On Thursday, U.S. District Judge Christopher Cooper handed down a ruling requiring the Kennedy Center to provide 30 days’ notice before undertaking any significant alterations to the building, including demolition, after the institution was temporarily shut down due to structural worries.
Matt Floca, the executive director and chief operating officer of the Kennedy Center, ordered the building shut down suddenly, with no warning given beforehand, because of “acute risks to public safety resulting from continued structural deterioration.”.
The Safety Inspection That Triggered the Closure
To evaluate the existing safety risks in parts of the main building that show serious structural damage, the building will stay shut down for a minimum of seven days. The decision came after an examination of the roof terrace canopy and a partial collapse of the ceiling, both of which happened earlier this month.
The requirement for a 30-day notice has now made Floca’s decision followed a vote by the board on Tuesday to close the center indefinitely for repairs. The vote also authorized the temporary shutdown, which the judge’s order official.
On Wednesday, Trump argued that his work on restoring the old building should be acknowledged, stating “if we don’t do that, it’s going to close. It’ll end up being ripped down. It’s in very, very bad shape, very dangerous shape.”
Trump’s Role on the Board
Trump was named the Kennedy Center’s chairman last year by loyalists on the board. His appointment has been central to the ongoing dispute over the building’s identity and future.
The Ohio Democrat Rep. Joyce Beatty, who sits on the Kennedy Center board as an ex-officio member, took the lead in trying to stop Trump’s name from being placed on the building. She raised her objections directly during a virtual board meeting held Tuesday.
Beatty’s lawyers said in a court filing Thursday that the board members’ rationale that they are only temporarily closing the Kennedy Center is a plain pretext to justify shutting down the Center permanently. Cooper denied a request by Beatty’s legal team to hold a hearing to clarify the board’s actions and intent.
The Order’s Key Terms
The court’s ruling means Cooper has agreed to a request “to make crystal clear”, which states that his order bars demolition of the building without 30 days’ notice. That prohibition covers any major physical changes, so the board cannot just tear down the building without first alerting the public.
Congress has allocated $257 million to cover the repairs. Trump has linked those funds to his demand that the board be allowed to proceed with plans to add his name to the building.
Streisand’s Response
A Kennedy Center honoree from 2008, Barbra Streisand, raised questions about the closure of the center for repairs and criticized the controversy surrounding its operation, calling it “galling and painful to witness.”.
The Associated Press reports that Streisand issued a statement in which she said “You can easily imagine my indignation at seeing this revered institution become the subject of such a bitter struggle over one man’s name and unchecked ego.”.
She noted her deep honor at being part of the 31st annual group of Kennedy Center Honorees, adding that “for me, and for so many artists, that honor represented something larger than a career recognition. It represented a belief in the importance of art to the life of a democracy.”
The Name Fight That Started It
In August, the board of the Kennedy Center voted to add wording to the building’s exterior that references Trump’s name on the Kennedy Center’. The result is that the facade now reads “The John F. Kennedy Center for the Performing Arts Restored and Renovated By President Donald J. Trump.”.
If the Trump Kennedy Center Fund reached $100 million, another inscription would be added reading “Endowed by the Trump Kennedy Center Fund.” The plaza in front of the Kennedy Center would also have been renamed in Trump’s honor.
All of those proposals were shot down Tuesday by Cooper, who ruled that nothing could happen “without Congress’s blessing.” Cooper had previously ruled in May that the Kennedy Center illegally added Trump’s name to the building, ordering it removed.
The institution’s leaders complied in June but left a tarp and scaffolding in place where Trump’s name was once displayed. Cooper’s Thursday order reinforces that earlier ruling by barring demolition without prior notice.
Who Holds the Power Now
The board’s ability to act is now constrained. Any major change to the building’s physical structure, including demolition, requires 30 days’ notice. That means the board cannot simply decide to tear down the structure if repairs prove too costly or too difficult.
The 30-day window gives interested parties time to respond. The judge’s order does not address the underlying dispute over the building’s name. It only deals with the physical structure. Cooper’s earlier rulings have blocked the board’s attempts to rename and renovate, and his Thursday order extends that protection to the building itself.
What Happens Next
Next week’s evaluation could lead to an extension of the closure. The seven-day assessment period runs at least through that point, even though the board has voted to close the center indefinitely for repairs.
The lawyers for Beatty have described the temporary closing as a permanent move in disguise. Whether Cooper returns to the matter hinges on what the board does over the next few weeks.
The $257 million allocation from Congress remains in place. Whether the board moves forward with repairs without renaming the building is unclear.
A Comparison of Positions
| Party | Position | Key Move |
|---|---|---|
| Trump-aligned board | Wants to add Trump’s name and rename the plaza | Vote to close for repairs; Aug. name vote |
| Judge Christopher Cooper | Prohibits demolition without 30 days’ notice | Ruling issued Thursday |
| Rep. Joyce Beatty | Seeks to block Trump’s name addition | Led efforts to stop name vote; filed court challenge |
The dispute shows no signs of ending soon. Cooper’s order provides some protection against a sudden demolition, but it does not resolve the political fight over the building’s identity.
The board’s vote to close the center indefinitely for repairs, combined with the judge’s order requiring 30 days’ notice for any major physical changes, puts the institution in an unusual position. The building is closed for assessment, the board has voted to close it indefinitely, and the judge has barred demolition without prior notice.
The order issued by Cooper stands to guard the public interest from demolition. The party that upholds respect for judicial authority and public safety has secured this victory.
Where the paper stands
The paper backs the Kennedy Center’s decision to shut down the building without warning when public safety risks were acute and is against any order that would force it to give 30 days’ notice before making repairs or alterations. A sudden shutdown based on genuine risk to the public is the right call, and the judge’s order should not stand as a mandate against it.
The paper supports smaller government and less control over people’s lives, which means it opposes agencies writing their own authority and mandates on private institutions. An order that forces a cultural institution to warn 30 days ahead of necessary repairs is an expansion of authority, not a protection of it.
The dispute over the building’s name and identity is real, but it is separate from the question of whether the center can fix its roof and ceiling. The paper wants the fight settled through the board’s judgment, not through a court order that ties the hands of those charged with protecting the building.
Get the Notebook.
The day's best stories and every fresh verdict, in plain English, in your inbox by seven. One email a day, no more.