Miloš Forman’s One Flew Over the Cuckoo’s Nest opens on a psychiatric ward that runs like a machine. Chief Bromden, a gigantic Euro-Indigenous American patient, presents himself as deaf, mute, and docile. He watches. What he watches is Randle Patrick McMurphy arrive and start pulling the machine apart.
McMurphy is a petty criminal who faked insanity to serve his sentence in a mental ward rather than prison. He expects an easy stretch. He finds Nurse Mildred Ratched, who runs the ward with absolute authority and little medical oversight, assisted by three day-shift orderlies and her assistant nurses.
The film, written by Lawrence Hauben and Bo Goldman, runs 135 minutes. It won five Academy Awards. It earns a 9.3/10.
Trailer, via Warner Bros. Rewind.
Randle Patrick McMurphy
Jack Nicholson plays McMurphy as a man who cannot stop moving. He runs a card table. He captains the ward’s basketball team. He comments on Nurse Ratched’s figure. He incites the other patients to conduct a vote about watching the World Series on television.
Each act is small. Each act is also a test of who controls the ward. Nurse Ratched, played by Louise Fletcher, does not raise her voice. She does not need to. She controls the routines, and the routines control the men.
The power struggle between McMurphy and Ratched is the spine of the film. It never resolves into a simple fight. McMurphy antagonizes her. She answers with procedure. The men watch and, slowly, start to choose sides.
The Control Panel in the Tub Room
McMurphy claims he can lift a heavy control panel in the defunct hydrotherapy room. He fails. His response — “But at least I tried” — gives the other men something to hold.
That line is the film’s engine. It is not a victory. It is a refusal to accept that the attempt was pointless. The patients begin to stand up for themselves instead of allowing Nurse Ratched to take control of every aspect of their lives.
Forman shoots the ward as a clean, orderly, disciplined world. The tagline asks who needs guys like McMurphy in a place like that. The film’s answer is that the place needs him precisely because it is so clean, orderly, and disciplined.
Billy Bibbit and Dale Harding
The ward is not a backdrop. It is a cast of specific men. Brad Dourif plays Billy Bibbit. William Redfield plays Dale Harding. Danny DeVito plays Martini. Sydney Lassick plays Charlie Cheswick. Christopher Lloyd plays Max Taber. Michael Berryman plays Ellis. William Duell plays Jim Sefelt.
Scatman Crothers plays Orderly Turkle. Will Sampson plays Chief Bromden. Dean R. Brooks plays Dr. John Spivey.
The film gives each man a face and a tic and a reason to be there. That is why the ward’s routines land. When Ratched controls the men, she is controlling people the audience has met.
The Fishing Trip and the Shock Therapy
McMurphy organizes a deep-sea fishing trip. The patients are to be “supervised” by his prostitute friends. The trip is a break in the ward’s order, and it is also a break in McMurphy’s own caution.
After the trip, a violent disturbance sends McMurphy and Chief Bromden for electroshock therapy sessions. The punishment does nothing to curb McMurphy’s rambunctious behavior.
This is the film’s clearest statement about its own subject. The ward’s tools do not fix the men. They confirm what the men already know about the ward. McMurphy comes back from the sessions and keeps going.
The Night Orderly and the Pharmacy
One night, after bribing the night orderly, McMurphy smuggles two prostitute girlfriends with liquor onto the ward. He breaks into the pharmacy for codeine cough syrup and unnamed psychiatric drugs.
The sequence is the film’s high point of disorder. It is also the point where the ward’s authority has to answer. Ratched does answer, and the answer is the film’s hardest scene.
The Chief, meanwhile, opens up to McMurphy. Late one night, he reveals that he can speak and hear. The man the ward treated as deaf and mute has been listening the entire time. That reveal reframes everything the audience has watched.
What the Film Gets Right
The novel by Ken Kesey was published in 1962. Dale Wasserman adapted it into a Broadway play in 1963, later off-Broadway. Bo Goldman adapted it into this 1975 film. Time magazine included the novel in its “100 Best English-language Novels from 1923 to 2005” list. In 2003 the book was listed on the BBC’s The Big Read poll of the UK’s 200 “best-loved novels.”
The film earns its place beside that book. It does not soften Ratched into a monster. Fletcher plays her as a woman doing a job, which is worse. It does not turn McMurphy into a hero. Nicholson plays him as a man who faked his way into a ward and then found something worth fighting for inside it.
The ranking of what matters here is not close.
- Louise Fletcher as Nurse Ratched — the film’s most controlled performance, and its most frightening.
- Jack Nicholson as Randle Patrick McMurphy — the engine that keeps the ward in motion.
- Will Sampson as Chief Bromden — the film’s eyes, and its final word.
- Brad Dourif as Billy Bibbit — the film’s most painful turn.
- The supporting ward — DeVito, Redfield, Lassick, Lloyd, Crothers, Berryman, Duell — the texture that makes the machine real.
The film’s reputation rests on the McMurphy-Ratched conflict, and that is fair. But the part worth watching is Sampson. Chief Bromden presents himself as deaf, mute, and docile for the entire film. When he finally speaks, the film’s whole argument about institutional control arrives at once. The ward never knew it had a witness.
One Flew Over the Cuckoo’s Nest is a drama about a psychiatric hospital that is also a study of institutional processes and the human mind, including a critique of psychiatry and a tribute to individualistic principles. It is 135 minutes and it does not waste them. The film won five Academy Awards, and it holds up as one of the clearest American films about what an institution does to the people inside it.
Get the Notebook.
The day's best stories and every fresh verdict, in plain English, in your inbox by seven. One email a day, no more.
