Harmony Korine’s Spring Breakers opens on a Florida beach where bodies move in slow motion, beer funnels tip skyward, and the sun does the work of a spotlight. It is a movie about four college girls who want this week badly enough to commit a felony for it, and it never quite decides whether it is laughing at them or praying for them.
That uncertainty is the point, and it is also the problem.
Trailer, via A24.
Four Girls, One Robbery, and a Ham Sandwich
The setup is lean. Brit, Candy, and Cotty party through their campus days while their friend Faith spends her time at a religious youth group. When their classmates leave for spring break, the four stay behind because they don’t have the money to travel.
So Brit and Candy get high on cocaine, pull on ski masks, and rob a local restaurant. They carry hammers and realistic-looking squirt guns. Cotty drives the getaway car, stolen from one of their professors, and later burns it.
They tell Faith what they did. She is horrified. She keeps quiet.
That sequence is the best thing in Spring Breakers. Korine shoots the robbery like a music video that wandered into a crime scene, and the tonal whiplash is deliberate. Faith’s face when she hears the details is the film’s sharpest moral register, and the film spends the rest of its runtime taking that register apart.
St. Petersburg, Narcotics, and a Holding Cell
In St. Petersburg, Florida, the girls hit the beach parties. Alcohol, drugs, sex, the whole catalog. After one especially wild night, all four are arrested for using narcotics and spend the night in a holding cell. They are bailed out by Alien before any of it is resolved on screen.
Alien is a rapper, a drug hustler, and an arms dealer, and James Franco plays him with grills, cornrows, and a drawl that sounds like a dare. He charms Cotty, Candy, and Brit with money and swagger. Faith is deeply uncomfortable.
Alien takes the girls to a club where gang members gather. Faith grows more uneasy. He tries to seduce her, mixing menace, threats, and tenderness in the same breath. She leaves. She begs the others to come with her. They refuse, and she returns to college alone.
That exit is the film’s cleanest break. Faith walks out of the movie and out of the danger, and Korine lets her go without a lecture. It is the one decision in Spring Breakers that reads as unambiguously sane.
Alien’s Mansion and the American Dream
What remains is Alien, Brit, and Candy. Alien brings them to a strip club owned by his rival and childhood best friend, Big Arch, played by Gucci Mane. Big Arch warns Alien to stop selling drugs in his territory. It is a short scene, and in my reading it is where the movie starts to feel like it owes you a payoff.
Then Alien takes the girls to his mansion. He shows off drug money and a cache of weapons. He calls his life the American Dream, and the line lands as both a boast and a diagnosis.
Brit and Candy grab two of his guns and threaten to kill him. Alien, aroused, fellates the guns and declares he has fallen in love with the girls.
That is the movie in one image. If you find it thrilling, Spring Breakers works for you. If you find it silly, it never recovers.
What the Cast Does With It
Franco is the engine. He commits completely, and the commitment is what keeps Alien from turning into a sketch-comedy bit. Selena Gomez has the harder job as Faith, the character asked to carry the film’s early conscience, and she is the reason the first act holds together.
Vanessa Hudgens and Ashley Benson play Candy and Brit as a single unit of appetite — best friends who share a brain and a rap sheet. Rachel Korine’s Cotty is the more careful one, and that caution gives the middle stretch what little friction it has.
Gucci Mane needs one scene and takes it. Heather Morris, Ash Lendzion, and Emma Holzer appear as Faith’s friends Bess, Forest, and Heather. Jeff Jarrett plays a youth pastor, Russell Stuart appears as a DJ, and Houston sports writer John McClain turns up as a judge.
A “Beach Noir” With No Case to Solve
Korine has called Spring Breakers a “beach noir,” and the label is more accurate than most director coinages. He wrote it partly to make up for his own spring breaks. As a kid he was devoted to skateboarding and missed what he later saw as chances for hedonism.
He developed the concept over several years, with fleeting ideas about plot and what should happen. His first desire was a “sensory film” — more about feeling than action. He placed little importance on narrative, and the story came later. Once he had the backbone, he went to Florida to write the screenplay. Production began in 2012.
That origin explains the film’s shape. Spring Breakers is not built to resolve. It is built to sustain a temperature for 94 minutes, and it mostly does.
The Release, the Numbers, and the Sequel
Spring Breakers opened in the United States on March 22, 2013, distributed by A24. It was one of Korine’s first theatrical works to get a wide release. It was selected to compete for the Golden Lion at the 69th Venice International Film Festival.
It grossed $31 million worldwide against a $5 million budget and has been described as a cult classic. A sequel is in development.
Here is the release and awards timeline:
| Date | Event |
|---|---|
| 2012 | Production begins |
| 2013 | Competes for the Golden Lion, 69th Venice International Film Festival |
| March 22, 2013 | U.S. release by A24 |
| — | Sequel in development |
Where the Movie Actually Stands
The casting history is the most revealing fact about Spring Breakers. The original lead lineup was announced as Emma Roberts, Selena Gomez, and Vanessa Hudgens. Korine had deliberately gathered young actresses with a similar Hollywood reputation. Roberts dropped out over discomfort with the film’s sexual content and was replaced by Ashley Benson.
That is the whole movie in a casting note. Korine wanted performers whose public image was already half-built, then pointed a camera at them and let the audience bring the rest. The film’s provocations work only if you arrive with expectations about Selena Gomez. Strip that away and you are left with a fairly thin crime story about a man with a mansion.
Which is why the middle sags. Once Faith leaves, the movie loses its one pair of eyes that can still be shocked. What replaces her is atmosphere — neon, guns, a long stretch of mood. Atmosphere is not nothing. But it is not a third act.
The acting drew praise on release, and Franco’s performance is the reason the movie is remembered at all. The cinematography drew praise too, and it is the film’s most reliable pleasure.
So where does that leave it? Spring Breakers is a genuine artifact, a movie that got to a certain sun-bleached, neon-soaked look early. It is also a movie that mistakes provocation for argument. The robbery is electric. The mansion is a slog. The ending wants to be a fever dream and, to my eye, reads instead as a shrug.
It earns its reputation as a cult classic because cult classics are allowed to be uneven. It does not earn much more than that. Korine set out to make a sensory film, and he made one. The trouble with a sensory film is that sensation fades, and what is left is four girls, a guy with a grill, and a plot that never quite closes.
Get the Notebook.
The day's best stories and every fresh verdict, in plain English, in your inbox by seven. One email a day, no more.
