ROBLOX. VIDEO GAMES. MOVIES. ORIGINAL ANIMATIONS.
CLAY TRIBUNE.
Advertisement

Freaky Friday Review: A Fortune Cookie That Holds

A close read of 2003's Freaky Friday: Lindsay Lohan's band, Jamie Lee Curtis's comic turn, and why a small dessert carries the whole premise.

By mitch·5 min read
A mother and daughter stand facing each other in a school hallway, their bodies swapped, with a whimsical and humorous expression.

The fortune cookie is the whole movie. Not the earthquake, not the body swap, not the two hours of Jamie Lee Curtis and Lindsay Lohan walking around in each other’s clothes — the cookie.

Mark Waters’ Freaky Friday understands that a premise this silly only works if the object at its center is treated as an ordinary thing. Tess and Anna Coleman are arguing at Pei-Pei’s Chinese restaurant when Pei-Pei’s mother sets two cookies on the table. The mother and daughter read their fortunes on opposite sides of a bathroom door, speak them at the same moment, and feel a quake the rest of the restaurant never notices. That’s it. No curse, no ritual, no explanation. The film moves on, and so do we.

Trailer, via Disney UK.

Advertisement

Lindsay Lohan Plays Guitar in Pink Slip

Anna is a teenage musician. She plays lead guitar in a band called Pink Slip, and the band has an audition for a spot at Wango Tango, held at the House of Blues. The audition lands on the same night as Tess’s wedding rehearsal, and Tess forbids her from going. This is the argument that gets them to the restaurant. It is also the cleanest piece of writing in Leslie Dixon and Heather Hach’s script: the conflict is not abstract. It is a date on a calendar, and only one of them can have it.

Lohan came to the role off The Parent Trap, and it fits her. Anna is not a rebel. She is a kid with a schedule and a dead father and a mother who has booked a wedding over the one night that matters to her. Lohan plays the grievance without whining, which is harder than it sounds.

Jamie Lee Curtis Wakes Up as a Teenager

Curtis was cast four days before production began. Andrew Gunn had wanted Jodie Foster, who played the daughter in the 1976 version, and she declined. Annette Bening and Michelle Trachtenberg were cast as the leads and both left over scheduling, with Bening uneasy about the script. Tom Selleck was set as Ryan and departed after Bening did. Curtis nearly turned it down herself because she was a parent.

None of that shows. Curtis as Tess-as-Anna is the performance the film is remembered for, and the Golden Globe nomination for Best Actress in a Motion Picture – Musical or Comedy was earned on the strength of it. She plays a teenager’s body language without turning it into a sketch. The scene where she sits in Anna’s classroom and realizes Mr. Bates has been targeting her daughter out of spite — he asked Tess to prom decades ago and she said no — is the film’s best argument that the swap was worth doing.

Harold Gould, Mark Harmon, and the Wedding Ryan Volvo Wants

The supporting cast does real work. Harold Gould plays Grandpa Alan, Mark Harmon plays Ryan Volvo, the fiancé Anna has not accepted. Anna’s resistance is not bratty. Her father died three years earlier, and she has not reconciled with it. Ryan is not a villain; he is a man marrying into a family that is still grieving, and Harmon plays him patiently.

Chad Michael Murray is Jake, the crush Tess disapproves of. Murray won the part on his audition with Lohan, during which he deliberately tried to make her uncomfortable in character. Jared Padalecki also read for it. Rosalind Chao plays Pei-Pei and modeled the performance on her father, who ran a Chinese restaurant in Orange County. She later answered criticism of her accent by saying it was based on his actual speech. Christina Vidal plays Maddie. Kelly Osbourne was originally cast in that role and withdrew after her mother Sharon’s cancer diagnosis.

The Body Swap Runs on Small Rules

The mechanic stays small, and that is the point. Tess goes to school as Anna and learns what her daughter’s days actually cost. Anna handles Tess’s psychiatry clients and the wedding preparations and finds them heavier than she expected. Harry’s parent-teacher conference gives Anna a composition about how much her younger brother admires her, and she decides to be kinder to him. The rule for undoing the swap, delivered by Pei-Pei, is that only selfless love toward each other will reverse it.

It is a soft rule, and the film does not pretend otherwise. There is no ticking clock beyond the wedding, no escalating cost, no third act where the magic turns dangerous. Anna and Tess simply have to stop keeping score. Waters keeps the runtime at 97 minutes and does not pad it.

What the 2003 Freaky Friday Gets Right

The movie opened August 6, 2003, from Walt Disney Pictures, on a $26 million production budget. It grossed over $160 million worldwide. A sequel, Freakier Friday, arrived in 2025 with Curtis, Lohan, Murray, and Harmon returning. That is a long tail for a fortune cookie.

Date Event
August 6, 2003 Theatrical release, Walt Disney Pictures
2025 Freakier Friday released

Here is the case against it. The film is the third adaptation of Mary Rodgers’ 1972 novel, and it does not add much to the premise beyond better acting. Mr. Bates is a cartoon. The bullying subplot with Stacey Hinkhouse goes nowhere. The final act leans on a wedding-day rush the script has not earned.

Here is the case for it, which wins. Freaky Friday uses the swap to say something specific: that a widowed mother and her teenage daughter are each carrying a load the other cannot see, and that neither will describe it out loud. Curtis and Lohan sell that without a single speech about it. The film never explains the cookie, and it is right not to. Some premises collapse under a mechanism. This one holds because the mechanism is a dessert.

The Notebook

Get the Notebook.

The day's best stories and every fresh verdict, in plain English, in your inbox by seven. One email a day, no more.

We send one note to confirm. Every issue has a one-click way out.

Film reviews
Advertisement

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

As an Amazon Associate, Clay Tribune earns from qualifying purchases.