Apple TV’s Home Before Dark premiered on April 3, 2020, with a hook that sounds like a pitch meeting fever dream: a nine-year-old investigative journalist moves from Brooklyn to a small coastal town, starts asking questions, and drags up a cold case the whole town buried. The series ran two seasons and 20 episodes, ending on August 13, 2021. It scored a 6.4 out of 10 across published reviews. That number is fair. The show is likable, well-acted and built on an unusual premise, but it never decides whether it wants to be a kids’ adventure or a grown-up mystery, and that split costs it.
Trailer, via Apple TV.
Brooklynn Prince Makes Hilde Lisko Believable
Dana Fox and Dara Resnik created the series, and it is inspired by the life of young journalist Hilde Lysiak. That inspiration is the show’s best asset and its heaviest burden. Brooklynn Prince plays Hilde Lisko, and she is the reason to watch. Prince has to sell a child who out-reports every adult in town, and she does it without the smugness that role usually invites. She is stubborn, nosy and occasionally wrong, which makes her believable.
Around her, the cast is deep. Jim Sturgess plays Matt Lisko, the father who left this town behind and clearly has reasons. Abby Miller is Bridget Jensen. Kylie Rogers plays Hilde’s sister Izzy. Michael Weston is Lt. Frank Briggs, Jr., and Louis Herthum is Sheriff Frank Briggs, Sr. — a pairing that tells you most of what you need to know about how power works in this town. Aziza Scott is Deputy Mackenzie “Trip” Johnson III. Joelle Carter plays Principal Kim Collins, Adrian Hough is Mayor Jack Fife, and Jibrail Nantambu and Deric McCabe round out the younger cast as Donny Davis and Wesley “Spoon” Witherspoon.
The Cold Case Is the Engine
The premise, per the show’s own framing, follows a young girl who moves from Brooklyn to the small coastal town her father left behind, where her dogged pursuit of the truth leads her to unearth a cold case that everyone in town, including her own father, tried hard to bury. That is a strong engine. A kid asking questions adults have agreed not to answer is a machine for generating tension, and Home Before Dark gets real mileage out of it.
The problem is that the show keeps softening the payoff. A cold case buried by an entire town should feel dangerous. Too often the stakes get resolved in a scene where an adult is gently embarrassed into telling the truth. The mystery is competent. It is rarely frightening.
What the Show Gets Right
- The central performance. Prince is the anchor, and the show knows it.
- The family unit. Matt, Bridget and Izzy give Hilde something to lose beyond the story.
- The town as a character. A coastal community with a shared secret is a durable setting.
- The generational split. Sheriff Briggs Sr. and Lt. Briggs Jr. put two eras of local power in the same room.
The Hard Numbers
- Network: Apple TV
- Created by: Dana Fox and Dara Resnik
- First aired: April 3, 2020
- Second season premiered: June 11, 2021
- Final episode aired: August 13, 2021
- Seasons: 2
- Episodes: 20
- Genres: Mystery, Drama
- Published critical score: 6.4/10 (Metacritic 64/100)
Casting came together fast. Brooklynn Prince was announced in the lead role on August 17, 2018. Jim Sturgess joined in a starring role on October 23, 2018. By November 2018, Abby Miller, Louis Herthum, Michael Weston, Kylie Rogers, Aziza Scott, Adrian Hough, Joelle Carter, Jibrail Nantambu and Deric McCabe had all signed on as series regulars. That is a full ensemble assembled in roughly three months, and it shows in how comfortably the adults inhabit the town.
Where the Show Loses Its Nerve
Home Before Dark has a tonal problem it never solves. The show wants Hilde to be a real journalist — she pursues the truth, she follows leads, she confronts people — but it also wants her to be a child who needs protecting. Those two impulses fight each other in almost every episode. When Hilde is onto something, the adults around her alternate between obstruction and concern, and the pattern gets repetitive across 20 episodes.
The second season, which premiered June 11, 2021, does not fix this. It extends it. By then the show has settled into a rhythm: new mystery, same resistance, same resolution. The format is sturdy enough to survive that, but sturdy is not the same as surprising.
What the show never does is let Hilde be genuinely outmatched. She is a kid in a town of adults with secrets, and yet she wins nearly every confrontation. That flatters the premise and drains it. A young journalist story works best when the truth is hard to get and costs something. Here, the truth is usually one more conversation away.
What 6.4 Out of 10 Actually Means
Home Before Dark is a good show for a specific appetite. If you want a mystery a family can watch together, with a strong child lead and a cast that clearly enjoys the material, it delivers. Prince is genuinely excellent, and the Lisko family works as a unit in a way many shows never manage.
But the 6.4 is not an accident. The show is caught between two audiences and never commits. It is too gentle to be a real thriller and too serialized to be a clean procedural. The cold case at its center should be the scariest thing in the room, and it almost never is.
Two seasons and 20 episodes is, in the end, about right. The show said what it had to say about Hilde Lisko, her father’s town and the secrets underneath it. It just never found the nerve to make those secrets hurt.
Get the Notebook.
The day's best stories and every fresh verdict, in plain English, in your inbox by seven. One email a day, no more.