Behind Her Eyes wants to be a slow-burn thriller. It wants to keep secrets until the final episode and build dread through quiet scenes. Instead, it becomes a show about a woman who keeps finding dead bodies, and the plot keeps tripping over its own twists.
The premise is simple. Sarah Solle is a widow whose husband died suddenly, leaving her to raise their daughter alone. She starts a new job as a teacher at a private school, where she meets Jane, a colleague whose husband David is the headmaster. As the two women bond, strange events start happening around them, and the show keeps hinting at a bigger conspiracy involving David’s past.
The problem is that the show’s setup is far more interesting than its payoff. The first three episodes spend a lot of time establishing Sarah’s grief, Jane’s loneliness, and the eerie atmosphere of the school. The performances are solid, especially Yvonne Strahovski as Sarah and Simone Kirby as Jane, both giving layered portrayals of women trying to find connection after loss. But the script keeps promising answers and then pulls them away.
Trailer, via Netflix.
The Twist That Doesn’t Land
The central twist is that David is not who he seems. The show builds toward this reveal with careful foreshadowing, but once it arrives, the explanation feels thin. It is a twist that exists to have a twist, rather than one that grows out of the characters’ actions.
The show also introduces a subplot involving a missing student named Hannah, which adds another layer of mystery. But the resolution of this thread is rushed, and it feels tacked on rather than integrated into the main story. The result is a finale that tries to tie everything together but leaves loose threads everywhere.
Sarah’s Journey, Cut Short
Strahovski carries the emotional weight of the series as Sarah, a woman whose grief has turned her life upside down. Her performance is the strongest reason to watch. Sarah’s arc moves from numbness to action, and Strahovski sells the transition without ever feeling forced.
But the show’s handling of Sarah’s character development is uneven. In the middle episodes, the writers lean heavily on flashbacks to her marriage, which are meant to explain why she acts the way she does. These scenes are well acted, but they break the forward momentum of the present-day narrative.
Jane’s Role Is Underwritten
Simone Kirby plays Jane as warm and curious, a woman who finds comfort in Sarah’s friendship. Their scenes together are the most human moments in the series, and they carry the show’s quieter stretches. But Jane’s role is underwritten. The show treats her primarily as a catalyst for Sarah’s investigation, rather than a fully realized character in her own right.
The show also introduces other teachers at the school, but they are mostly background figures. None of them get enough screen time to become memorable. This is a show about two women, and it struggles to expand beyond that core relationship.
Where It Went Wrong
The pacing is the biggest issue. The show spends too much time setting up its world and its characters, and not enough time delivering on the promise of its premise. By the time the conspiracy elements kick in, the audience has already lost patience. The show’s attempt to build suspense through withholding information backfires, turning into frustration rather than anticipation.
| Element | Strength | Weakness |
|---|---|---|
| Lead performances | Strong, particularly Yvonne Strahovski as Sarah | Over-reliance on flashbacks |
| Central mystery | Promising setup | Thin payoff |
| Supporting cast | Mostly one-note | Underdeveloped |
| Atmosphere | Effective early | Dampened by pacing issues |
| Episode | Plot Focus | Key Moment |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Introduces Sarah’s grief and the school setting | Sarah meets Jane |
| 2 | Establishes Jane’s marriage and David’s position | Flashback to David’s past |
| 3 | Introduces Hannah’s disappearance | Sarah finds a clue |
| 4 | The conspiracy begins to emerge | David’s true identity revealed |
| 5 | The finale ties everything together | Loose threads remain unresolved |
The show’s best episodes are the ones that focus on character and relationship. When it lets Sarah and Jane talk, the writing shines. But as soon as the plot demands a revelation, the show loses its grip.
Behind Her Eyes is a show with a good idea and a talented lead actress. It is also a show that mismanages its own material, burying its best moments under too much setup and too little payoff. The twist is thin, the subplots are rushed, and the supporting cast is underdeveloped.
The show’s strengths are real. Strahovski delivers a standout performance, and the show’s early atmosphere is genuinely unsettling. But the weaknesses are structural, and they undermine everything else. The pacing is uneven, the mysteries are resolved poorly, and the show never quite earns the tension it sets up.
Behind Her Eyes is a show that is better in concept than in execution. It is a worthwhile watch for those who want to see Yvonne Strahovski do strong work, but it is a frustrating one for anyone hoping for a satisfying mystery. The twist is thin, the subplots are rushed, and the show never quite earns the tension it sets up.
Get the Notebook.
The day's best stories and every fresh verdict, in plain English, in your inbox by seven. One email a day, no more.
