The Bucket List: A 4.2/10 Vacation That Never Faces the Fear
Rob Reiner’s The Bucket List asks a simple question: what would two dying men do with their last months? Its answer is a road trip, financed by a billionaire, across the Great Wall of China, the Taj Mahal and the Great Pyramid of Giza. It is a comedy about terminal lung cancer, and at 97 minutes it never sits still long enough to decide how to feel about that.
Trailer, via Warner Bros. Rewind.
Two Men in One Hospital Room
The setup is efficient. Carter Chambers (Morgan Freeman) is a blue-collar automotive mechanic and a gifted amateur historian who wanted to become a history professor but had to make a choice when he was having a baby. Edward Cole (Jack Nicholson) is a four-time-divorced healthcare tycoon who owns the hospital they share.
Both are diagnosed with terminal lung cancer. They meet as roommates, not friends, and the film treats their first scenes together as a mismatch worth watching.
Carter starts writing a list of things to do before he “kicks the bucket.” When a doctor tells him he has less than a year, he throws the list away. Edward finds it the next morning, urges Carter to do everything on it, adds his own items, and offers to finance all of it.
Justin Zackham’s First Studio Film
Screenwriter Justin Zackham coined the expression. He wrote his own “List of Things to do Before I Kick the Bucket,” shortened it to “Justin’s Bucket List,” and put “get a film made at a major studio” at the top.
That item came true. The Bucket List was his first studio film, and the phrase he invented is now common usage.
The premise, then, has a real origin. The execution is where the trouble starts. The film takes two men facing death and hands them a checklist, then treats the checklist as the story rather than the fear underneath it.
Skydiving, Mustangs and Mount Everest
The itinerary is the movie. Carter and Edward skydive. They drive a vintage Shelby Mustang and a Dodge Challenger around California Speedway. They fly over the North Pole, eat dinner at Chèvre d’or, visit the Taj Mahal, ride motorcycles on the Great Wall of China, attend a lion safari in Tanzania and visit Mount Everest.
Edward’s personal valet Matthew (Sean Hayes) comes along. Edward calls him Thomas, wrongly but on purpose, and keeps doing it.
Virginia Chambers (Beverly Todd), Carter’s wife, objects to the trip. Carter goes anyway.
The film’s one substantial scene sits atop the Great Pyramid of Giza, where the two men talk about faith and family. Carter reveals he has long been feeling less in love with his wife and feels some regret for his chosen path. Edward discloses he is deeply hurt by his estrangement from his only daughter, who distanced herself after he drove away her abusive husband.
Those confessions are the movie the film could have been. Everything around them is a postcard.
What the Itinerary Costs
| Stop | What happens | What it reveals |
|---|---|---|
| California Speedway | Vintage Shelby Mustang and Dodge Challenger | Money can buy speed; nothing else follows |
| Great Wall of China | Motorcycles | A photo opportunity, not a conversation |
| Tanzania | Lion safari | Spectacle standing in for reflection |
| Great Pyramid of Giza | The two men confide about faith and family | The only scene that earns its runtime |
The table is also the problem. Four stops, one of them dramatic. The film spends its middle on movement and saves its feeling for a single conversation, then returns to movement.
Nicholson and Freeman Carry the Giza Scene
The casting is the reason the film was made and the reason it holds attention. Nicholson plays Edward as a man who has confused control with connection. Freeman plays Carter as a man who has confused duty with a life.
Both performances are better than the material. Freeman in particular carries the Giza scene without pushing it. When Carter says he feels less in love with his wife, the line lands because Freeman underplays it.
Sean Hayes has little to do as Matthew beyond absorbing the wrong name. Rob Morrow appears as Dr. Hollins. The supporting cast is functional.
A Hit the Reviews Didn’t Match
The Bucket List premiered in Hollywood on December 15, 2007. Warner Bros. Pictures opened it in limited release on December 25, 2007, then wide on January 11, 2008.
Despite receiving mixed reviews from critics, the film was chosen by the National Board of Review as one of the top ten films of 2007. It opened at No. 1 in the United States and grossed over $175.4 million worldwide against a $45 million budget.
That gap between the box office and the reviews is the whole story of this movie. Audiences wanted the fantasy: two great actors, a big trip, a tidy ending. The film gave them exactly that and asked nothing difficult in return.
The premise promises a reckoning. The film delivers a vacation. That is a fair trade for a January release and a poor one for a movie about dying.
What the Bucket List Leaves Out
The Bucket List is a buddy comedy-drama that keeps its terminal illness at arm’s length. It has two of the best actors of their generation, one genuinely moving scene on the Great Pyramid of Giza, and a supporting structure of skydives, race cars and landmarks that never adds up to a point.
Zackham coined the phrase, and the film carried it into common usage. That is telling. “Bucket list” became a way to talk about ambition. The movie that named it never found a way to talk about regret.
The National Board of Review put it among the year’s ten best. That looks generous now. The box office number looks like what it is: proof that a likable premise and two movie stars can carry almost anything.
Worth watching once for Freeman and Nicholson, and for the Giza scene. Not worth watching twice.
Get the Notebook.
The day's best stories and every fresh verdict, in plain English, in your inbox by seven. One email a day, no more.
