You Were Never Really Here is a film about a man who does not exist outside his work. Joaquin Phoenix plays Joe, a hired gun who rescues missing girls for a living. He is unafraid of violence, but he is also a man of no fixed address, unable to stay in one place for too long before the pain of his past catches up. Lynne Ramsay directs, and she wrote the screenplay from the 2013 novella by Jonathan Ames. The film runs 89 minutes, and it is a tight, brutal, often hard-to-watch piece of work.
Joe’s job is simple on paper: he finds girls and brings them back. He does it with brutal methods, and he is instructed to destroy any captor who stands in his way. The film’s central thread involves a New York State Senator named Albert Votto, played by Alex Manette, who offers a large sum of money to rescue his abducted daughter, Nina, played by Ekaterina Samsonov. Joe takes the job, tracks down a brothel for wealthy patrons, and kills his way through security guards and patrons to save her.
But the mission does not go according to plan. As Joe and Nina wait for Votto’s arrival in a hotel room, the news reports that Votto has committed suicide. Police gain access to the room, kill the desk clerk, and take Nina. Joe escapes after killing an officer sent to kill him. The film then reveals that government agents have killed Joe’s handler, John McCleary, played by John Doman, and his associates, Angel and Moises. Joe returns home to find two agents have murdered his mother, played by Judith Roberts, and have been waiting for him. He kills one agent and mortally wounds the other.
In that final scene, the dying agent reveals the full conspiracy: Votto and Governor Williams, played by Alessandro Nivola, are pedophiles and child traffickers, and Nina is Williams’s favorite. The agent explains that Williams is directing the authorities to cover up the trafficking. Joe drives to a lake in a forest, fills his pockets with stones, and gives his mother a water burial. The film ends with Joe, alone, in a place where he can finally be still.
Trailer, via Prime Movies.
The Trauma Driving Joe’s Violence
Joe is a traumatized mercenary. The film opens with flashbacks of the abuse he and his mother endured from his violent father, and of his brutal past in the military and FBI. He is troubled by suicidal thoughts throughout the narrative. Ramsay uses these flashbacks to ground Joe’s violence. He is not a monster; he is a man who has been broken again and again, and he has learned to answer violence with violence as the only language he trusts.
Phoenix’s performance is the engine of the film. He carries the weight of every scene, and he never overplays the pain. His Joe is a man who is always on the verge of cracking, but he never quite does. The film is a meditation on trauma, and Phoenix’s restraint is the reason it works.
The Politics of the Film
The film is a neo-noir crime thriller, but it is also a political statement. Joe is hired by a politician to rescue his daughter, but the politician is part of the conspiracy. Votto and Williams are pedophiles and child traffickers, and the film makes no attempt to hide that fact. When Joe discovers that Nina is Williams’s favorite, the film is saying something about power and corruption. The government agents who kill McCleary, Angel, and Moises are doing their job, but their job is to protect a system that profits from the suffering of children.
The film’s politics are not subtle, but they are consistent. Every character who helps Joe is killed. Every authority figure is complicit. The film is a portrait of a world where the powerful are never held accountable, and where the only people who can fight back are the broken ones like Joe.
The Technical Craft
Ramsay’s direction is exact. The film is shot in a way that makes the world feel oppressive, with long takes that track Joe’s movements and short, jarring cuts that land with force. The sound design is often quiet, and then it explodes. The film is edited to keep the audience off balance, and it works.
The film was co-produced between the United Kingdom and France, and it premiered at the 2017 Cannes Film Festival in competition. Ramsay won the award for Best Screenplay, and Phoenix won the award for Best Actor. That recognition was deserved. Phoenix gave a performance that critics praised as one of the best of his career, and the film itself received critical acclaim for its direction and its performance.
The film was released in the UK by StudioCanal on 9 March 2018. In the US, it began a limited release in Los Angeles and New York on 6 April 2018, and a wide release on 20 April. It was distributed by Amazon Studios.
The Sound of the Film
The film’s sound design is a character in itself. There is a scene where Joe is in a hotel room with Nina, and the sound of a phone ringing is the only thing that breaks the silence. The ringing continues, and it becomes unbearable. The film is a masterclass in tension, and the sound design is a major part of that. The film also uses music sparingly, and when it does, it is often a piano score that adds to the sense of unease.
The film’s use of sound is deliberate. It is a film about a man who is always listening for something, and the sound design reflects that.
The Ending
The film’s ending is a moment of quiet. Joe buries his mother in the lake, and the stones in his pockets weigh him down. It is a water burial, and it is a release. The film has been through a great deal, and Joe has been through even more. The ending is not a triumph. It is a kind of peace.
Comparison of the Film’s Key Figures
| Character | Role | Relationship to Joe | Known For |
|---|---|---|---|
| Joe | Hired mercenary | Protagonist | Brutal methods, unafraid of violence |
| Nina Votto | Senator’s daughter | Rescued from a brothel | The senator’s favorite |
| John McCleary | Handler | Joe’s contact | Killed by government agents |
| Albert Votto | Senator | The senator who hires Joe | Committed suicide after Nina’s rescue |
| Governor Williams | Governor | The man behind the trafficking | A pedophile and child trafficker |
The Release Schedule
| Date | Event | Location |
|---|---|---|
| 9 March 2018 | UK release | StudioCanal |
| 6 April 2018 | US limited release | Los Angeles, New York |
| 20 April 2018 | US wide release | Amazon Studios |
The Verdict
You Were Never Really Here is a difficult film. It is unrelenting in its violence, and it is unflinching in its portrayal of corruption. But it is also a deeply human film. Phoenix’s performance makes Joe a character you can feel for, even when you cannot look at him. The film is a critique of a world where the powerful are never held accountable, and it is a portrait of a man who has been broken by that world.
The film does not offer an easy answer. It does not end with Joe avenging his mother or exposing the conspiracy. It ends with Joe burying his mother and disappearing into the water. It is a film about the cost of survival, and it is a film that demands to be watched closely.
The film is a masterful piece of direction and acting, and it is a hard watch. It is not for everyone, but for those who can sit with its brutality, it is a powerful experience.
Get the Notebook.
The day's best stories and every fresh verdict, in plain English, in your inbox by seven. One email a day, no more.
