“Bad Apples” asks a simple question: what happens when a system fails a child, and one adult decides to fix it herself. The film follows Maria, a struggling primary school teacher whose student is injured, and she starts making questionable decisions to protect him. It is a kidnapping premise dressed in a dark comedy coat, and the coat fits.
Director Jonatan Etzler and writer Jess O’Kane keep the tone uneasy throughout. This is not a family-friendly tale. It is arthouse cinema that explores systemic educational failure through the narrow lens of one act of violence.
Saoirse Ronan plays Maria with a controlled edge that keeps the character sympathetic even as she slides toward something dangerous. Jacob Anderson plays Sam, the student at the center of the story, and his performance grounds the film’s moral weight. Sean Gilder, Robert Emms, Rakie Ayola and Kerry Howard round out the cast as Maria’s colleagues and the police investigating her actions.
“It only takes one.”
The tagline sums up the film’s thesis: one bad apple can spoil the whole bunch. The movie leans into that idea, and it is the film’s central tension.
Trailer, via Paramount Pictures UK.
Maria’s Descent
Maria’s decisions start small and grow larger. Each step she takes pushes the film further into thriller territory, and the comedy that frames the setup fades into something darker. The film does not let the audience forget the stakes, even when the jokes try to.
Etzler directs with a steady hand, letting the tension build slowly rather than rush to a climax. The pacing works in the film’s favor, giving the kidnapping premise room to breathe before it fully unfolds.
Comparing the Two Halves
| Aspect | Early Comedy | Late Thriller |
|---|---|---|
| Tone | Light, satirical | Dark, tense |
| Focus | Maria’s frustration | Sam’s danger |
| Pace | Quick, punchy | Slower, deliberate |
The film’s audience score sits at 6.964 out of 10 from 14 TMDB votes. That is a rough measure, but it points to a split reception: some viewers find the darkness compelling, others find it too heavy-handed.
This is a film that trusts its audience to sit with discomfort. It does not offer easy answers, and it does not pretend the problem Maria faces can be solved with a simple twist of the plot.
The film earns its ambition. It is a demanding watch, and it is not for everyone. Those who stick with it will find a tight, unsettling piece of cinema that refuses to look away from its own darkness.
Get the Notebook.
The day's best stories and every fresh verdict, in plain English, in your inbox by seven. One email a day, no more.
