Michael Bay’s 13 Hours: The Secret Soldiers of Benghazi runs 144 minutes and ends with a title card promising that six men did what was right. The film spends most of that runtime trying to earn the line, and it never quite does.
Trailer, via Paramount Pictures.
The Annex and the Compound
The setup is clean. Benghazi, 2012, after the fall of Muammar Gaddafi. Most embassies have pulled out. The U.S. keeps a diplomatic compound open, and less than a mile away sits a CIA outpost called the Annex, guarded by private contractors from Global Response Staff. Jack Silva (John Krasinski) arrives as the new man and is picked up by Tyrone “Rone” Woods (James Badge Dale), the team commander and an old friend.
Bay stages the geography well. The distance between the two buildings is the whole engine of the film, and he makes you feel every yard of it. The CIA Chief-of-Station tells the team never to engage the citizens. Ambassador Chris Stevens (Matt Letscher) arrives to keep diplomatic channels open and, against warnings, stays at the Special Mission with two Diplomatic Security agents, Wickland and Ubben, plus local guards from the February 17th Martyrs Brigade.
On the eleventh anniversary of September 11, Stevens spots men photographing the compound. He tells his security detail. That night, militants from Ansar al-Sharia attack.
When the 17-Feb Guards Walk Away
The compound falls fast. The 17-Feb guards surrender their posts, and the attackers walk in. Wickland gets Stevens and an IT specialist named Smith into the safe room. The militants can’t breach it, so they set the building on fire. Wickland escapes. Stevens and Smith do not.
When everything went wrong, six men had the courage to do what was right.
That tagline is the film’s thesis, and it’s also its problem. The Annex team spends the back half of 13 Hours fighting to get to a compound they were ordered not to leave, and Bay shoots it as a series of escalating night battles. The action is loud, legible and exhausting in roughly equal measure.
What the Cast Carries
Krasinski plays Silva as a man counting the days until he goes home; early on he learns his wife is pregnant. It’s the film’s only quiet thread, and he holds it. Dale gives Woods a worn authority that the script doesn’t always give him room to use.
Pablo Schreiber, Max Martini, Dominic Fumusa, David Denman and Toby Stephens fill out the six-man team, and the film is better when it lets them talk to each other than when it cuts to the fire.
Chuck Hogan’s screenplay, based on Mitchell Zuckoff’s 2014 book, takes historical liberties that drew criticism on release. Bay’s direction drew a split response too: some saw his over-the-top action as the wrong register for a true story, others called it his most mature and grounded work. Both readings are defensible. Neither fully wins.
The Numbers Behind It
- Runtime: 144 minutes
- Release date: January 15, 2016 (Paramount Pictures)
- Production budget: $50 million
- Worldwide gross: over $69 million
- Metacritic: 48/100
- Filming began: April 27, 2015, in Libya
- Oscar nomination: Best Sound Mixing, 89th Academy Awards
The box office is the tell. Against a $50 million budget, $69 million worldwide made 13 Hours one of Bay’s lowest-grossing films. An Oscar nomination for sound mixing is a real achievement, and the mix is genuinely the most disciplined craft on display here.
What actually matters is the gap between the film’s ambition and its method. Bay wants a tribute to six contractors who chose to fight. He has the cast for it, and a true story with a clear moral shape. What he doesn’t have is restraint. Every emotional beat gets a slow-motion flag or a swelling score, and the effect is to flatten men who were, by all accounts, ordinary and scared into symbols.
The sound mixing nomination is deserved. The rest is noise dressed as reverence. 13 Hours is watchable, occasionally moving, and ultimately a lesser film than its subject earned.
Get the Notebook.
The day's best stories and every fresh verdict, in plain English, in your inbox by seven. One email a day, no more.
