Love, Rosie opens with a promise: two people who belong together, separated by circumstance, will find each other again. That premise could support a quiet, tender drama. Instead, the film leans on coincidence, missed connections, and a script that can’t quite decide whether it wants to be a romantic comedy or a tragedy of missed opportunities. The result is a movie that feels less like a love story and more like a series of missed deadlines.
The film follows Rosie (Lily Collins) and Alex (Sam Claflin) from childhood through adulthood. They meet as children, fall in love as teenagers, and then lose touch after a cruel misunderstanding. The plot runs on a simple engine: every time they get close to each other, something happens. A letter goes astray. A phone call gets cut off. A flight is canceled. The film treats these failures as fate, but they start to feel more like bad writing.
Trailer, via LionsgateFilmsUK.
Childhood Sweethearts
The film spends its early scenes establishing the bond between Rosie and Alex. They grow up in Ireland, share a bedroom, and promise to marry each other. The performances are earnest, and the chemistry between Collins and Claflin is real. Their scenes together are the film’s best moments, full of warmth and genuine affection.
But the setup is also where the film begins to strain. The childhood scenes are too long, and the misunderstandings that drive the plot feel manufactured rather than earned. The film wants us to believe that a single letter misdirected by a postal worker is the reason the two characters spend years apart. That’s a thin thread to hang a feature-length narrative on.
The Long Gap
The bulk of the film covers the years between the teens and the present day. Rosie becomes a writer in New York. Alex moves to London to pursue music. They both have successful careers, but neither finds lasting happiness. The film shows them meeting people, falling in love, and losing those relationships. Each of these stories is told in a few minutes, and they often feel like filler rather than character development.
The pacing suffers here. The film rushes through decades of life in a way that feels rushed and unsatisfying. We see snapshots of Rosie’s and Alex’s lives, but we don’t get to know them. We see their jobs, their apartments, their lovers, but we never understand why they’re doing what they’re doing. The film is so eager to get to the reunion that it forgets to let the characters breathe.
The Reunion
The film’s climax comes when Rosie and Alex finally cross paths in London. It’s a moment that should land with weight. Instead, it lands with confusion. The film has spent so much time setting up the reunion that when it arrives, it feels anticlimactic. The characters look at each other, smile, and the film moves on.
The final stretch of the film tries to tie everything together. Rosie and Alex talk about their lives, their regrets, and their feelings for each other. The dialogue is sentimental, and the delivery is sincere. But the script hasn’t built enough foundation to support this emotional payoff. The film asks us to care deeply about these characters, but it hasn’t given us enough reason to.
Lily Collins and Sam Claflin
Collins and Claflin are the heart of Love, Rosie. They play characters who are meant to be soulmates, and they sell that connection. Their scenes together crackle with energy, and their chemistry is the only thing that keeps the film from collapsing under its own contrivances.
Collins brings a vulnerability to Rosie that makes her relatable. She’s a writer struggling to find her footing, and Collins plays that uncertainty with grace. Claflin brings a restless energy to Alex. He’s a musician chasing success, and Claflin captures that drive without tipping into caricature.
Together, they make the central romance work. They make you believe that Rosie and Alex were meant to be together, even when the script doesn’t.
The Supporting Cast
The film also features a strong supporting cast. Chris O’Dowd plays Rosie’s brother, and he brings a warmth to the role that grounds the story. Anna Faris appears as a love interest for Alex, and she’s funny and charming. The ensemble is talented, but the script doesn’t give them much to do.
The film’s approach to supporting characters is telling. Everyone around Rosie and Alex exists to move the plot forward. A friend tells a story that leads to a revelation. A colleague provides a job opportunity that sends Alex on a trip. These characters are functional, not fleshed out. They serve the story, but they don’t feel like people.
The Direction
The film is directed by Sharon Maguire, who also directed Bridget Jones’s Diary. That pedigree suggests a director who understands romantic comedy. Unfortunately, Maguire’s direction here is uneven. Some scenes are sharp and well-framed, while others feel loose and unfocused. The film’s visual style is bright and colorful, but it can’t hide the weaknesses underneath.
The editing is also a problem. The film jumps through time with little warning, and the transitions between decades are jarring. The film loses its sense of place, moving from Ireland to New York to London without giving us a chance to settle in. This is a movie about two people who are always searching for each other, and it never lets us settle anywhere.
The Score
The score is pleasant but forgettable. It swells during emotional moments, but it doesn’t add anything to the scene. The songs used throughout the film are serviceable, but they don’t linger. The sound design is clean, and the dialogue is easy to hear. None of it elevates the material.
| Scene | Setting | Time Period |
|---|---|---|
| Childhood | Ireland | Childhood |
| Teenage Years | Ireland | Teenage Years |
| Young Adult Years | New York / London | Young Adult Years |
| Reunion | London | Present Day |
The Verdict
Love, Rosie has a good idea at its core. Two people who belong together, separated by circumstance, finding each other again. That idea deserves a better film. The script is too thin, the pacing is too rushed, and the emotional payoff is too small. The film is watchable, thanks to Collins and Claflin, but it’s a film that leaves you wanting more.
The film’s biggest flaw is its lack of patience. It rushes through decades of life in a handful of scenes, and it skips over the messy middle of adult relationships. It wants to show Rosie and Alex growing up, but it never lets them. The film is so focused on getting them back together that it forgets to let them live.
Love, Rosie is a film that wants to be a romance, but it keeps getting in its own way. It’s a film about missed connections, but it misses the mark itself. The performances are good, the premise is promising, and the ending is sincere. But none of that is enough to save a film that’s built on coincidence and convenience.
Love, Rosie is a film that will satisfy some viewers and frustrate others. It’s a film that rewards a second viewing, but it doesn’t demand one. It’s a film that’s pleasant to watch, but it’s not a film that lingers.
Get the Notebook.
The day's best stories and every fresh verdict, in plain English, in your inbox by seven. One email a day, no more.
