X2 opens with a bang and never quite regains its footing. The sequel to 2000’s X-Men picks up where the first film left off, with the mutant population under attack from humans and from within. The result is a bigger, louder, and messier version of the original, one that trades quiet character moments for spectacle and loses some of the charm that made the first film work.
The film follows Charles Xavier (Patrick Stewart) and Erik Lehnsherr (Ian McKellen) as their opposing philosophies come to a head. Xavier believes mutants can coexist peacefully with humanity; Lehnsherr believes mutants must fight back. The plot strands branch out across the cast, with Wolverine (Hugh Jackman) tracking down a new mutant, Rogue (Anna Paquin) searching for a cure, and Nightcrawler (Alan Cumming) caught in the middle of a government conspiracy.
Trailer, via MovieStation.
Patrick Stewart and Ian McKellen Carry the Weight
Stewart and McKellen are the engine of X2. Their scenes together, particularly the ones where Lehnsherr’s past catches up with him, are the film’s best stretches. Their mutual history gives the philosophical conflict weight, and the actors play it with a subtlety that few of the other performances can match.
The film also introduces Cyclops (James Marsden) and Jean Grey (Famke Janssen) as a couple, which adds a layer of personal stakes to the wider conflict. Their relationship is tender, and Janssen brings a warmth to Grey that helps anchor her later, darker turns.
Hugh Jackman’s Wolverine Gets Lost in the Shuffle
Jackman is still excellent as Wolverine, but his role is diluted in X2. He spends a good chunk of the film chasing a new mutant named Pyro (Aaron Stanford), a subplot that feels like filler. The film is overstuffed, and Wolverine’s arc gets lost in the shuffle.
The action sequences are bigger and busier than in the first film. A climactic battle at the White House is a highlight, though the film leans on CGI more than practical effects. Some of the fights feel less grounded than the hand-to-hand combat in the original.
The Cameos and the Cast
The supporting cast gets stretched thin. Famke Janssen and Alan Cumming get less screen time than they deserve, and their characters feel like they were written in at the last minute to fill gaps. Rebecca Romijn-Stamos returns as Mystique, and she delivers a strong performance despite being underused.
“We are mutants, and we are everywhere.”
That line, delivered by McKellen, captures the film’s central tension. The mutants are not a monolithic group, and the film struggles to hold onto that diversity while juggling multiple storylines.
Anna Paquin’s Rogue and the Cure Plot
Paquin’s Rogue is the emotional center of the film. Her search for a cure drives much of the story, and her scenes with Bruce Davison’s Senator Robert Kelly are the film’s most human moments. The cure plot raises questions about identity and acceptance, but the film doesn’t fully explore them.
The villain, William Stryker (Bruce Davison), is a competent threat, but he lacks the charisma of Magneto or Professor X. His plan is elaborate, involving a hidden compound and a virus, but it feels like a device to move the plot forward rather than a genuine threat.
The Pace Problem
X2 is overlong. The runtime is generous, and the film could have used a tighter edit. The middle section drags, with too many characters and too many threads competing for attention. The film tries to do everything — a love triangle, a government conspiracy, a cure plot, a villain with a secret base — and none of it gets the room it needs.
The film also leans heavily on exposition, with characters explaining things to each other that the audience has already seen. This slows the pacing further and weakens the sense of discovery.
The Final Score
X2 is a worthy but uneven sequel. It has stronger performances and bigger set pieces than the first film, but it loses some of the intimacy that made X-Men work. The film is best when it focuses on its central characters, worst when it tries to do too much.
Key Facts
– Title: X2
– Year: 2003
– Director: Bryan Singer
– Runtime: Over 130 minutes
– Score: 6.8 of 10
X2 is a film that aspires to greatness but stumbles on execution. It is a solid entry in the franchise, but it falls short of the standard set by the first film. The performances are strong, the action is ambitious, and the ideas are big, but the film struggles to hold them all together.
Score: 6.8 of 10.
Get the Notebook.
The day's best stories and every fresh verdict, in plain English, in your inbox by seven. One email a day, no more.
