The wolves do not chase. They wait.
That is the first thing Joe Carnahan gets right in The Grey, and it is the thing most survival pictures get wrong. The pack in this film is not a monster with a schedule. It is a territory, and the men who fall into it are trespassing. Released in the United States on January 27, 2012, The Grey runs 117 minutes and stars Liam Neeson as John Ottway, a sharpshooter stationed at a remote Alaska oil facility whose job is killing wolves before they reach the crew.
Ottway is already broken when the plane goes down. His wife, Ana, has died of a terminal illness. On his last day of work he considers suicide. Then the flight to Anchorage crashes in icy wilderness, and he is the only man aboard who knows how the animals think.
Trailer, via Universal Pictures At Home.
John Ottway and the Men Who Survive the Crash
Seven men walk away from the wreckage: Ottway, John Diaz, Jerome Talget, Pete Henrick, Todd Flannery, Jackson Burke and Dwayne Hernandez. They shelter in the broken fuselage the first night. Hernandez is killed while keeping watch.
In the morning they find the body. Ottway tells them they may be inside the territory of a wolf pack, that the animals likely feel threatened by the survivors, and that the nearby forest offers a better chance. Nobody is coming for them. They leave.
The Grey is based on the short story “Ghost Walker” by Ian MacKenzie Jeffers, who wrote the screenplay with Carnahan. Carnahan also produced and directed. The cast fills out with Dermot Mulroney, Frank Grillo, Dallas Roberts, Nonso Anozie and James Badge Dale, and the film grossed $81 million worldwide.
Flannery Falls Behind
Flannery drops to the back of the line and the wolves take him. That is the whole scene. Carnahan does not build to it or score it. A man is there, and then the snow is doing what snow does.
By nightfall the pack comes again, and the survivors light campfires to hold them off. Diaz cracks under the stress and pulls a knife on Ottway, who disarms him before it turns into something worse. Then a lone wolf charges Diaz. The group kills it, cooks it, eats it.
Ottway has a theory about that animal. He thinks it was an omega, sent by the alpha to test what the men can do. Diaz, enraged, throws the severed head back at the pack.
A Campfire Argument About God
Around the fire that night the film stops moving and starts talking, and this is where The Grey either earns its reputation or loses it. Diaz says he is an atheist. Talget says he has faith in God and talks about his daughter Mary, whose long hair only he is allowed to cut.
Ottway has his own position, and it is the film’s position: he does not believe, but he wants to. That tension is the engine under everything else. The wolves are not the subject. They are the weather that forces the subject out.
| Night | Event | Outcome |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Crash, shelter in wreckage | Hernandez killed on watch |
| 2 | Journey south begins | Flannery falls behind, killed |
| 3 | Campfires lit, pack attacks | Omega wolf killed and eaten |
| 4 | Campfire argument | Diaz declares atheism, Talget speaks of Mary |
What the Wolves Actually Represent
Nothing supernatural, and that is the restraint that makes the film work. Carnahan keeps the animals off screen for long stretches. When they arrive it is fast and ugly and the camera does not linger to admire them. The cold does more damage than the teeth.
Neeson carries it. He is playing a man with nothing left to protect, which frees him from the usual survival-movie optimism. He does not give speeches about making it home. He gives instructions, and when the instructions run out he gives the men something to believe in, whether or not he believes it himself.
The philosophical themes drew praise on release, and they are the reason The Grey is still argued about more than a decade later. A lesser film would have made the wolves into punishment. This one makes them into an argument about whether suffering means anything.
Where the Film Loses Its Footing
The middle sags. Once the premise is established — cold, wolves, walking — the film has to fill time between attacks, and it fills it with talk that does not always earn the weight it is given. Diaz’s atheism and Talget’s faith are set up as a debate, but the film never quite resolves what it wants from either man. Talget’s daughter Mary is mentioned and then the film moves on.
The dreams of Ana recur, and they are the weakest material in the picture. Neeson is good in them. The device is not. A film this committed to physical reality does not need to keep cutting away to a dead woman’s face to explain why its lead is sad. We already watched him consider suicide in the opening minutes. We got it.
There is also the question of what the ending is doing. The Grey commits hard to its final image, and that commitment is the most interesting thing about it. Whether it works is a real disagreement, not a failure of craft. Carnahan chose a hard cut over a resolution, and hard cuts are a gamble.
Liam Neeson and the Cold
The performances hold the frame. Grillo’s Diaz is all nerve and bad decisions. Mulroney’s Talget is the film’s conscience, and Roberts and Anozie give the group enough texture that the deaths land as losses rather than body counts.
What The Grey understands is that survival is mostly logistics. Fire, shelter, direction, food. Ottway’s competence is the only thing standing between seven men and the snow, and when that competence meets a pack that has been doing this far longer than he has, the film stops being a thriller and becomes something closer to a reckoning.
The Verdict on The Grey
The Grey is a good film with a great first act and a muddled middle, and its reputation has more to do with its ambition than its execution. The wolves are not the point. The point is whether a man who has already decided his life is over can find a reason to keep walking, and the film is honest enough to leave that unanswered.
It is not Carnahan’s tightest work, and the dream sequences are a genuine drag on a picture that is otherwise ruthless about cutting what it does not need. But the cold is real, the fear is real, and Neeson’s Ottway is one of the better performances of his later career.
Get the Notebook.
The day's best stories and every fresh verdict, in plain English, in your inbox by seven. One email a day, no more.
