of Oz. The unit at the center of the story is Emerald City, named after the fantastic place in the Oz books.
Tim McManus, played by Terry Kinney, runs Em City. He believes in rehabilitation and responsibility during incarceration rather than pure punishment. To keep the peace, he builds a careful balance of members from each racial and social group. The theory is that shared space eases tension. The practice is that almost every faction is at war with every other, and prisoners get beaten, raped or killed as a result.
Warden Leo Glynn, played by Ernie Hudson, oversees the whole facility and spends much of the series cleaning up after McManus’ experiments. The two men want order. They disagree, constantly, about how to get it.
Augustus Hill Narrates the Whole Thing
Harold Perrineau plays Augustus Hill, an inmate who narrates the series. Hill explains the show, gives context, offers thematic analysis and supplies most of its humor. He is also confined to a wheelchair, which makes him both an observer and a target.
The narration is the show’s smartest structural choice. Hill can step outside the story, address the audience directly and tell us what a scene means without breaking the drama. He is the one character who understands that Emerald City is a failed idea, and he says so.
The Factions at War
The show’s engine is its groups. Fontana builds a whole society behind the walls, and the roster of factions is the show’s real cast list.
- The African-American Homeboys, including Adebisi, Wangler, Redding, Poet and Keane
- The Muslims, including Saïd, Arif and Khan
- The Wiseguys, including Pancamo, Nappa, Schibetta and Ortolani
- The Aryan Brotherhood, including Schillinger, Robson and Mack
- El Norte, the Latinos, including Alvarez, Morales, Guerra and Hernandez
- The Irish, mostly the O’Reily brothers
- The Gays, including Hanlon, Cramer, Ginzburg and Torquemada
- The Bikers, including Hoyt and Ross
- The Christians, including Cloutier, Coushaine and Cudney
Then there are the men who belong to no group at all: Rebadow, Busmalis, Keller, Stanislofsky and others. In “Oz,” independence is not freedom. It is exposure.
Kareem Saïd, played by Eamonn Walker, is the Muslim leader and the show’s most articulate voice of principle. Vernon Schillinger, played by J.K. Simmons, leads the Aryan Brotherhood and is the show’s most reliable source of cruelty. Ryan O’Reily, played by Dean Winters, works every angle and trusts no one. Tobias Beecher, played by Lee Tergesen, starts as a lawyer with a family and becomes something the system made.
The Cast Carries the Weight
The show’s cast is unusually deep for a cable drama of its era, and several of these actors became familiar faces because of it. Simmons turned Schillinger into one of television’s great villains. Winters made O’Reily a schemer you root for against your better judgment. Perrineau’s Hill holds the whole thing together.
Rita Moreno plays Sister Peter Marie Reimondo, the prison’s nun and counselor. BD Wong plays Father Ray Mukada. Tom Mardirosian plays Agamemnon Busmalis. Kirk Acevedo plays Miguel Alvarez, whose arc across the series is one of the show’s most punishing. Craig muMs Grant plays Poet.
The show asks these actors to do things network television would not touch in 1997. Rape, drug trade, murder, solitary confinement and the slow erosion of men who had lives before prison. The cast never plays it as shock. They play it as routine, which is worse.
What Oz Gets Right
“Oz” understands that a prison is a bureaucracy before it is a battlefield. McManus and Glynn fight over budgets, policy and blame while men die in the unit they run. The show never lets the administrators off the hook, and it never pretends the inmates are innocent.
The writing is spare and fast. Fontana and his writers move through story at a pace that most dramas of the period could not match. Characters die without warning. Alliances flip. The show does not explain itself twice.
The narration from Hill is the device that lets “Oz” cover years of plot without losing the thread. It is also the device that keeps the show from becoming pure misery. Hill finds the joke in the worst room in the building.
Where Oz Stumbles
The show’s later seasons lose discipline. The factions multiply, the violence escalates and the balance that made Emerald City interesting in the first place gives way to pure chaos. McManus’ experiment stops being an experiment and becomes a setting.
The show also ages in ways that are hard to ignore. Its treatment of race and sexuality is blunt, and not always in a way that reads as deliberate. Some of the story arcs rely on shock where the early seasons relied on character. By the end, “Oz” is still watchable, but it is no longer the same show that premiered in 1997.
A note on the numbers: the series holds an 8.0 out of 10 audience score on TMDB across 875 votes. That is a fair measure of how the show sits with viewers who found it. It is not a measure of how it holds up.
Why Oz Still Matters
“Oz” is the show that proved HBO could make drama without network limits, and it cleared the way for the series that followed. It also proved that a prison story could be about institutions rather than individual redemption. The men of Emerald City are not trying to get better. They are trying to get through the day, make parole or see tomorrow.
That is the show’s real subject, and it is the reason the series still holds up better than its reputation suggests. The factions are loud. The narration is clever. The thing that sticks is the system, and how little any one person inside it can do.
The show’s best episodes are not the ones with the most blood. They are the ones where McManus and Glynn sit in an office and decide what a man’s life is worth on paper. “Oz” is at its sharpest when it is a show about administration, and at its weakest when it forgets that and reaches for the next outrage.
The cast is the reason to watch. Simmons, Winters, Perrineau, Walker and Tergesen give the show a floor it never falls through. Even in the weakest seasons, these actors make the unit feel like a place where people live, not a set where things happen.
“Oz” is not a perfect series. It is a necessary one. It took the freedom HBO offered and used it to build something television had not seen before, and it did so with a cast that understood exactly what it was making.
Our score: 8 of 10.
Get the Notebook.
The day's best stories and every fresh verdict, in plain English, in your inbox by seven. One email a day, no more.