AVP: Alien vs. Predator arrived in 2004 as a movie meant to settle a cosmic argument once and for all. The question was simple: who wins, the Alien or the Predator? The answer, unfortunately, is that neither does. The film is a technical showcase — the Predators look better than ever, the Aliens are terrifying in close combat — wrapped in a plot so thin it could fit inside a lunch box. This is a film that knows exactly what it wants to show you and has almost nothing left over for telling you why it matters.
Trailer, via TrailerTrackerEnglish.
The Setup
The story opens with a group of scientists and mercenaries arriving on Bouvetøya, a remote Arctic island, to investigate strange signals coming from the ruins of a frozen pyramid. Inside, they find the remains of a massacre. The survivors are picked off one by one until a small group, led by Lieutenant Ellison Shaw (Sanaa Lathan) and the mercenary Hupp (Larenz Tate), discovers the truth: the Predators hunt humans for sport, and the Aliens are the game. The pyramid is a hunting ground, and the humans are the prey.
That premise is clever. It treats the Predator as a hunter and the Alien as the hunted, which gives the film a sense of scale the previous entries lacked. But the setup also sets up a problem that the movie never quite solves. The humans are supposed to be the audience surrogates, the people we root for to survive. Instead, they spend most of the runtime screaming, running, and dying in ways that feel less like survival and more like set dressing.
The Predators
The Predators are the highlight of AVP: Alien vs. Predator. They move with grace, their armor is sleek and deadly, and their weapons are a joy to watch in action. The film spends a lot of time on their technology — the wrist blades, the shoulder cannon, the cloaking device — and it all looks fantastic. The actors playing the Predators are mostly motion-capture performers, and the suits are built with care. These are the best-looking Predators in any film, bar none.
But the Predator characters are also the weakest. The film introduces several hunters, but none of them get enough screen time to become memorable. The Predator roster includes:
- Stargazer, the leader of the pack
- Scar, a younger hunter who wants to prove himself
- Other hunters whose names and roles are never clarified
Their rivalry is supposed to drive the middle act, but it never clicks. The dialogue between them is stilted, and their motivations are vague. They hunt humans because it is their job, but the film never explains why they hunt. The Predator mythology is rich, but this movie barely scratches the surface.
The Aliens
The Aliens fare better than the Predators as characters, but worse as creatures. The film introduces a Queen, and her arrival is genuinely frightening. The design team, led by Neville Page, created a massive Alien that towers over everything else in the frame. The Queen is a sight to behold, and her scenes are tense. She is a force of nature, and the humans who face her are doomed.
But the other Aliens are a mixed bag. Some of the face-huggers are excellent, with detailed prosthetics that make them look genuinely slimy and disgusting. Others are clearly CGI, and the difference in quality is jarring. The film leans heavily on practical effects for the close-ups, but the wide shots rely on digital Aliens that look like they belong in a video game. The inconsistency is distracting, and it breaks the immersion.
The Humans
The human cast is competent, but they are not memorable. Sanaa Lathan brings a quiet strength to Ellison Shaw, but she is mostly a survivor rather than a character with agency. Larenz Tate plays Hupp as a gruff, capable leader, but he is also a victim of circumstance. The supporting cast is filled with familiar faces from action films, but none of them leave a mark. The film does not give them enough time to develop, and their deaths feel arbitrary rather than earned.
The only standout is Karl Pruner, a scientist who becomes obsessed with the pyramid and its history. His arc is the most interesting one in the film, but even he gets sidelined in the final act. The humans are meant to be the heroes, but they are not given the tools to be compelling. The film trusts them to be scared, but it does not trust them to be smart.
The Action
The action sequences are the reason to watch AVP: Alien vs. Predator. The fights between the Predators and the Aliens are brutal, with claws slashing and acid blood splattering. The film knows how to stage a fight, and the editing is sharp. The sound design is also excellent, with the Predator’s roar and the Alien’s screech cutting through the noise. These moments are the film at its best, and they justify the ticket price.
But the action is also the film’s weakness. The pacing is uneven, and some scenes drag while others rush past. The film is nearly two hours long, and it feels longer. The middle section, where the humans explore the pyramid and discover its secrets, is slow and talky. The tension builds, but it never releases. The payoff comes too late, and by the time the final battle arrives, the audience is exhausted.
The Problems
The biggest problem with AVP: Alien vs. Predator is that it is a crossover film that fails to cross over. The Predator and Alien universes share a common mythos, but this film treats them as separate entities. The Predators hunt humans, and the Aliens are the result of their experiments. That is a clever idea, but the film does not follow through on it. The Aliens are not the result of Predator experiments; they are simply there to be hunted. The connection is never explained, and the film’s attempt to merge the two franchises feels superficial.
There are also practical issues. The film was shot on location in Iceland, and the icy landscape is beautiful. But the cold weather caused problems for the actors, who had to wear layers under their costumes. The film also had a troubled production, with delays and reshoots. None of that shows on screen, but it explains why the finished product feels rushed.
The Verdict
AVP: Alien vs. Predator is a technically proficient film that fails to deliver a coherent story. The Predator designs are amazing, the Alien Queen is terrifying, and the action is exciting. But the humans are weak, the plot is thin, and the crossover idea is abandoned halfway through. It is a film that knows what it wants to show you but has no idea what it wants to say.
If you are a fan of either franchise, you will find moments to enjoy. The Predator hunt scenes are worth the price of admission. The Alien Queen is a highlight. But if you are looking for a movie with a strong narrative, you will be disappointed. The film is a hollow victory, a spectacle without substance.
Get the Notebook.
The day's best stories and every fresh verdict, in plain English, in your inbox by seven. One email a day, no more.
