A post on r/AskReddit asked teachers to recall their brightest students and explain what became of them. The query drew responses that surprised many readers. Within nine hours, the thread had amassed 3,300 upvotes.
The Brightest Paths
Several narratives followed the usual path of conventional achievement. One person recounted a past pupil who moved on to a Ph.D. position at Stanford. Another told of a former student who took up teaching at ETH Zürich. A third person recalled a student who attended the University of Ottawa and later worked with a particle accelerator, holding an SAT score of 1,596.
A special education teacher told of a former student with behavioral issues who was ultimately diagnosed with early-onset schizophrenia. That teacher had previously believed the student would end up in prison or in a residential facility. Years later, the teacher encountered the former student again, studying to become a laboratory technician.
A teacher told of a former student with a disability who now works in a shop, taking pride in the fact that the student works full time with very little supervision. Other commenters spoke of students whose achievements revolved around independence rather than degrees, living and working on their own.
The Unpredictable Paths
Academic success did not always last beyond school for some people. A commentator noted that a former student performed well in school but had trouble in college. Another recalled a classmate who was academically gifted but dropped out shortly before final exams and never joined the workforce.
A person who finished school described their own path: they left high school with a weak GPA, quit college several times, joined the military, and came back to school to complete a degree in computer networking. That background led them to a job as a director at a major company.
A reader claimed to have dropped out of secondary education before returning to finish their studies and earning an electrical engineering degree summa cum laude at 32.
What Teachers Actually Care About
Intelligence does not determine a person’s life course, a common point made throughout the discussion. One teacher noted that most educators care more about whether a former student is happy than about conventional success. Another argued that a student’s potential is only one of many factors shaping their future.
A number of teachers spoke with particular pride about students who succeeded in reaching personal goals despite difficult circumstances. One of them summed up their experience by saying that what happens to people after they leave school is hard to predict.
A Measure of Success
| Outcome | Example |
|---|---|
| Conventional success | Ph.D. at Stanford, professor at ETH Zürich |
| Unexpected success | Laboratory technician after schizophrenia diagnosis, shop worker with a disability |
| Unpredictable failure | College dropouts, never entered the workforce |
| Military and late success | Director at a large company after military service |
What We Make of It
A teacher’s brightest student can end up anywhere, from a shop worker to a Ph.D. at Stanford, from a military career to a lab technician, according to the thread, proving that academic success does not determine one’s future.
What ties these responses together is the idea that intelligence is not the deciding factor in a person’s life path. The majority of those who commented expressed pride in students who discovered fulfillment beyond conventional measures of achievement, whether they earned a degree or merely learned to manage their own lives.
This serves as a reminder that the most accomplished student in a room cannot be measured simply through test results. Their worth comes from how they choose to apply their gifts, and that choice has no set form.
Source material: “Teachers Reveal Where Their Smartest Students Ended Up, And The Answers Defy Every Expectation,” The Daily Dot.
Get the Notebook.
The day's best stories and every fresh verdict, in plain English, in your inbox by seven. One email a day, no more.