Wynonna Earp premiered in 2016 with a simple premise: a descendant of Wyatt Earp carries a gun, a badge, and a curse that turns her into a walking, talking ghost when she touches a dead body. The show wanted to be a supernatural western, a horror comedy, and a character drama all at once. It mostly succeeds at being entertaining, even when it fails at being coherent.
The show follows Wynonna Earp (Melissa McCarthy), who lives in the small town of Purgatory, Montana, and spends her days chasing ghosts, demons, and the occasional serial killer. She is assisted by her deputy, Nicole Haught (Katy Santiago), and later by her daughter, Charles (Dominique Provost-Chalkley). The series is based on the comic book of the same name, and it leans heavily into its source material’s campy tone.
Trailer, via Seriendario Com.
Wynonna Earp’s Premise
The curse is the engine of the show. Whenever Wynonna touches a corpse, she becomes a wraith that can pass through walls and scare the living hell out of anyone who sees her. It is a clever idea, and the show uses it well for several episodes. The problem is that the curse gets diluted over time. By the middle of the season, it is barely a plot device, replaced by more conventional supernatural threats.
The show also introduces a recurring villain named Bobobo (Jesse James), a clownish demon who seems to enjoy tormenting Wynonna for no reason. Bobobo is a strange choice for a lead antagonist, but he grows on you over time. He is genuinely menacing in his own bizarre way, and his presence gives the show a consistent threat that other villains lack.
Melissa McCarthy’s Performance
Melissa McCarthy brings a physicality to Wynonna that few actors could manage. She is tall, athletic, and moves with a grace that belies her size. Her performance is committed and often funny, especially in the show’s more absurd moments. She plays Wynonna as a woman who has lost everything and found a purpose in protecting her town. That conviction carries the show through its weaker stretches.
The supporting cast is solid, but Katy Santiago and Dominique Provost-Chalkley get less room to breathe. Nicole is a loyal sidekick, and Charles is a smart kid, but neither character gets the depth they deserve. The show tends to treat them as plot devices rather than fully realized people. That is a shame, because both actresses are capable of more.
The Camp Factor
Wynonna Earp is a campy show, and it knows it. The costumes, the music, and the dialogue all lean into the over-the-top aesthetic of its comic book origins. There are moments when the show is pure fun, especially when it embraces its own ridiculousness. The best episodes are the ones that commit fully to the absurdity.
“I am a walking, talking ghost.”
That line sums up the show’s approach. It is not trying to be realistic, and it does not pretend to be. The audience is meant to laugh at the spectacle, not question it. That commitment to style over substance is both the show’s strength and its weakness.
The Plot Problems
The show suffers from a lack of focus. It jumps from one threat to the next without giving any of them enough time to develop. The pacing is uneven, and some episodes feel like filler while others are genuinely engaging. The season finale tries to tie everything together, but it leaves too many threads unresolved. It is a frustrating ending, one that promises more without delivering closure.
The show also struggles with its mythology. The world of Purgatory is supposed to be a place where the dead linger, but the rules governing that world are inconsistent. Sometimes the dead can walk freely, and sometimes they cannot. Sometimes Wynonna can see them, and sometimes she cannot. These contradictions make it difficult to care about the stakes.
The Good Episodes
Not all of Wynonna Earp is bad. Some episodes stand out as genuinely excellent. The season premiere, “The Devil Went Down to Georgia,” sets the tone perfectly. It introduces the curse, the town, and the basic setup without wasting a minute. The episode is sharp, funny, and full of energy.
Another standout is “The Return of Bobobo,” which reintroduces the clown villain in a way that feels fresh. The show also excels at its action sequences, which are well-choreographed and shot with confidence. The fight scenes are a highlight, even when the story around them is shaky.
The Running Order
| Episode | Title | Plot Focus |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | “The Devil Went Down to Georgia” | Wynonna learns the curse |
| 2 | “The Return of Bobobo” | Bobobo returns |
| 3 | “The Curse Explained” | Wynonna digs into her family history |
| 4 | “The Town Under Siege” | A supernatural threat hits Purgatory |
| 5 | “The Final Stand” | Wynonna faces off against the season’s big bad |
The Verdict
Wynonna Earp is a show that is better than its reputation suggests. It is not a masterpiece, but it is not a failure either. It is a show that knows what it wants to be and delivers it with confidence. The performances are strong, the action is exciting, and the tone is consistently entertaining.
The problems are real, though. The plot is thin, the mythology is inconsistent, and the characters are underdeveloped. The show’s refusal to take itself seriously is both its charm and its flaw. It is a show that rewards casual viewing but frustrates closer inspection.
The show’s second season improved on its first, tightening the plotting and deepening the mythology. The third season ended the series on a high note, wrapping up the main storylines satisfactorily. For those who stuck with it, the ending delivered on the promise of the premise.
For new viewers, the first season is a mixed bag. The good episodes are worth watching, but the bad ones are forgettable. The show is best enjoyed as a guilty pleasure, not a serious investment.
Wynonna Earp is a show that rewards patience and punishes indecision. It is a show that is better in memory than in execution. It is a show that is fun to watch but not a show that stays with you.
Get the Notebook.
The day's best stories and every fresh verdict, in plain English, in your inbox by seven. One email a day, no more.
