“Don’t Toy with Me, Miss Nagatoro” opens with a boy crying in a library. That is the whole hook. Naoto Hachiouji, a second-year at Kazehaya High School, wants to draw manga alone. Hayase Nagatoro, a first-year, finds his sketchbook, calls him “Senpai,” and teases him until the tears come. It sounds cruel. It is, at first. Then it becomes something else, and the show’s willingness to sit in that discomfort is what makes it worth watching.
Trailer, via Crunchyroll.
The Library and the Sketchbook
The premise is a trap, and the series knows it. Senpai is an introvert who avoids people. Nagatoro is a first-year who enjoys tormenting him. She follows him to the art club room and keeps at it, mocking his timid personality and his otaku interests, sometimes in a sexually suggestive way. Early on, Senpai does not like her at all. He tries to stay away. He fails.
The show is adapted from Nanashi’s web manga, which ran in Magazine Pocket, Kodansha’s online and app-based magazine, from November 2017 to July 2024. The anime came in two pieces. Telecom Animation Film produced the first season, which aired from April to June 2021. OLM produced the second, which ran from January to March 2023. Across both, 24 episodes aired on Tokyo MX and BS11, from April 11, 2021 to March 26, 2023.
Nagatoro’s Real Feelings
Here is the turn the series takes, and it takes it slowly. Nagatoro does not just want to torture Senpai. She develops genuine feelings for him, and she becomes hostile toward anyone else who tries to bully him. The teasing is not the opposite of affection. It is how she reaches for it.
Senpai changes too. As Nagatoro keeps pushing him to be more assertive, he starts to come out of his shell. He realizes he is falling in love with her. He involves himself in her life. That arc, from a boy who wants to be left alone to a boy who makes a promise about a confession, is the spine of the show.
The friends matter more than they first appear to. Gamo, Yoshi and Sakura look like shallow girls who only want to torment Senpai. They catch on to the mutual crush. They become supportive and start scheming to bring the two closer. That shift keeps the series from being a two-hander.
Judo, the Art Club, and a Kiss
The second season widens the world. Sana Sunomiya, the art club’s semi-retired president, shows up and tries to shut the club down. After a contest with Senpai during the culture festival, she lets it continue. Then her younger cousin Hana joins the art club, and Nagatoro joins the judo club.
That judo arc carries the show’s biggest swing. Nagatoro enters a tournament and makes Senpai promise that if she beats her rival, Orihara, he will give her a kiss. Senpai thinks she is teasing. She insists she is serious. So he makes a promise of his own: if he scores first on his mock university entrance exam, he will confess.
That is the structure of the whole series in one exchange. Two people who cannot say what they mean, turning a confession into a wager. It is a device, and it works because the show has spent two seasons earning it.
Sumire Uesaka and Daiki Yamashita
The voice cast is doing real work here. Sumire Uesaka plays Hayase Nagatoro, and Daiki Yamashita plays Naoto “Senpai” Hachioji. Both are in the Japanese production. Kimberley Anne Campbell voices Nagatoro and Erik Scott Kimerer voices Senpai in the English dub.
Uesaka has the harder job. Nagatoro has to be annoying and adorable in the same breath, and the performance never lets one cancel the other. Yamashita’s Senpai is quieter, and that is the point. He is a boy learning to occupy a room.
The show’s genres, per its listings, are animation, comedy and drama. That is accurate, and it undersells the drama. The comedy is the surface. The drama is what happens when the teasing stops being a game.
What the Teasing Is Actually Doing
A show built on a boy being reduced to tears by a girl invites a fair question: is this mean, or is this tender? “Don’t Toy with Me, Miss Nagatoro” answers by refusing to separate them. Nagatoro’s cruelty and her care come from the same impulse. She pushes because she wants him to push back.
That is also the show’s biggest risk. For a stretch in the first season, the balance tilts toward discomfort, and a viewer could reasonably walk away. What pulls it back is the supporting cast and the slow reveal that Nagatoro’s friends see the crush before either principal does. The scheming gives the series a second engine.
The art club and the judo club give it a third. Senpai’s drawing is not a hobby he abandons. It is the thing that made Nagatoro notice him. Nagatoro’s judo is not a side plot. It is where she puts her own stake on the line.
The Score, and What It Measures
“Don’t Toy with Me, Miss Nagatoro” holds an 8.2 out of 10 audience score on TMDB across 830 votes. That number is not a verdict on the animation, which is competent rather than remarkable, or on the pacing, which drags in places. It is a verdict on the relationship at the center, which lands.
The order of what matters here, from most to least:
- The Senpai-Nagatoro dynamic and its slow reversal from torment to mutual feeling.
- The judo tournament and the double promise, the show’s best-constructed arc.
- Gamo, Yoshi and Sakura, who turn the premise from a two-hander into an ensemble.
- The Sunomiya cousins, who give the art club a second life in season two.
- The voice performances, which hold the tone together.
- The production split between Telecom Animation Film and OLM, which is invisible in the final product.
The manga’s run ended in July 2024 after starting in November 2017. The anime’s 24 episodes cover a fraction of that. What the adaptation gets right is the thing that made the manga work: it never lets the audience forget that Nagatoro’s teasing is a form of attention, and that attention is what Senpai has been missing.
The show is not for everyone. The early episodes are hard to sit through, and that is a feature, not a flaw. “Don’t Toy with Me, Miss Nagatoro” asks you to trust that the cruelty is going somewhere, and it earns that trust by the end of the second season. A lesser series would have softened Nagatoro in episode three. This one waits.
8.2 of 10.
Get the Notebook.
The day's best stories and every fresh verdict, in plain English, in your inbox by seven. One email a day, no more.