DAHMER – Monster: The Jeffrey Dahmer Story is a true-crime drama that asks a simple question: how does a normal man become a monster? The answer is not simple. It is slow, painful, and often repetitive, but it is also effective. The show follows Jeffrey Dahmer’s life from his awkward youth in Ohio to his capture in Milwaukee, Wisconsin, in 1991. It is a grim watch, but it is a necessary one.
The series is based on the book Monster: The True Story of the Serial Killer Who Terrorized America by John Teague. It stars Evan Peters as Dahmer and is directed by Michael Urie. The show premiered on Netflix in September 2022. It ran for seven episodes and received widespread acclaim, earning a Metacritic score of 8.0 out of 10.
Trailer, via Rotten Tomatoes TV.
Evan Peters and the Early Years
Evan Peters plays Dahmer with a quiet intensity that makes the character both sympathetic and terrifying. He is not a cartoon villain. He is a lonely, confused young man who never quite fits in. His performance carries the weight of the entire series.
The show spends a significant amount of time in Dahmer’s childhood. We see him bullied at school, struggling with his sexuality, and drifting through a series of dead-end jobs. His mother, played by Susan May Pratt, is distant and emotionally unavailable. The show suggests that this neglect was a key factor in Dahmer’s descent into violence.
The early episodes are the strongest. They establish the character’s humanity without excusing his actions. We understand why he is lonely, but we never forgive what he does. The show makes us feel both pity and revulsion simultaneously, which is a rare achievement.
The Killing Begins
The middle episodes shift focus to Dahmer’s first murders. The show does not flinch from the violence, but it also does not glorify it. The killings are shown in brief, unsettling flashes rather than full-on gore. This restraint works. It makes the horror feel more real than a wall of blood ever could.
The show also explores Dahmer’s psychological profile. He collects trophies from his victims, dissects their bodies, and keeps their remains. These behaviors are not explained away as madness. The show presents them as logical extensions of a mind that has stopped processing reality normally.
The show’s pacing slows down in the middle. Some episodes feel padded, repeating information we have already heard. This is a fair complaint, but it does not sink the overall experience.
The Milwaukee Years
The final episodes move to Milwaukee, where Dahmer commits his most notorious crimes. The show tracks his interactions with the people he kills, including his roommate and his coworkers. It also covers the investigation that eventually leads to his capture.
The performances in these episodes are strong across the board. The supporting cast includes Jimmi Simpson as Dahmer’s friend Ed Gein and Tim Blake Nelson as his coworker John Smith. These characters provide a human context for the crimes, making the horror more personal.
The show’s ending is deliberately unsatisfying. It does not resolve anything. It simply stops. This is a bold choice, and it works. The show leaves the audience with a sense of unease rather than closure.
Directing and Style
Michael Urie directs with a cold, clinical eye. The show is shot in a muted palette, with most scenes taking place in dim, claustrophobic interiors. This visual style reinforces the emotional tone of the story. It is a show about isolation, and the visuals reflect that.
The score, composed by Mike Hill, is sparse and atmospheric. It uses piano motifs and low drones to create a sense of dread. It is effective without being overbearing.
The production design is meticulous. The sets accurately recreate the apartments and houses where the crimes took place. This attention to detail adds to the show’s authenticity.
The Criticism
DAHMER – Monster: The Jeffrey Dahmer Story was praised for its performances, direction, and restraint. Critics noted that the show avoided sensationalism while still delivering a powerful narrative. The series was also commended for its exploration of the psychological factors that drove Dahmer’s behavior.
The show was criticized for its pacing in the middle sections and for its repetitive structure. Some viewers found the show too slow, particularly in the episodes that cover Dahmer’s mundane daily life. These criticisms are valid, but they do not detract from the overall impact.
The show’s success was also notable in the streaming era. It became one of Netflix’s most-watched original series upon release, demonstrating the continued appetite for true-crime content.
The Legacy
DAHMER – Monster: The Jeffrey Dahmer Story is a flawed but compelling work of television. It is not for everyone. The subject matter is disturbing, and the pacing can be uneven. However, when it works, it works brilliantly. It offers a nuanced portrait of a man who committed monstrous acts, without losing sight of the humanity that made him capable of those acts.
The show succeeds because it refuses to simplify. It shows Dahmer as a complex individual, shaped by trauma and loneliness, but ultimately responsible for his own actions. This balance is rare in true-crime media, and it makes the show stand out.
The show also raises uncomfortable questions about society’s role in shaping individuals. It suggests that Dahmer’s crimes were not inevitable, but that they were enabled by a system that failed to help him. This is a powerful message, delivered with skill and restraint.
Key Facts
– Title: DAHMER – Monster: The Jeffrey Dahmer Story
– Premiere: September 2022, Netflix
– Episodes: 7
– Runtime: Full series runs approximately 6 hours
– Metacritic score: 8.0 out of 10
DAHMER – Monster: The Jeffrey Dahmer Story is a demanding watch, but it is a rewarding one. It is a show that stays with you long after the credits roll. It is not perfect, but it is essential viewing for anyone interested in true crime or character-driven drama. The score is 8 of 10.
Get the Notebook.
The day's best stories and every fresh verdict, in plain English, in your inbox by seven. One email a day, no more.
