The image of a pencil so small it can’t be held was posted to r/mildlyinfuriating, and readers there have split into two camps. The poster’s mother wanted to throw it away, and the poster said their mother reportedly did not want them “to live in misery” over a pencil.
The Two Sides
The poster disagreed, writing, “It’s not about the price, I feel guilty when the pencil still has worth.” That final sentence quickly became the center of the discussion. Some Reddit users focused on the pencil’s size, while others questioned the attachment behind keeping it.
A reader came to the mother’s defense and pointed out that short pencils can put a strain on the hand. Another person responded with “Excellent point – hands are worth more than pencil stubs.”, which the original writer addressed by saying “I put it in a straw to make it longer.”.
“I put it in a straw to make it longer,” the poster wrote. That prompted another commenter to joke, “Well now you just wasted a straw!” The poster replied that they reused the straw.
The Pencil Extender Debate
A pencil extender was proposed by several users as a more conventional approach. One person said that these devices allowed them to keep going with costly colored pencils once the regular ones grew too uncomfortable to hold. A second user offered a brief endorsement, writing just “Consider a proper pencil extender.”.
The person who posted the image would not give up on the small pencil. Instead, they said they built their own extender using a straw, hot glue and a longer pencil. That fix won approval from many, yet plenty of Reddit users kept demanding the pencil be removed entirely. One user wrote, “You have to let go… walk into the light my sweet pencil.” while another summed it up even more briefly: “Just let go bro.”
“Excellent point – hands are worth more than pencil stubs.”
Why the Poster Feels Attached
Some commenters transformed the poster’s remorse over squandered worth into a query about why they felt so invested. A few pointed to signs of hoarding behavior, even though a Reddit discussion offers no clinical context and these labels hold no diagnostic standing.
A reader recounted how attaching feeling to possessions ultimately led them to gather far too much, while another told of a parent who held on to heaps of partly used pencils. Together, those accounts gave the conversation a more serious edge.
One commenter described fully using pencils and pens as a “niche pastime” and called the poster a completionist. One Reddit user told the poster they needed to learn how to let things go. Another commenter wrote, “That’s not even a pencil anymore dude.”
Some users came forward to support the poster’s resolve instead. A single commenter wrote, “No keep it and be proud of using it, if we all had your sense the world would be a lot cleaner.”
The Daily Dot relied on a post from r/mildlyinfuriating for this article. The site was unable to confirm the poster’s situation or the specifics of the argument with their mother.
The Daily Dot has no way to confirm the poster’s situation or the specifics of the exchange with their mother. Instead, it serves as a modest illustration of how online forums transform everyday moments into shared discussion.
Get the Notebook.
The day's best stories and every fresh verdict, in plain English, in your inbox by seven. One email a day, no more.