ROBLOX. VIDEO GAMES. MOVIES. ORIGINAL ANIMATIONS.
CLAY TRIBUNE.
Advertisement

GoldenEye Review: Brosnan’s Debut Is a Solid, Half-Rebooted Bond

GoldenEye review: Pierce Brosnan's 1995 Bond debut, Judi Dench as the first female M, Sean Bean as 006, and a franchise reboot that half works.

By mitch·8 min read
A man in a suit stands on a snowy mountain peak overlooking a city lit at night.

GoldenEye arrived in 1995 after the longest gap in the Bond series’ history, and it carries the weight of that pause in every frame. The film is the seventeenth entry in the Eon Productions run, the first to star Pierce Brosnan as James Bond, and the first in the series to draw no story elements from Ian Fleming’s novels. It is also the first Bond film made after the dissolution of the Soviet Union, which gives its villain a motive the series had never tried before.

Martin Campbell directed from a screenplay by Jeffrey Caine, Bruce Feirstein and Michael France, with the story conceived and written by France. The film runs 130 minutes. It is an adventure, action and thriller picture with a tagline that promises “No limits. No fears. No substitutes.” It does not entirely deliver on that promise, but it gets closer than the six-year wait had any right to expect.

Trailer, via James Bond 007.

Advertisement

Pierce Brosnan Takes Over From Timothy Dalton

The casting story behind GoldenEye is almost as dramatic as the plot. Timothy Dalton’s contract expired during the legal disputes that stalled the series, and he chose to leave the role. Brosnan, who had been blocked from succeeding Roger Moore in 1986 by his contract to star in Remington Steele, finally got the part. He was introduced at a press conference at the Regent Palace Hotel on 8 June 1994.

Before the producers settled on Brosnan, Mel Gibson, Hugh Grant and Liam Neeson all passed. Neeson said his then fiancée Natasha Richardson would not marry him if he accepted. Ralph Fiennes met with the producers about the part and later played Gareth Mallory, the M of Skyfall, Spectre and No Time to Die. Paul McGann auditioned and was the studio’s second choice if Brosnan declined.

Brosnan was paid $1.2 million out of a total budget of $60 million. He plays Bond as a man who has been at this a while and has not enjoyed it. The performance is the film’s steadiest asset.

Judi Dench Becomes the First Female M

The film recast M, with Judi Dench replacing Robert Brown and becoming the first woman to portray the character. The decision is widely believed to have been inspired by Stella Rimington, who had become head of MI5. Dench’s M is brisk and unimpressed by Bond, and she treats him as a tool rather than a hero.

Samantha Bond replaced Caroline Bliss as Miss Moneypenny. Desmond Llewelyn was the only actor to reprise a previous role, returning as Q, the head of Q Branch. That continuity matters. Llewelyn is the one thread tying this new model to the old one.

GoldenEye was also the first Bond film not produced by Albert R. Broccoli. He stepped down from Eon Productions and was replaced by his daughter Barbara Broccoli alongside Michael G. Wilson, though Broccoli stayed on as a consultant producer. It was his final film project before his death in 1996.

Alec Trevelyan and the Janus Crime Syndicate

The plot opens in Arkhangelsk, where MI6 agents James Bond and Alec Trevelyan infiltrate a clandestine Soviet chemical weapons lab. Trevelyan appears to be executed by the facility’s commanding officer, Colonel Arkady Grigorovich Ourumov. Bond destroys the site and escapes in a stolen airplane.

Nine years later, after the Soviet Union dissolves, Bond tries to stop Xenia Onatopp, a member of the Janus crime syndicate, from hijacking a Eurocopter Tiger attack helicopter during a military demonstration in Monte Carlo. He fails. The stolen helicopter turns up at a radar site in Severnaya, Siberia, and an electromagnetic pulse blast wipes out the site and several Russian fighter jets while knocking out satellite systems in orbit.

M assigns Bond to investigate after the blast is traced to a Soviet-era satellite armed with a nuclear electromagnetic pulse space-based weapon, codenamed “GoldenEye.” Janus is suspected, but Bond suspects Ourumov, now a general, because the weapon required high-level military access.

In Saint Petersburg, Bond contacts CIA operative Jack Wade, who points him to Valentin Dmitrovich Zukovsky, a former KGB agent turned gangster, to arrange a meeting with Janus. Escorted by Onatopp, Bond learns Janus is led by Trevelyan, who faked his death. Trevelyan wants vengeance for his parents, Lienz Cossacks betrayed by the British and repatriated to the Soviet Union after collaborating with the Axis powers during World War II.

The Supporting Cast Does the Heavy Lifting

Sean Bean plays Trevelyan as a mirror of Bond, and the film is smartest when it lets that mirror do the work. Bean’s 006 is what Bond could have become. The script does not push the idea as hard as it could, but Bean sells it.

Famke Janssen’s Xenia Onatopp is a Georgian fighter pilot and Trevelyan’s henchwoman, and she is the most memorable creation here. Izabella Scorupco plays Natalya Simonova, a programmer at the Severnaya lab and the sole survivor of the GoldenEye attack on its own control centre. She is given more to do than the average Bond woman and handles it.

