HBO’s The Outsider opens with a murder case that looks solved before the first episode is half over. A young boy is dead. The evidence points at a suspect, and the case seems airtight.
Then it isn’t.
Trailer, via HBO.
Richard Price Adapts Stephen King
The Outsider is a 10-episode miniseries based on Stephen King’s 2018 novel of the same name. Richard Price adapted the book for television and created the series. HBO ordered it on December 3, 2018, after MRC optioned it as a miniseries in June 2018.
It premiered on January 12, 2020, and closed its run on March 8, 2020.
Ben Mendelsohn and Cynthia Erivo Lead the Cast
Ben Mendelsohn plays Ralph Anderson, a seasoned cop whose certainty starts to come apart. Cynthia Erivo plays Holly Gibney, the unorthodox investigator pulled into the case. The two carry the show’s central tension: a man who trusts procedure and a woman who doesn’t.
The cast around them is deep. Bill Camp is Howie Gold. Paddy Considine is Claude Bolton. Julianne Nicholson is Glory Maitland. Jason Bateman appears and directed the first two episodes. Marc Menchaca, Mare Winningham, Jeremy Bobb and Yul Vazquez round out the ensemble.
A Murder Case That Turns Supernatural
The Outsider begins as a crime story. A boy is murdered. The investigation looks straightforward. Then an insidious supernatural force edges into the case, and the ground shifts under everyone.
That turn is the show’s whole gamble. Price and King built a procedural that stops behaving like one.
One Season, 10 Episodes, No Second Run
HBO passed on a second season in November 2020. MRC, the production company, intended to shop the series to other outlets. King said scripts for a second season were written. The cast and crew said they wanted to keep going.
None of that continuation came to pass on HBO. The Outsider ends where it ends.
What the Show Gets Right
The case at the center is built to be believed, and that is the point. The Outsider works best when it plays as a straight investigation, because the supernatural intrusion only lands if the procedural half holds. Mendelsohn’s Ralph is a man who does his job by the book, and Erivo’s Holly is the opposite — she reads people and situations that don’t fit the book.
The pairing gives the season its spine. Price’s adaptation keeps King’s premise intact and lets the two leads carry the weight.
Where It Slips
Ten episodes is a long time to hold a single turn. The Outsider spends its middle stretch circling a case the audience has already accepted is strange, and the show’s grip loosens there. The supernatural force is the engine, but the series is most alive in its early episodes, before the explanation starts arriving.
The finale resolves what it set up. It does not leave much behind.
What the Season Leaves Behind
The Outsider is a strong cast in service of a premise that only needs half its runtime. Mendelsohn and Erivo are the reason to watch, and the first two episodes — Bateman’s — are the sharpest. What follows is competent and slower.
The show’s cancellation in November 2020 was not a loss of an unfinished story. It was a story that had already said what it had to say.
KEY FACTS
- Score: 6.8/10
- Network: HBO
- Premiered: January 12, 2020
- Finale: March 8, 2020
- Episodes: 10
- Seasons: 1
- Metacritic: 68/100
Cast
- Ben Mendelsohn as Ralph Anderson
- Cynthia Erivo as Holly Gibney
- Bill Camp as Howie Gold
- Paddy Considine as Claude Bolton
- Julianne Nicholson as Glory Maitland
- Jason Bateman, director of the first two episodes
The Outsider is a case study in a good cast outrunning a thin premise. It is worth the first two episodes. It is a harder sell after that.
Get the Notebook.
The day's best stories and every fresh verdict, in plain English, in your inbox by seven. One email a day, no more.