SoulCalibur IV arrived in 2008 as the fifth main entry in Namco’s weapon-based fighting series, and it did the thing a fighting game has to do to matter: it gave players a reason to keep coming back after the credits rolled. Project Soul built the game for PlayStation 3 and Xbox 360, published it through Namco Bandai Games, and packed it with a roster of 34 fighters, a revived Character Creation suite, and the series’ first real online multiplayer. It also put Darth Vader and Yoda in a sword-fighting game. That last part should have been a stunt. It mostly works.
Trailer, via Bandai Namco Entertainment America.
Tower of Lost Souls and the Modes That Carry It
The standard modes are here: Story, Arcade, Training, Museum. None of them is the reason to buy the game. The new Tower of Lost Souls is. Players climb a tower by winning battles, and each floor pays out rewards. It gives the single-player side a spine that Arcade mode never had, a reason to keep a created fighter sharp instead of parking them after one run through Story.
Story mode itself is thinner than the Tower. The plot centers on the ancient king Algol, his tower, and his link to the origin of the spirit sword Soulcalibur. Character motivations get explored in a mode called Chain of Souls. Most fighters want to obtain, destroy, or defend one or both of the legendary swords now held by Siegfried and Nightmare, and most face Algol as the final boss. Every character gets an animated ending cutscene.
The endings are not canon, as usual for the series. None of the individual endings from Soulcalibur III count as canonical events, and most characters’ motivations from that game remain unresolved. A few threads do carry over. Siegfried has died and been resurrected by Soulcalibur. Sophitia’s daughter Pyrrha was kidnapped by Tira and malfested by Soul Edge, which leaves Sophitia fighting on the side of evil to defend her corrupted daughter. Tira has a split personality disorder. These are the beats that stick.
A Roster of 34, and the Star Wars Problem
SoulCalibur IV fields 34 fighters. Veterans return. Two newcomers join. Three guest characters come from Star Wars: Darth Vader, Yoda, and The Apprentice.
The platform split was the story at launch. Darth Vader was exclusive to PlayStation 3. Yoda was exclusive to Xbox 360, and his inclusion was meant to represent the colors of the Xbox logo. The Apprentice, the main protagonist of Star Wars: The Force Unleashed, was playable on both platforms. Namco later made Vader and Yoda available on the opposite platform for a fee, which softened a split that had annoyed players on both sides.
The guest characters bring their own Force Meter mechanics, and that is where the crossover earns its place. They do not play like the rest of the roster. The Force Meter adds a resource layer to their combat that the sword fighters do not have, and it makes the Star Wars trio feel like a separate design problem rather than a skin swap.
Beyond the guests, the roster reaches into the series’ past. Revenant, Frederick Schtauffen, and several other minor characters appear in battle, and most can be created in Character Creation mode. Five bonus characters designed by manga artists are playable, using the fighting styles of returning characters: Angol Fear, Ashlotte, Kamikirimusi, Scheherazade, and Shura. They were designed by Mine Yoshizaki, Ito Ōgure, Hirokazu Hisayuki, Yutaka Izubuchi, and Hiroya Oku, respectively.
Character Creation Grows Up
Character Creation returns from Soulcalibur III, but it works differently. Instead of original weapon styles built for certain classes of fighters, SoulCalibur IV lets players pick which series character their created fighter mimics. That is a real loss. Soulcalibur III had unique styles like “Grieve Edge” that existed only for created characters. Here, your fighter borrows someone else’s moves.
The compensation is depth elsewhere. A wide array of new equipment pieces is available. New options include a broader range of character voices and the ability to adjust their pitch. Players can modify a character’s general physique and muscularity.
Equipped items now affect statistics. Armor, weapons, and accessories can raise health, attack, or defense. They can also grant skill points that unlock special traits affecting playstyle. Those traits include automatically triggered guard impacts, the ability to inflict damage on a blocking opponent, or a statistic increase based on parameters like an opponent’s alignment or gender. Standard characters can be modified the same way, though only modestly, which lets custom costumes and skill sets carry into Special VS. mode.
There is one hard limit: one profile is permitted for Offline VS. mode. That is a small thing that becomes a large one in a house with more than one player.
Online, Critical Finish, and the Rules Around Custom Fighters
Online multiplayer is new to the series here, and it arrives with two modes: Standard and Special VS. The distinction matters because of how equipment works. Custom characters can be used in Standard VS. mode, but without any special abilities gained through equipment or weapon choice. Their gear is cosmetic there. In Special VS., the stats and skills count.
The Critical Finish system adds another layer to combat. Combined with the Force Meter mechanics reserved for the guest characters, it gives SoulCalibur IV more strategic texture than a straightforward sword-fighting game would have.
The styles of Algol, the bonus characters, and the Star Wars guests cannot be used by player-created characters. That keeps the most distinctive move sets out of the creation pool, which is a defensible call and a disappointing one at the same time.
The game runs in HD resolution with 5.1 channel surround sound on both platforms.
What the Two Versions Actually Offer
| Feature | PlayStation 3 | Xbox 360 |
|---|---|---|
| Exclusive guest character at launch | Darth Vader | Yoda |
| Yoda’s design rationale | — | Meant to represent the colors of the Xbox logo |
| Shared guest character | The Apprentice | The Apprentice |
| Later guest access | Yoda for a fee | Darth Vader for a fee |
| Resolution and audio | HD, 5.1 surround | HD, 5.1 surround |
The table is the whole platform war in miniature. Both versions ran the same resolution and the same surround sound. The only thing that separated them was which Star Wars character you got, and Namco eventually sold you the other one.
Where the Fighting Actually Lives
The fighting is the point, and SoulCalibur IV does not neglect it. Visually realistic environments and interactive stages give the arenas more to do than serve as backdrops. Enhanced AI makes the single-player climb through the Tower of Lost Souls worth the time. The battle system is new, and it holds up against what Soulcalibur III offered in 2005.
The comparison to its predecessor is where the game gets interesting. Soulcalibur III had unique creation styles and no online play. SoulCalibur IV has online play and borrowed creation styles. The series traded a piece of its creative identity for a feature that every fighting game now needs. That trade was correct. It just was not free.
The Verdict on SoulCalibur IV
SoulCalibur IV is the installment that pushed the franchise into the next generation and set up what came after. It was followed by the handheld title Soulcalibur: Broken Destiny in 2009 and the full sequel Soulcalibur V in 2012.
The Tower of Lost Souls is the best addition here. It turns a fighting game’s single-player content into something with a shape and a payoff. The online modes are the necessary one. The Character Creation changes are the trade-off, and the loss of original creation styles stings more than the equipment system makes up for.
The Star Wars guests are the part people remember, and they are not a gimmick. The Force Meter gives Vader, Yoda, and The Apprentice a combat identity the rest of the roster cannot copy, and locking their styles out of Character Creation keeps that identity intact. The platform exclusivity was a marketing decision that aged badly once the other character became available for a fee, but it did not damage the game underneath.
What matters most is that SoulCalibur IV still plays like a Soulcalibur game. The swords, the roster, the Tower, the created fighters with their stat-boosted gear — it all serves the fight. That is why it holds up, and why the series kept building on it.
Get the Notebook.
The day's best stories and every fresh verdict, in plain English, in your inbox by seven. One email a day, no more.
