“Torchwood” premiered in 2006 as a spinoff of “Doctor Who,” and it quickly established itself as a darker, more adult cousin of the BBC science fiction staple. The series follows a team of investigators who work for Torchwood, a secret government agency that deals with alien threats in modern-day Cardiff. It runs for three seasons, each exploring a distinct theme and tone. The result is a show that rewards attention but occasionally loses focus.
The core premise is simple: aliens are real, and Torchwood captures them for study. Jack Harkness, played by John Barrowman, leads the team with a charm and a past that make him the heart of the operation. His character carries over from “Doctor Who” and brings a bisexual swagger that was rare on British television at the time. The show also features Gwen Cooper, played by Eve Myles, whose arc moves her from civilian to full-time agent.
Trailer, via HereComeTheDrums.
Cardiff as Character
The series is set in Cardiff, Wales, which serves as a character in itself. The city’s Millennium Centre provides a distinctive backdrop, and the show makes frequent use of its streets, parks and landmarks. This setting allows the show to feel grounded even when dealing with monsters and time travel. The Welsh identity is woven into the fabric of the show, giving it a local flavor that distinguishes it from other British sci-fi properties.
Jack Harkness
Barrowman’s performance anchors the series. Jack is a rogue time agent who has lived for centuries, and he carries a weariness and a sense of humor that make him a compelling lead. His relationship with Ianto Jones, played by Gareth David-Lloyd, adds a layer of tenderness to the show. Their dynamic is one of the strongest elements of the series, and it is often cited as a highlight of the show’s early seasons.
The show also explores Jack’s complicated history, including his role in a war that left him trapped in a time loop. These flashbacks add depth to his character and give the audience a sense of his longevity. The writers use Jack’s backstory to explain why he is so invested in the Torchwood mission, and the character’s refusal to age becomes a running joke that never grows stale.
Tonal Whiplash
Where “Torchwood” struggles is in balancing its tone. Some episodes lean heavily into horror, with unsettling monsters and tense atmospheres. Others dip into comedy, with Jack cracking jokes and the team bantering. This tonal whiplash can be jarring, especially when an episode tries to be both funny and frightening at once. The show’s willingness to shift gears is admirable, but it sometimes leaves the viewer unsure what kind of story they are watching.
The third season, in particular, is uneven. Some episodes are sharp and memorable, while others feel like filler. The show’s attempt to build a mythology around the Weevils, a race of insectoid creatures that live beneath Cardiff, is ambitious but not always well-executed. The Weevils become a recurring threat, but their presence is not always integrated smoothly into the plot.
The Third Season
The third season is the weakest of the trilogy. It introduces new characters and locations, but it loses some of the intimacy that made the earlier seasons work. The show attempts to expand its scope, bringing in larger-scale threats and more complex political intrigue. While this expansion has its moments, it dilutes the personal stakes that defined the earlier series.
The season also sees the departure of several key cast members, which changes the dynamic of the team. The show handles these departures with varying degrees of success, and some fans found the final episodes disappointing. The third season ends on a cliffhanger that was later resolved in the subsequent series, but the resolution felt rushed compared to the buildup.
What Works
- The chemistry between Jack and Ianto is consistently strong.
- Cardiff is used effectively as a character in its own right.
- The show’s willingness to explore mature themes sets it apart from mainstream sci-fi.
- John Barrowman’s performance remains the highlight of the series.
What doesn’t work as well:
- The tonal shifts can be jarring and confusing.
- The third season feels bloated and less focused.
- Some episodes rely too heavily on monster-of-the-week storytelling.
The show’s strengths are substantial. Its exploration of sexuality, grief and loss is handled with a maturity that was unusual for British television at the time. The show does not shy away from difficult subjects, and it often uses its sci-fi framework to explore human behavior in extreme circumstances. This willingness to engage with serious topics is one of the reasons the show remains relevant to viewers today.
“Torchwood” is a show that demands attention. It rewards viewers who are willing to sit through its weaker episodes to get to the ones that work. The series is at its best when it focuses on character relationships and its central mystery. When it wanders into generic monster territory, it loses some of its edge. Overall, the show is a solid entry in the Doctor Who franchise, and it stands on its own as a worthwhile watch for fans of the genre.
Get the Notebook.
The day's best stories and every fresh verdict, in plain English, in your inbox by seven. One email a day, no more.
