Saw V is a horror film about a man named Detective Mark Hoffman who is being investigated by FBI Agent Peter Strahm. The film opens with Seth Baxter waking up chained to a table beneath a pendulum blade, told he can free himself by crushing his hands between two presses. He does so, but the blade still cuts him in half as someone watches through a hole in the wall.
Strahm escapes the room he was locked in by Hoffman, only to be attacked by a figure in a pig mask and wake up with his head sealed in a box filling with water. Hoffman delivers Corbett, the kidnapped daughter of Jeff, to the police and claims they are the only survivors. Strahm survives by performing a tracheotomy with his pen and is brought out alive. Hoffman is promoted to lieutenant and credited with closing the Jigsaw case.
The film then shifts to five people trapped in a sewer: Ashley, Brit, Charles, Luba and Mallick. Their necks are locked together by cables attached to a set of blades on the wall behind them. The keys to the collars sit in individual glass boxes across the room. A videotape warns they must “do the opposite” of their instincts to survive.
Ashley fails to get her key and gets beheaded. Charles enters the second room, which is filled with explosives on a timer.
Trailer, via YouTube Movies.
The Trap That Doesn’t Work
The central puzzle in Saw V is a trap that requires a person to cut off their own hand to escape. It is meant to be the film’s signature device, but it fails on nearly every level.
The setup is simple: a trap that forces a victim to choose between cutting their own hand or being caught. The execution is not. The film spends several minutes showing the victim struggle with the decision, the blade, the pressure, the pain. None of it lands.
The problem is that the trap has been done before, and better. Previous films in the series built entire stories around a single trap. Here it feels like a homework assignment, a requirement the filmmakers clearly did not want to meet.
The payoff is worse. The film reveals the trap’s purpose at the end, and the reveal is thin. It is a twist that exists to justify the scene, not to elevate it.
Hoffman’s Fall From Grace
Costas Mandylor plays Detective Hoffman, the man Strahm believes is working with Jigsaw. Hoffman is promoted to lieutenant after the Jigsaw case closes, and Strahm becomes suspicious of him. The film is built on the tension between the two men, with Strahm digging into Hoffman’s past while Hoffman tries to keep his secrets hidden.
Tobin Bell returns as Jigsaw, whose character was killed in Saw III. He shoots new flashback scenes for the film. Betsy Russell returns as Jill, Jigsaw’s ex-wife. Scott Patterson plays Agent Strahm, the FBI investigator who drives the plot forward.
Julie Benz plays Brit, a real estate developer who is put in a Jigsaw trap. She describes her character as “very unlikeable.” The film’s marketing leaned into that, with the tagline promising “You won’t believe how it ends.”
The Sewer Tests Fail
The sewer sequence is the film’s attempt to deliver on the promise of its title. Five people are trapped together, connected by cables to a set of blades. They must find the keys to their collars, which are placed in glass boxes across the room. The videotape tells them to “do the opposite” of their instincts.
It sounds clever. It does not play out that way.
Ashley dies early, beheaded for failing to reach her key. Charles enters the second room, which is filled with explosives on a timer. The sequence drags, the tension stalls, and the finale arrives without earning it.
A Career Low Point
Saw V was released by Lionsgate Films in the United States on October 24, 2008. It grossed $118.2 million worldwide. That number does not measure quality. It measures endurance.
The film received generally negative reviews from critics. Its reputation has not improved since.
| Event | Date |
|---|---|
| Filming begins | March 17, 2008 |
| Filming ends | April 28, 2008 |
| Release date | October 24, 2008 |
The production moved to Toronto for filming. The filmmakers used a full storyboard on set, which helped actors know the correct camera angles at any given time.
The Verdict on Saw V
Saw V is a failure of ambition. It wants to be a puzzle box, a trap film, a thriller about a corrupt detective. It manages to be none of those things well.
The hand-cutting trap is a hollow imitation of earlier films. The sewer tests are a slog. The performances are adequate but unremarkable. The film’s central mystery is resolved without dignity.
It is a step down, not a step forward. It is a career low point for a franchise that once set a bar for horror filmmaking.
Saw V earns a score of 2.0 out of 10.
Get the Notebook.
The day's best stories and every fresh verdict, in plain English, in your inbox by seven. One email a day, no more.
