“Game Night” opens on a trivia night meet-cute and ends in a hail of gunfire, fake and real, and the film’s best trick is that it never quite lets you tell which is which. John Francis Daley and Jonathan Goldstein direct from a Mark Perez script. Jason Bateman and Rachel McAdams play Max and Annie Davis, a married couple who host a weekly game night and who, for one chaotic evening, get a mystery they did not sign up for.
Trailer, via Warner Bros..
Max, Annie, and a Stolen Corvette
The setup is clean. Brooks, Max’s more successful brother, arrives in Max’s dream car, tells an embarrassing childhood story, and offers to host the next game night himself. At his rental house he unveils an interactive role-playing mystery, with his Corvette promised to the winner. An actor walks in to start the game and is knocked out cold by two masked men who take Brooks. The friends assume it is all part of the show.
That assumption is the engine of the whole movie. Ryan and Sarah try to bribe the role-playing company for the final clue. Kevin and Michelle talk to the actor and learn the abduction was real. Max and Annie track Brooks’s phone to a bar, hold his captors at gunpoint, and free him. Annie accidentally shoots Max in the arm. Only then does the danger land.
Brooks, the Fabergé Egg, and the Bulgarian
Brooks confesses he is a black marketeer. He procured a Fabergé egg for a criminal called “the Bulgarian,” then sold it to someone using the alias “Marlon Freeman.” He jumps out of the car so Max and Annie can escape.
The cast is deep and the film knows it. Kyle Chandler gives Brooks a smug charm that curdles on cue. Jesse Plemons plays Gary Kingsbury, the awkward police officer neighbor, and was nominated for a Detroit Film Critics Society Award for Best Supporting Actor. Michael C. Hall turns up as the Bulgarian. Sharon Horgan, Billy Magnussen, Lamorne Morris and Kylie Bunbury fill out the couples. The directors cameo as Carter and Dan.
| Element | Who or what | Function |
|---|---|---|
| The game | Interactive role-playing mystery | The fake kidnapping the friends keep solving |
| The real crime | Fabergé egg procured for the Bulgarian and sold to “Marlon Freeman” | The actual kidnapping |
| The prize | Brooks’s Corvette | The bait that pulls the group in |
| The neighbor | Gary Kingsbury | The outsider kept out of game night |
What Actually Works
“Game Night” runs 100 minutes across mystery, comedy and crime, and its sharpest idea is structural: the audience learns the truth roughly when the characters do, and the gap between those two moments is where the laughs live. Warner Bros. released it on February 23, 2018. It grossed $117 million worldwide and drew positive reviews.
The weakness is that the film’s twists stack so fast that the stakes blur. Once Brooks admits he is a black marketeer, the movie asks you to care about a Fabergé egg and a man you have just learned is a liar. It mostly gets away with it, because Bateman and McAdams are good at panic, and because Plemons is genuinely unsettling as a man who wants in and cannot get in.
This is a well-built comedy that mistakes volume for momentum in its last act. The cast carries it further than the plot does. 6.6/10.
Get the Notebook.
The day's best stories and every fresh verdict, in plain English, in your inbox by seven. One email a day, no more.
