Apple TV’s Murderbot has a problem it never solves, and the problem is the same one its hero has: it would rather be watching something else.
The series, created by Paul Weitz and Chris Weitz and based on Martha Wells’ All Systems Red, premiered May 16, 2025, and ran 10 episodes through July 10. It stars Alexander Skarsgård as the rogue security construct who has secretly gained free will and mostly wants to binge soap operas. That premise is funny for about twenty minutes. Murderbot stretches it across a full season, and the strain shows in the parts that should be the show’s whole reason to exist.
Trailer, via Apple TV.
Skarsgård Plays a Machine That Watches TV
The setup is a good joke told at feature length. Murderbot is a private security construct, manufactured from cloned human tissue and mechanical parts, assigned to protect a team of scientists on a dangerous planet. It has hacked its own governor module. It could walk away. Instead it tags along on the mission, hides its autonomy, and resents every second it spends being useful.
The twist is that Murderbot is not cold. It is drawn to the humans it guards and appalled by their weakness, both at once. Skarsgård plays that split with a flat affect that occasionally cracks. Noma Dumezweni’s Mensah is the scientist who treats him as something closer to a person, and the show is at its best when the two of them share a scene and nothing explodes.
The cast around them is deep. David Dastmalchian is Gurathin, Sabrina Wu is Pin Lee, Akshay Khanna is Ratthi, Tamara Podemski is Bharadwaj, Tattiawna Jones is Arada. That is a lot of names for a first season, and the show does not always give them enough to do.
The Comedy and the Danger Never Quite Meet
Murderbot is billed as science fiction action comedy, and the genre label is doing more work than the scripts. The action sequences are competent. The comedy lands when it stays small — a robot sulking through a job it could refuse, a machine that would rather be anywhere else. The drama wants to be about personhood. Those three modes sit next to each other more often than they blend.
The result is a season that feels like it is still introducing itself when it ends. Ten episodes is not a short order, but Murderbot spends several of them establishing a tone it then abandons.
What the First Season Gets Right
The voiceover. The premise’s central irony — a being with total freedom choosing to keep working — is the show’s sharpest idea, and it survives the uneven pacing.
Skarsgård’s restraint. He never plays the robot as cute. Murderbot is irritable, not adorable, and the performance keeps the character on the right side of that line.
Martha Wells. The author of The Murderbot Diaries serves as a consulting producer, and the adaptation tracks the first book, All Systems Red, closely enough that fans of the source will recognize the shape of it.
Where the Season Loses Its Grip
The supporting scientists. Seven named cast members and a mission, and most of them register as obstacles or exposition rather than people. The show keeps telling us Murderbot is drawn to humans; it rarely gives us a human worth being drawn to.
The soap operas. Murderbot’s obsession with serialized drama is the funniest thing in the premise and the least developed thing on screen. The show treats it as a running gag when it could be the engine.
The ending. The season closes on a mission completed and a second season already ordered in July 2025. It reads as a setup, not a conclusion.
Murderbot by the Numbers
| Detail | |
|---|---|
| Network | Apple TV |
| Created by | Paul Weitz, Chris Weitz |
| Based on | All Systems Red, book one of The Murderbot Diaries by Martha Wells |
| Episodes, season 1 | 10 |
| First aired | May 16, 2025 |
| Last aired | July 10, 2025 |
| Renewed | July 2025, for season 2 |
| Genres | Comedy, Drama, Sci-Fi & Fantasy |
| Lead | Alexander Skarsgård as Murderbot |
The Case for the Show’s Central Trick
Here is what Murderbot gets right, and it is not a small thing. The show understands that the funniest version of a free robot is not a robot that rebels. It is a robot that complies, badly, while privately judging everyone.
That is the whole engine. Murderbot could leave. It stays because the alternative is boredom and because, despite itself, it cares. The show knows this. It just does not trust the idea to carry an episode without a firefight or a crisis to break up the monotony.
When it does trust the idea — when Skarsgård is alone with a screen and a bad mood — Murderbot is genuinely good television. Those moments are too rare across ten episodes.
The Hard Numbers on Murderbot
- Score: 7.0 of 10
- Metacritic: 70/100
- Season 1: 10 episodes
- Premiere: May 16, 2025
- Finale: July 10, 2025
- Renewed for season 2: July 2025
- Source novel: All Systems Red by Martha Wells
- Network: Apple TV
What Season 2 Has to Fix
The renewal is the right call, because the raw material is stronger than the execution. Martha Wells wrote a narrator with a distinctive voice — paranoid, funny, weirdly tender — and the show has cast the right actor to deliver it.
What it has not done is decide what kind of show it wants to be. A comedy about a robot avoiding work is one thing. A drama about a constructed being learning to care about fragile people is another. Murderbot keeps promising both and delivering a version of each that undercuts the other.
The fix is not more plot. It is fewer scientists with nothing to say, more time inside Murderbot’s head, and the willingness to let a scene be quiet. The show has proven it can do that. It has not proven it wants to.
A 7.0 is a fair score for a first season that is more interesting than it is good — a show with a great character, a great cast, and a structure that has not caught up to either. Murderbot is worth watching. It is not yet worth the devotion its premise invites.
Get the Notebook.
The day's best stories and every fresh verdict, in plain English, in your inbox by seven. One email a day, no more.