The X-Files arrived on Fox on September 10, 1993, with a simple engine: two FBI agents, one case at a time, and a disagreement that never quite resolves. Fox Mulder believes. Dana Scully does not. Chris Carter built a show around that friction, and it ran, in one form or another, until March 21, 2018. That is 218 episodes across 11 seasons, two feature films, and a cultural half-life that outlasted most of the paranormal phenomena it chased.
Trailer, via ONE Media.
Mulder, Scully, and the Case Files Nobody Wanted
The premise is spare. Mulder and Scully investigate the X-Files, the marginalized, unsolved cases the Bureau would rather bury. Mulder is a skilled criminal profiler, a conspiracy theorist, and an ardent supernaturalist who believes in extraterrestrial life. Scully is a medical doctor and a skeptic, assigned to analyze his discoveries and debunk them, returning him to mainstream work. That assignment is the joke and the heart of the show. She is sent to end his career and instead becomes the only person he trusts.
Early on, both agents become pawns in a much larger conflict. They come to trust only each other and a select few others. They find what appears to be a government agenda to hide evidence of extraterrestrial life. The show never fully resolves that agenda, and that is not a flaw. It is the point. The X-Files is a series about the gap between what an institution says and what it does, and the two people caught in that gap.
David Duchovny Nearly Talked His Way Out of the Part
The casting story is worth telling because it explains the show’s texture. Duchovny had worked in Los Angeles for three years, focused on feature films. In 1993 his manager Melanie Green handed him the pilot script. Green and Duchovny both thought it was good, so he auditioned for the lead. His audition was, by the account that survives, “terrific,” though he talked rather slowly. The casting director was positive. Carter was not convinced Duchovny was particularly intelligent. He asked the actor if he could “please” imagine himself as an FBI agent in “future” episodes.
Duchovny turned out to be one of the best-read people Carter knew. That is the whole Mulder character in one anecdote: a man who seems distractible and turns out to be the most prepared person in the room.
Gillian Anderson Was Not What the Network Wanted
The network wanted someone more established for Scully, or at least someone “taller, leggier, blonder and breastier” than the 24-year-old Anderson, a theater veteran with minor film experience. Anderson recalled reading the script and saying, “I couldn’t put the script down.” After auditions, Carter felt she was the only choice. He insisted she had the “no-nonsense integrity that the role required.”
She won the Screen Actors Guild Award in 1996 and 1997, an Emmy in 1997, and a Golden Globe in 1997. Those awards are not a proxy for quality, but they mark the moment the show stopped being a genre curiosity and became a career. Scully is the reason. Mulder is the engine; Scully is the brake, and a show with only an engine is a stunt.
Walter Skinner and the Audition That Took Three Tries
Mitch Pileggi played Walter Skinner. He had auditioned unsuccessfully for two or three other characters on The X-Files before getting the part. Being asked back for a recurring role puzzled him, until he learned why he had not been cast before: Carter could not picture Pileggi as any of those characters because the actor had been shaving his head. When Pileggi read for Skinner, he was in a grumpy mood. That reading worked.
Skinner matters more than his screen time suggests. He is the Bureau’s face, the man who signs off and looks away, and the show needs him to make the conspiracy feel bureaucratic rather than abstract. The X-Files is scariest when the threat has a desk.
What Holds Up and What Does Not
Here is where the show’s structure shows its age. The mythology episodes — the alien agenda, the syndicate, the buried evidence — are the ones that made the show a phenomenon, and they are also the ones that age worst. They promise answers and withhold them, season after season, and the withholding becomes a habit rather than a method. The standalone cases hold up better. A monster-of-the-week hour has a beginning, a middle, and an end, and the two leads get to be good at their jobs.
The revival seasons test this. Fox brought the show back for a tenth season of six episodes from January to February 2016, and after the ratings success of that run, an eleventh season of ten episodes from January to March 2018. The later episodes do not recapture the original run’s grip, and the reason is not nostalgia. It is that Mulder and Scully worked best as two people with something to prove inside an institution that had already decided against them. Once the show made them legends, the friction went soft.
The 1998 feature film and the 2008 stand-alone The X-Files: I Want to Believe sit outside the main run. The first extends the mythology; the second, released six years after the original television run ended, tries to work as a self-contained case.
Ranking the show’s strengths:
- Gillian Anderson as Dana Scully, the skeptic who gives the paranormal its only real opposition.
- The standalone case files, which deliver complete stories instead of deferred ones.
- David Duchovny as Fox Mulder, a believer played with enough irony to keep him from becoming a crank.
- Mitch Pileggi as Walter Skinner, the bureaucratic wall the agents keep hitting.
- The mythology arc, which built the show’s reputation and then spent it.
That order is the argument. The X-Files is remembered for the conspiracy, but it is watched for the partnership. The aliens gave it a hook; the two agents gave it a reason to keep going for 218 episodes.
The show’s real subject was never extraterrestrials. It was the cost of believing something the people in charge have decided is not true. Mulder pays that cost in credibility. Scully pays it in a career she was told to protect. The X-Files ran long enough to prove that premise could carry nine seasons, two films, and two revivals, and it ran long enough to show where the premise runs out.
The original nine-season run, from September 10, 1993, to May 19, 2002, remains the definitive version: 202 episodes of a show that knew exactly what it was doing with two people in a basement office. The later seasons are a bonus, not the case for watching. Start with the early standalone hours, stay for Anderson, and accept that the conspiracy will never fully pay off. That is not a bug in The X-Files. It is the shape of the thing.
Get the Notebook.
The day's best stories and every fresh verdict, in plain English, in your inbox by seven. One email a day, no more.