The Greatest Showman premiered on December 8, 2017, aboard the RMS Queen Mary 2 in New York City, then opened in the United States on December 20 through 20th Century Fox. Michael Gracey directed from a screenplay by Jenny Bicks and Bill Condon, working from Bicks’s original story. Hugh Jackman plays P. T. Barnum. The film runs 105 minutes and carries the tagline “The impossible comes true.”
Trailer, via 20th Century Studios UK.
Pasek and Paul’s Nine Songs
The musical numbers are the film’s strongest asset. Benj Pasek and Justin Paul wrote nine original songs; John Debney and Joseph Trapanese composed the orchestral score. “This Is Me,” sung by Keala Settle as the bearded lady Lettie Lutz, won the Golden Globe for Best Original Song and was nominated at the 90th Academy Awards. The soundtrack won Best Compilation Soundtrack. Rebecca Ferguson’s Jenny Lind performs “Never Enough,” and the film drew nominations for Best Motion Picture – Musical or Comedy and Best Actor – Musical or Comedy for Jackman at the 75th Golden Globe Awards.
Those honors are real. They also measure the gap between the songs and everything holding them up.
A Plot That Skips the Hard Parts
The Greatest Showman is a heavily fictionalized account of Barnum’s life. It follows him from boyhood, courting Charity while she attends finishing school, through marriage and two daughters, Caroline and Helen, in New York City. He loses a shipping-clerk job after a typhoon sinks his firm’s cargo vessels, secures a bank loan by deceptively using those lost ships as collateral, and opens Barnum’s American Museum. Slow ticket sales push his daughters to suggest something “alive.” He adds performers including Lettie and Charles Stratton, draws protests and bad notices from critic James Gordon Bennett Sr., renames the venture Barnum’s Circus, and recruits playwright Phillip Carlyle for publicity.
Phillip, played by Zac Efron, falls for trapeze artist Anne Wheeler, played by Zendaya, and hides it. The film arranges a meeting with Queen Victoria, then sends Barnum on tour managing Jenny Lind.
| Element | What the film gives it |
|---|---|
| Barnum’s fraud | A loan, then a shrug |
| The troupe | Songs, then distance |
| Phillip and Anne | Held hands, dropped fast |
| Jenny Lind | One showstopper, no fallout |
What the Artistic License Costs
The film’s problem is not that it bends history. It is that the bending removes every cost. Barnum’s deception over the collateral never returns to him. His decision to distance himself from his troupe, advising them to work without him, gets a defiant musical number instead of a consequence. Phillip’s parents see him holding Anne’s hand and he lets go; the film treats that as a wound but never as a choice with weight.
The performances are committed. Jackman sells the hunger. Settle sells the defiance. Michelle Williams, as Charity, gets almost nothing to do beyond waiting.
Barnum’s Story, Told Without Consequence
The Greatest Showman wants to be a film about people told they do not belong, made by a film that will not sit still long enough to show what belonging costs. The songs are genuinely good, and they carry the movie further than its script earns. But a musical rises or falls on whether the numbers grow from the story, and here they mostly replace it. What is left is a bright, well-sung advertisement for a man the film declines to examine.
The 4.8 score is not a punishment for optimism. It is what happens when craft this strong is spent protecting its subject instead of testing him.
Get the Notebook.
The day's best stories and every fresh verdict, in plain English, in your inbox by seven. One email a day, no more.
