Twist and Shout is the Beatles’ second album, and it is a machine built for one job: making teenagers move. Released in 1964, it collects the furious, breathless side of the band’s early repertoire. This is not the studio-whisper pop of later years. It is a record of covers and quick originals, played at a pace that suggests the band was afraid the tape would run out before they finished.
The album’s purpose is simple. It wants to be loud, immediate, and slightly dangerous. The title track’s reputation — that “pounding beat” and those “bloodcurdling John Lennon screams,” as the New Musical Express put it — anchors the whole project. The rest of the record orbits that performance, trying to catch some of its heat.
It does not always succeed. But when it does, the result is a snapshot of a band at its rawest, before the suits and the studio trickery smoothed the edges.
Opening With a Slow Burn
The record opens with Anna (Go to Him), a slow, aching cover that lets the lead vocalist play the wounded romantic. It is a strange way to start a party record. The tempo is a crawl, and the vocal is strained rather than sweet. It works, but it works as a palate cleanser, not a statement of intent.
Then comes Chains, a bright, jangling piece of girl-group pop. The voice here is lighter, less urgent than on the opener. The song bounces along on a handclap rhythm, but it feels like a polite version of what the band could do. It is pleasant. It is not thrilling.
Boys changes the mood instantly. The drums are up front, the harmonies shout rather than sing, and the whole thing sounds like a live show caught on tape. It is the first moment on the album where the band sounds like they are having fun.
Ask Me Why pulls back again. It is an original, but a soft one, with a slightly dreamy vocal and a melody that wanders. It feels like a B-side, which it was. It is not a bad song. It is just not a song that demands attention.
The Originals Hold Their Ground
Please Please Me arrives with a harmonica riff and a sense of purpose. This is the band as hitmakers, and the track has a drive the earlier covers lack. The call-and-response vocal is tight, and the chorus lands with real force. It is the first track on the record that sounds like the band’s future.
Love Me Do follows, and it is the odd one out. The song is simpler, more folk-adjacent, with that signature harmonica line carrying the melody. It is historically important, but on this album it feels slight. It is a promise of what was coming, not a fulfillment of it.
From Me to You is better. The hook is infectious, and the track moves at a brisk clip. It is another original, and it shows the band could write pop that did not need a cover version to give it life. The harmonies are clean, the rhythm is propulsive, and it earns its place.
P.S. I Love You returns to the slower, sweeter side. It is a letter set to music, and it is fine. It is not a standout, but it does not embarrass anyone. It is the kind of track you skip on a playlist but tolerate on an album.
Covers That Carry the Middle
Baby It’s You is a cover, and it is a highlight. The vocal is raw and pleading, and the arrangement builds to a proper climax. The backing vocals are pure girl-group, but the band plays it with enough grit to make it their own. This is the album’s second-best performance after the title track.
Do You Want to Know a Secret is another original, and it is a quiet one. The voice here is gentle, almost shy. The song is slight, but it has a charm that the more aggressive tracks lack. It is a breather, and the album needs it.
A Taste of Honey is the weakest moment on the record. It is a ballad, played straight, and the band sounds uncomfortable with it. The vocal is strained, the arrangement is thin, and the song never finds a groove. It is the only track here that feels like filler.
There’s a Place picks the pace back up. It is another original, and it has a driving rhythm and a harmonica line that recalls the band’s earlier singles. It is not a classic, but it is solid, and it sets the table for the finale.
The Centerpiece Arrives
Twist and Shout is the reason this album exists. The vocal is a full-throated roar, ragged and almost out of control. The band behind it is locked in, and the track builds to a frenzy that still sounds wild 62 years later.
It is the moment the album has been building toward. Every slower track before it was a setup. This is the payoff.
She Loves You closes the record, and it is a smart choice. The song is a hit, and it is a strong one, with a chorus that refuses to leave your head. It is a victory lap, and it sends the listener out on a high note.
An Image That Outlasted the Music
The album’s cover photograph has its own reputation. The Telegraph called it “one of the key images of the 1960s.” It shows the four band members in matching suits, leaning forward, with a slightly manic energy that matches the music inside. It is a portrait of a band at full speed, and it has aged better than most album art from the era.
The image matters because it sells the record’s promise. This is a band that looks like it is about to jump out of the frame. The music mostly delivers on that.
Sorting the Strong From the Weak
Not every song earns its place. A Taste of Honey is a misstep. Ask Me Why and P.S. I Love You are pleasant but forgettable. Love Me Do is more historically significant than musically exciting.
- Anna (Go to Him) — slow, aching, a decent opener
- Chains — bright and polite, a little too tame
- Boys — loud, fun, a standout moment
- Ask Me Why — soft and dreamy, a B-side at heart
- Please Please Me — a real hit, full of drive
- Love Me Do — historically important, musically slight
- From Me to You — infectious hook, strong original
- P.S. I Love You — sweet, forgettable
- Baby It’s You — raw and pleading, a genuine highlight
- Do You Want to Know a Secret — gentle, charming, quiet
- A Taste of Honey — the weak link, thin and strained
- There’s a Place — solid, unspectacular
- Twist and Shout — the centerpiece, still electric
- She Loves You — a strong closer, a real hit
The balance is roughly two-thirds hits to one-third filler. That is a good ratio for a 1964 album, when the standard was often lower.
Final Judgment
This is a record of its moment. It captures a band that had not yet learned to be subtle, and that is its strength. The covers are played with a ferocity that the originals sometimes lack, and the originals show a songwriting team finding its footing in real time.
The album is not a masterpiece. It is too uneven for that. But it is a document of a band at a specific point, and that point was loud, fast, and exciting.
The title track alone is worth the price of admission. The rest of the record supports it, sometimes well and sometimes barely. But the energy is consistent, and the energy is the point.
It is a record that wants to be played loud, in a room full of people, with the volume turned up past the point of comfort.
That is what it does best.
8 of 10.
Get the Notebook.
The day's best stories and every fresh verdict, in plain English, in your inbox by seven. One email a day, no more.
- Anna (Go to Him)2:55
- Chains2:22
- Boys2:25
- Ask Me Why2:22
- Please Please Me2:00
- Love Me Do2:22
- From Me to You2:00
- P.S. I Love You2:02
- Baby It’s You2:33
- Do You Want to Know a Secret1:55
- A Taste of Honey2:01
- There’s a Place1:50
- Twist and Shout2:32
- She Loves You2:23
