The Girl Next Door wants to be two movies at once, and the 2004 release never settles the argument. Luke Greenfield directs a film that opens like a teen romance, turns into a porn-industry thriller, and closes with a prom-night scheme that belongs to neither. It premiered at the Texas Film Festival on February 18, 2004, before 20th Century Fox put it in theaters nationwide on April 9, 2004. Our score: 4.7 of 10.
Trailer, via PakoMorientes.
Emile Hirsch as Matthew Kidman
Emile Hirsch plays Matthew, a suburban California high school senior who has been accepted to Georgetown University and cannot pay for it. As class president he raises $25,000 so a Cambodian student, Samnang Sok, can study in the United States. His friends Eli Brooks and Tim Klitz care more about mischief and adult films than anything else. Hirsch got the part after Greenfield watched an audition tape he had recorded for Gus Van Sant’s Elephant.
Elisha Cuthbert and the Casting That Stuck
Elisha Cuthbert plays Danielle Clark, the neighbor who moves in next door. The studio wanted Katie Holmes. Greenfield insisted on Cuthbert, who had just finished Old School. “She was so hungry. I remember meeting her and she had done so much preparation,” Greenfield said. “She had all these pictures of different looks that Danielle would have. She was 20 years old at the time. She was talking about the character and she had such maturity.”
That is the film’s best decision. Cuthbert holds the screen, and the movie is steadier whenever she is in it.
Timothy Olyphant plays Kelly, Danielle’s ex-boyfriend and manager, after Brad Pitt passed on the project. Olivia Wilde, who had worked as a casting intern on the film, makes her screen debut in a minor role as high school student Kellie.
A Plot That Keeps Changing Its Mind
Matthew falls for Danielle, learns from Eli that she is a former adult film actress, and takes her to a motel on bad advice. She ends the relationship and considers going back to the industry. He tracks her to an adult film convention in Las Vegas and confronts Kelly, then talks her out of returning.
Kelly retaliates. He abducts Matthew and forces him to steal from a rival producer, Hugo Posh. Matthew escapes police capture, arrives at a scholarship dinner on ecstasy, gives an impromptu speech, and loses the award. Kelly then poses as a school advisor and takes the $25,000. Danielle’s fix is to produce an adult film at the senior prom, with Eli directing and Klitz in a key role.
What the Movie Is Actually Selling
Strip the premise down and The Girl Next Door is Risky Business with a meaner streak. The screenplay drew partly from that 1983 film, and the debt shows in every act break. But Risky Business kept its farce inside one night. This film keeps escalating past the point where the joke lands.
| Element | The Girl Next Door (2004) |
|---|---|
| Director | Luke Greenfield |
| Writers | David Wagner, Stuart Blumberg, Brent Goldberg |
| Runtime | 110 minutes |
| Genres | Comedy, Romance |
| Lead cast | Emile Hirsch, Elisha Cuthbert |
| Score | Paul Haslinger |
| Cinematography | Eric Alan Edwards |
| Tagline | “Matt never saw her coming… but all his friends had!” |
The tagline is honest about the problem. It promises a comedy about a kid in over his head. The finished film keeps reaching for something heavier — the Vegas confrontation, the abduction, the ecstasy speech — and the tonal shifts never cohere.
The Kelly Problem
Kelly is where the movie loses its footing. Olyphant is a real presence, and the part is written as a threat rather than a joke. But the film cannot decide whether he is a villain or a punchline, so he is neither. The extortion, the stolen scholarship fund, the coerced theft from Hugo Posh — none of it connects to the romance the film opened with.
The adult-industry material is handled with more care than most 2004 comedies managed, and retrospectives have credited the film for subverting the genre. That credit is earned in pieces, not across the whole runtime.
Numbers Behind the Release
- Release: April 9, 2004, by 20th Century Fox
- Premiere: Texas Film Festival, February 18, 2004
- Runtime: 110 minutes
- Metacritic: 47/100
- Scholarship fund in the plot: $25,000
- Hirsch and Cuthbert signed on: October 2002
- Olivia Wilde’s screen debut
Why the Cult Following Makes Sense
The Girl Next Door was made for a specific moment and missed it. Reviews were mixed, with praise for the performances and complaints about the tonal inconsistencies, and it underperformed at the box office. Home media and television did the work the theatrical run could not.
You can see why. Cuthbert is genuinely good. The premise has a hook. The prom sequence is absurd enough to be memorable. None of that makes the film work as a whole.
What This Paper Makes of It
The Girl Next Door is a romance that keeps interrupting itself with a crime plot it cannot carry. Hirsch is fine, Cuthbert is better, and Olyphant is stranded between two movies. The screenplay’s debt to Risky Business is structural, not incidental, and it never finds its own ending.
The cult status is real and the genre subversion is real. Neither rescues the middle. What the film needed was to trust its own romance and cut the Kelly material down to a single threat.
Get the Notebook.
The day's best stories and every fresh verdict, in plain English, in your inbox by seven. One email a day, no more.
