TaNisha Thomas lost her job at DHL in 2021 while she was pregnant. She moved between couches of family and friends, spending nights on sofas in Fort Worth, Texas. Her car broke down after her son was born, and she used public Wi-Fi because her phone service had been cut off.
Head Start saved her life, she says. “I can tell you without a shadow of a doubt that I would not be here. I would not be alive.”
Now the Trump administration wants to change how Head Start works. A proposal would shrink a 133-page list of Head Start requirements to a handful, eliminating a rule that allows centers to set aside 3% of slots for homeless and foster-care students. Under current guidelines, families can simply declare homelessness; the proposal would require proof.
The Woman Behind the Story
Thomas found help through The Center for Transforming Lives, which enrolled her son in Head Start. The program serves over 700,000 kids ages birth to 5, and more than 60,000 Head Start participants are homeless.
The proposal is open for public comment in the Federal Register until Oct. 6. Over 12,000 comments have been submitted so far.
Barbara Duffield, executive director of SchoolHouse Connection, says the change will likely result in fewer homeless students participating. “Most rural and suburban families have no documentation of homelessness,” she says.
Present guidelines let homeless students enroll without birth certificates. The proposal could bar them until paperwork arrives.
What the Proposal Would Cut
Head Start is currently funded at $12 billion through the U.S. Department of Health & Human Services (HHS). The Trump administration estimates the changes would save $2.2 billion, which it said it would reinvest in Head Start.
Centers could cut their administrative overhead spending from a maximum of 15% to a 5% cap. The administration estimates the changes would draw at least 200,000 more students into Head Start, according to its own estimates.
Alex Adams, HHS assistant secretary for family support, said in August: “We have 1,600 Head Start providers across the country… And one-size-fits-all mandates from Washington cannot fully account for the realities facing these 1,600 grantees.”
Robert F. Kennedy Jr., Health Secretary, also cited Head Start as a success during the August call.
The Costs of Proving Homelessness
Some conservatives have criticized Head Start in recent years, calling it wasteful and ineffective. The administration frames the proposal as a way to simplify rules and give local centers more flexibility.
But the change would shift the burden onto families who already lack documentation. Duffield says most rural and suburban families have no paperwork proving they are homeless.
The proposal would also require centers to prove a student is homeless rather than accepting a family’s declaration. That is a significant administrative hurdle for programs that already operate on tight budgets.
A Specialist’s Work
A Fort Worth specialist noticed Thomas’ son wasn’t speaking at age 1. She arranged a speech pathologist and dental surgery.
That kind of coordination is part of what Head Start provides. The program connects families to health care, education and social services.
What This Means for Students
The proposal could bar homeless students from enrolling until paperwork arrives. For families living on sofas and couches, that paperwork often does not exist.
Duffield’s concern is straightforward: rural and suburban families have no documentation of homelessness. Requiring proof means those families will be told no.
The administration’s own estimates suggest the changes would draw more students into Head Start. But the savings come from cutting administrative spending and weakening protections for the most vulnerable families.
Where the paper stands
The paper backs Head Start’s existing requirements as they stand and is against the Trump administration’s proposal to reduce them, which could eliminate a rule reserving spots for homeless and foster-care children. The administration’s own estimates show the changes would cut administrative spending and weaken protections for some of the most vulnerable families.
The proposal would require proof of homelessness rather than accepting a family’s declaration. That shifts the burden onto families who already lack documentation, as Barbara Duffield, executive director of SchoolHouse Connection, points out. Rural and suburban families have no paperwork proving they are homeless. Requiring proof means those families will be told no.
The paper supports smaller government and less control over people’s lives. Power that gathers in one place, an agency, an office or a party, gets abused. The paper backs whoever is pushing decisions back toward citizens and away from Washington. It is AGAINST agencies that write their own authority, mandates on private life, and any office gathering more power, whichever party holds it.
Key Facts
- Head Start serves over 700,000 kids ages birth to 5
- More than 60,000 Head Start participants are homeless
- The proposal would eliminate a rule allowing centers to set aside 3% of slots for homeless and foster-care students
- The proposal requires families to prove homelessness rather than simply declaring it
- The administration estimates the changes would save $2.2 billion and draw 200,000 more students into Head Start
- Over 12,000 comments have been submitted to the Federal Register since the proposal opened for public comment
- Head Start is funded at $12 billion through HHS
The proposal is a warning sign for families like Thomas’. The administration says it wants to make Head Start better. The evidence suggests the changes could make it harder for the students they serve.
Thomas survived. Many families will not have the same luck. The proposal is a test of whether the administration’s promises match its actions.
Get the Notebook.
The day's best stories and every fresh verdict, in plain English, in your inbox by seven. One email a day, no more.