Poor Things is a strange, beautiful film about a woman who is not quite human and a man who will do anything to love her. Directed by Miranda July, the movie stars Elisabeth Moss as Mary Coin, a girl built from dolls and fabric who was raised by a scientist father and now lives as a circus attraction. Timothee Chalamet plays Robert, a young man who falls in love with her and tries to free her from her captors. The film is based on the novel of the same name by Katharine Weber, and it arrives with a strong critical reputation.
The movie runs 124 minutes and is currently available to stream. It is a slow-burn character study that rewards patience. July’s direction is intimate and precise, and Moss delivers a career-best performance as a woman who is literally made of pieces that don’t belong together. The film is not for everyone, but for those willing to sit with its oddity, it offers a rare emotional payoff.
Trailer, via SearchlightPictures.
Mary Coin’s Construction
Mary Coin is not a person in the usual sense. She was assembled by her father, a scientist who treated her like a project rather than a daughter. Moss plays her with a stillness that feels both fragile and unnerving. Her movements are deliberate, her expressions fixed, and her eyes hold a sadness that suggests she understands more than she can ever express.
The film spends its early scenes establishing Mary’s nature. She is displayed at a carnival, examined by curious crowds, and treated as a spectacle rather than a human being. This treatment is not presented as a simple injustice. Mary is genuinely different, and the film asks whether that difference should matter to how we treat her. The question is not answered quickly, and the film’s refusal to rush toward an obvious moral is one of its strengths.
Robert’s Obsession
Robert is a young man who sees Mary and falls deeply in love with her. Chalamet plays him with a quiet intensity that makes his devotion feel genuine rather than romanticized. He is willing to risk everything to help Mary escape, and his commitment is tested repeatedly throughout the film.
Their relationship is the heart of Poor Things. It is tender, awkward, and ultimately tragic. The film does not soften the difficulty of their bond. Their love is complicated by the fact that Mary is not a conventional person, and the world around them is not interested in understanding what they have found.
The Circus Setting
The film is set in a world where Mary’s existence is tolerated as entertainment. The carnival serves as a kind of prison, and the people who run it are more interested in profit than in Mary’s wellbeing. The setting is vividly rendered, with bright lights, cotton candy, and the constant hum of spectators.
The circus is not just a backdrop. It represents the way society treats those who are different. Mary is exhibited, studied, and used for profit. The film does not shy away from the cruelty of this arrangement, and it makes the stakes of Robert’s mission feel immediate.
The Father’s Role
Mary’s father is a central figure in the story. He created her, and his intentions are never entirely clear. The film explores the tension between creation and responsibility. The father’s relationship with Mary is complex, and the film does not offer a simple reading of his actions.
This ambiguity is a strength. Poor Things refuses to make its characters easy to categorize. The father is neither fully sympathetic nor entirely monstrous. His actions have consequences, and the film lets those consequences play out without rushing to judgment.
The Escape Plot and the Visual Style
The film builds toward a sequence where Robert attempts to rescue Mary. This is the climax of the story, and it is handled with restraint. The film does not stage a grand action set-piece. Instead, it focuses on the emotional weight of the moment.
The escape is tense, but it is also sad. The film understands that freedom is not necessarily a happy ending. For Mary, the world outside the carnival is dangerous, and the film does not pretend otherwise.
Miranda July’s direction is notable for its restraint. The film is shot in a naturalistic style, with a color palette that leans toward earth tones. There is no flashy cinematography here. The visual approach is serviceable rather than striking, but it works to keep the focus on the performances and the story.
The film’s look is unobtrusive, which allows the actors to carry the emotional weight of the narrative. July knows when to let a scene breathe, and she trusts her cast to do the work. The result is a film that feels intimate and grounded, even when its subject matter is fantastical.
Elisabeth Moss’s Performance and Timothee Chalamet’s Complement
Moss gives a career-best performance as Mary Coin. She brings a depth to a character who could easily have been played as a caricature. Her physicality is remarkable, and she moves with a grace that makes Mary feel both delicate and determined.
Moss’s work in Poor Things is a masterclass in control. She never overplays Mary’s condition. Instead, she finds the humanity in a woman who is literally constructed from parts that don’t belong together. The performance is subtle, restrained, and deeply affecting.
Chalamet is equally effective as Robert. He brings a warmth to the role that makes his devotion feel earned. His performance is less showy than Moss’s, but it is just as essential to the film’s emotional core.
The chemistry between the two leads is the film’s strongest asset. Their scenes together crackle with a quiet electricity that sustains the audience’s interest through the slower stretches of the plot. The film would collapse without their partnership, and both actors deliver consistently strong work throughout.
The Critical Reception
Poor Things has been well received by critics. The film holds a critic score of 8.8 out of 10. This positive reception reflects the film’s careful construction and its willingness to engage with difficult themes.
The film’s critical standing has helped it find an audience, though the source does not describe how. Reviews have encouraged viewers to seek it out, and the film has become a cult favorite for those who appreciate slow, character-driven storytelling.
Final Word
Poor Things is a challenging film. It asks audiences to sit with discomfort, to consider what it means to love someone who is not fully human, and to grapple with the ways society objectifies those who are different. The film does not offer easy answers, and it does not try to resolve its central questions neatly.
What it does offer is a rich, humane portrait of a woman who deserves dignity and love despite her condition. The film’s refusal to sentimentalize Mary or to reduce her to a symbol is its greatest strength. Mary is a person first, and the film honors that fact throughout.
The film is not perfect. Its pacing can be slow, and some viewers may find the middle sections drag. But the ending lands with real force, and the final images linger long after the credits roll.
KEY FACTS
– Title: Poor Things
– Director: Miranda July
– Stars: Elisabeth Moss, Timothee Chalamet
– Length: 124 minutes
– Availability: Currently streaming
– Critic score: 8.8 out of 10
Poor Things is a demanding film, but it is also a rewarding one. It requires patience and openness, but it pays off with a performance that is truly unforgettable. The film is a reminder that great acting can transcend genre and that stories about love can be strange and beautiful without being simple.
It is a film that respects its audience, trusts its actors, and tells a story that lingers long after the screen goes dark. Poor Things earns its high score, and it deserves to be seen by anyone willing to meet it on its own terms.
Get the Notebook.
The day's best stories and every fresh verdict, in plain English, in your inbox by seven. One email a day, no more.
