Before she was Olivia Benson, Mariska Hargitay was a sitcom actress who lost the role of Monica on Friends to Courteney Cox. She also had a brief, memorable turn on Seinfeld.
Hargitay appeared in the first half of the two-part Season 4 finale, “The Pilot,” playing Melissa Shannon, an actress reading for the role of Elaine in Jerry Seinfeld’s show-within-a-show, “Jerry.” It was a small part, but it came at a moment when Hargitay thought her future was in comedy, not crime drama.
A Guest Spot on “The Pilot”
Hargitay’s career before Law & Order: Special Victims Unit was built on guest spots and sitcom auditions. On Amy Poehler’s podcast “Good Hang,” she said she spent years trying to break into comedy, testing repeatedly for the role of Monica on Friends.
“I tested for ‘Friends’ so many times,” she said. “I always thought that I would end up being on a sitcom or doing comedy, that’s what I thought.”
Courteney Cox got the part. Hargitay kept working anyway, landing a co-starring role on the one-season CBS show Can’t Hurry Love and appearing in three episodes of NBC’s The Single Guy. Then came ER, where she played Cynthia Hooper, the ditzy girlfriend of Dr. Mark Greene, played by Anthony Edwards. She appeared in 13 episodes during the fourth season of the medical drama.
The Psychic’s Prediction
After her ER run ended, Hargitay’s life changed direction. A psychic told her it would.
Hargitay was in New York when a friend suggested she visit the psychic. She described the encounter on Poehler’s podcast, recalling that the man predicted she would move to the Big Apple and become famous.
“I said, ‘Uh, no, I live in L.A., and I’m gonna be a comedian because I’m funny, and I’m pretty, and that is a deadly combination.’ And he looks at me — and this is my favorite moment in my life — and he goes like this, ‘I don’t give a rat’s ass what you say.’ Six months later, swear to God, I got ‘SVU.'”
The Friends Near-Miss
The Friends audition is a piece of television trivia that still follows Hargitay. She tested for Monica multiple times, but the role went to Cox. Hargitay has said she expected to land a sitcom, and the fact that she did not is part of what made her eventual success on SVU so unexpected.
The psychic’s blunt dismissal — “I don’t give a rat’s ass what you say” — became the punchline to her own career arc.
From Sitcoms to SVU
The shift to SVU was dramatic. The show is a hard-hitting crime drama, far from the tone of Can’t Hurry Love or The Single Guy. Hargitay has played Olivia Benson on Law & Order: Special Victims Unit, becoming one of the most recognisable detectives on television.
What the Seinfeld Role Shows
Looking back, the Seinfeld appearance is a snapshot of a performer before her defining role. Melissa Shannon is a bit part, but it is a funny one — a woman auditioning for a part in a show about a comedian making a show. She did not get Monica, but she got Olivia Benson instead, and that changed everything.
Key Facts
- Role: Melissa Shannon on Seinfeld, Season 4 finale “The Pilot” (part one of two)
- Audition: Tested multiple times for the role of Monica on Friends
- Lost the part to: Courteney Cox
- Other sitcom work: Can’t Hurry Love (one season, CBS), The Single Guy (three episodes, NBC)
- TV drama: Cynthia Hooper on ER, 13 episodes in Season 4
- Podcast: Amy Poehler’s “Good Hang”
- Psychic prediction: Move to New York and become famous; six months later she got SVU
The Seinfeld role was brief, but it was not the last time Hargitay played someone trying to get a part. She spent years auditioning for comedies, and she has said she thought she would end up on a sitcom. Instead, she became one of the most enduring figures on television drama, playing a detective whose seriousness is the opposite of the funny, pretty comedian she once planned to be.
The psychic, by her account, was right. She became famous, and she did it on SVU — not on a laugh track.
Source: tvline.com
Get the Notebook.
The day's best stories and every fresh verdict, in plain English, in your inbox by seven. One email a day, no more.