Love & Other Drugs arrived in theaters on November 24, 2010, riding a wave of Viagra jokes and two of the most bankable young stars of the moment. Edward Zwick directed and co-wrote it with Charles Randolph and Marshall Herskovitz, working from Jamie Reidy’s 2005 memoir Hard Sell: The Evolution of a Viagra Salesman. The film runs 112 minutes. It premiered at AFI Fest on November 4, 2010, and was released by 20th Century Fox. It grossed $105 million against a $30 million budget. It is a romance, a comedy and a drama, and it never settles on which one it wants to be.
Trailer, via 20th Century Studios.
Jamie Randall and the Pfizer Bag
Jake Gyllenhaal plays Jamie Randall, a Pittsburgh womanizer fired from an electronics store in 1996 after sleeping with his manager’s girlfriend. His wealthy brother Josh, played by Josh Gad, refers him for a job as a pharmaceutical sales rep. After a Pfizer training program, Jamie starts pushing Zoloft. Doctors ignore him. His regional manager Bruce, played by Oliver Platt, sees Jamie as his ticket to the Chicago market and suggests he get Dr. Stan Knight to switch from Prozac.
The film’s best stretches are these early ones. Jamie flirts with Dr. Knight’s female employees while secretly discarding Prozac samples. Hank Azaria plays Knight with a weary calm that makes Jamie’s hustle look small. The sales-floor material has a specific, grubby texture. Then the movie loses its nerve.
Maggie Murdock and the Parkinson’s Diagnosis
Anne Hathaway plays Maggie Murdock, a young woman with early onset Parkinson’s disease. Jamie learns about her while observing Dr. Knight examine her. He gets her number from one of Knight’s assistants he previously seduced. They go on a date and agree neither wants anything serious. Casual sex follows.
Hathaway is the reason to watch. She plays the disease as a fact of her life rather than a tragedy, and she refuses to let Jamie turn her into a project. When he starts talking about a real relationship, she breaks up with him. That refusal is the movie’s sharpest idea. It is also the idea the script keeps trying to soften.
Here is the comparison that matters most, and it is not flattering to the film:
| Element | What Love & Other Drugs does | What it should do |
|---|---|---|
| Jamie’s job | Uses pharma sales as a backdrop for romance | Make the sales war the actual story |
| Maggie’s illness | Motivates her independence, then fades | Stay present in every scene, including the happy ones |
| The Viagra plot | Arrives late, solves everything | Complicate the relationship instead of rescuing it |
Trey Hannigan and the Prozac Samples
Gabriel Macht plays Trey Hannigan, the top-selling Prozac rep who beats Jamie up after discovering the discarded samples. Maggie reveals Trey is an ex-boyfriend. She also passes along a rumor about a new drug for erectile dysfunction. Bruce confirms Viagra is about to hit the market. Jamie starts selling it. It is an instant success.
The Viagra turn is where the film’s ambitions collapse. The drug is a punchline, and the movie treats it like one. Jamie’s professional triumph arrives just as his personal life falls apart, which should be ironic. Instead it plays as a plot convenience. The film wants credit for noticing that selling erections and fearing commitment are the same problem. It does not do the work.
The Bus to Canada
Maggie helps senior citizens onto a bus bound for Canada to buy cheap prescription drugs. Jamie confronts her there. They argue. He refuses to leave and waits all night at a bus stop. Touched, she takes him back. The scene is well played and completely unearned. A single night of waiting does not resolve a disease that will get worse.
Jill Clayburgh plays Nancy Randall. The film was a posthumous release for Clayburgh, who died on November 5, 2010. It is dedicated to her memory. George Segal plays Dr. James Randall. Both are underused, which is a waste of two actors who could have given the family scenes some weight.
The supporting cast is deep. Oliver Platt, Hank Azaria, Josh Gad and Gabriel Macht all get moments. Judy Greer plays Cindy. Katheryn Winnick plays Lisa. Kimberly Scott plays Gail. Kate Jennings Grant plays Gina. None of them get enough to do.
What the Film Gets Right and Wrong
The tagline asks: “Addicted to one-night stands or dependent on one another?” That is the film’s whole thesis in one line, and it is a good one. Love & Other Drugs wants to argue that love is a drug, with all the dependency and withdrawal that implies. Zwick knows how to stage a romantic scene. The problem is that the movie keeps reaching for the metaphor instead of trusting its own characters.
Ranking the film’s three modes from most to least successful:
- The pharmaceutical sales satire — specific, funny, and the only part that feels observed rather than assembled.
- The romance between Jamie and Maggie — carried entirely by Gyllenhaal and Hathaway, who are better than the script.
- The Parkinson’s drama — handled with real sensitivity in individual scenes, then abandoned whenever the plot needs a lift.
The film received mixed reviews from critics. That verdict holds up. Love & Other Drugs is not a bad movie. It is a movie that keeps choosing the easier version of every scene it sets up. When Maggie says she does not want to be tied down, the film believes her for about twenty minutes. Then it decides she was wrong.
Gyllenhaal and Hathaway have real chemistry, and the film is never boring. But chemistry is not a story. The best version of Love & Other Drugs is a movie about a man who sells pharmaceutical dependence for a living and cannot admit his own. That movie is in here somewhere. What got released is a romance that uses Parkinson’s as a complication and Viagra as a third-act solution. Both deserve better.
Get the Notebook.
The day's best stories and every fresh verdict, in plain English, in your inbox by seven. One email a day, no more.