Robbie Coltrane plays Zukovsky, the Russian gangster and ex-KGB officer. Joe Don Baker plays Jack Wade, a veteran CIA officer. Baker previously played the villainous Brad Whitaker in The Living Daylights in 1987 and would return as Wade in Tomorrow Never Dies in 1997.

Alan Cumming plays Boris Grishenko, a computer programmer at Severnaya later revealed as a Janus affiliate. Gottfried John plays Ourumov, a Hero of the Soviet Union and Commander of Russia’s Space Division who secretly works for Janus. Tchéky Karyo plays Russian Defence Minister Dimitri Mishkin. Michael Kitchen plays Bill Tanner, M’s chief of staff. Serena Gordon plays Caroline, an MI6 psychological and psychiatric evaluator Bond seduces at the start.

What GoldenEye Gets Right and Wrong

The film’s best decision is its villain’s motive. Trevelyan is not a madman with a laser. He is a man with a grievance rooted in a real historical betrayal, and that makes him the most interesting antagonist the series had produced in years. The Cold War is over, and the film knows it. That gives GoldenEye a nervous energy the later Brosnan entries would lose.

The worst decision is the pacing. At 130 minutes, the film sags in its middle stretch. The Saint Petersburg section takes too long to arrange a meeting the audience already knows is coming. Campbell stages the action cleanly but rarely with urgency.

Here is how the film’s key figures line up:

Character Actor Role in the story
James Bond Pierce Brosnan MI6 officer assigned to stop Janus from acquiring GoldenEye
Alec Trevelyan Sean Bean Rogue ex-MI6 agent, fakes death, builds Janus over nine years
Natalya Simonova Izabella Scorupco Severnaya programmer, sole survivor of the attack
Xenia Onatopp Famke Janssen Georgian fighter pilot, Trevelyan’s henchwoman
Jack Wade Joe Don Baker Veteran CIA officer on the same mission as Bond
Valentin Zukovsky Robbie Coltrane Russian gangster and ex-KGB officer
M Judi Dench Head of MI6, first woman to play the role

Ranking the Pieces That Work

Judged on its parts, GoldenEye breaks down like this, from strongest to weakest:

  1. Sean Bean as Alec Trevelyan, the villain whose grievance gives the film its spine.
  2. Judi Dench as M, a recast that reset the series’ power dynamic.
  3. Famke Janssen as Xenia Onatopp, the henchwoman who steals every scene she is in.
  4. Pierce Brosnan as Bond, a confident debut that never quite finds a darker register.
  5. The satellite plot, a serviceable Cold War leftover that the film cannot fully modernize.
  6. The 130-minute runtime, which lets the middle act drift.

That ordering is the review in miniature. The film’s strengths are its people. Its weakness is its structure.

The Six-Year Gap Shows

GoldenEye had to do two jobs at once: reintroduce Bond to an audience that had moved on, and justify the series’ existence after the Cold War removed its natural enemy. It does the first job well and the second job halfway.

The film’s answer to the second question is Trevelyan, and it is a good answer. A Bond villain motivated by British betrayal is a sharper idea than a foreign power with a superweapon. But the film keeps retreating to the superweapon anyway, and the satellite plot is the least interesting thing in it.

Compare the two halves of the film’s ambition. The Trevelyan material is personal, historical and specific. The GoldenEye weapon is abstract, generic and interchangeable with a dozen other Bond doomsday devices. Whenever the film chooses the second over the first, it gets smaller.

A Reboot That Only Half Reboots

The production facts tell the story. This is the first Bond film with no Fleming story elements, the first without Albert R. Broccoli producing, the first with a female M, and the first made after the Soviet Union ceased to exist. Every one of those breaks is real.

But the film’s shape is still the old shape. Bond gets briefed, Bond travels, Bond meets a contact, Bond infiltrates the villain’s lair, Bond wins. The new pieces are dropped into a familiar frame rather than replacing it.

That is not a failure. It is a compromise, and a commercially sensible one. But it explains why GoldenEye feels like a transition rather than a reinvention. The series would not truly test its new freedom until later entries, and not all of those tests worked either.

The Verdict on GoldenEye

GoldenEye is a solid Bond film with one great idea and a lot of good casting. Brosnan is a credible 007 from his first scene. Bean gives the film a villain worth remembering. Dench’s M changes the temperature of every scene she is in. Janssen is the most fun the series had had in a decade.

Against that, the film is too long, its central threat is its dullest element, and it never commits fully to the revenge story it sets up. The six-year gap is visible in the pacing, even where it is invisible in the performances.

This is a film that relaunched a franchise by borrowing the franchise’s own history and pointing it at a new target. It works often enough to justify the return. It does not work consistently enough to be the best of the Brosnan run.

The Notebook

Get the Notebook.

The day's best stories and every fresh verdict, in plain English, in your inbox by seven. One email a day, no more.

We send one note to confirm. Every issue has a one-click way out.

Film reviews
Advertisement

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

As an Amazon Associate, Clay Tribune earns from qualifying purchases.